Originally published 2020-07-31.
In July 2020 Sudan made female genital mutilation (FGM) a crime for the first time in its modern history. Anyone who performs it now faces up to three years in prison and a fine. The change was part of a wider package of legal reforms passed by the transitional government that took over after the fall of Omar al-Bashir. The same package scrapped the death penalty for apostasy, allowed non-Muslims to drink alcohol and ended the rule that mothers needed a male guardian's permission to travel abroad with their children.
Campaigners welcomed the reforms as historic, while warning that a law on paper is only the beginning. Here is what changed, why it mattered, and what stands in the way of real progress.
What the July 2020 reforms changed
On 9 July 2020, Justice Minister Nasredeen Abdulbari announced that the head of the Sovereign Council had approved four new laws, including amendments to the Criminal Code and a Fundamental Rights and Freedoms Act. Prime Minister Abdalla Hamdok endorsed them the next day, describing them as "an important step in reforming the justice system." The main changes were:
- FGM criminalised. Performing female circumcision became an offence punishable by up to three years in prison and a fine.
- Apostasy decriminalised. Leaving Islam had carried a possible death sentence under the 1991 Criminal Act. That provision was abolished.
- Alcohol for non-Muslims. Non-Muslims were no longer to be punished for drinking alcohol, a ban imposed on everyone since 1983.
- Travel with children. Women could travel with their children without needing permission from a male guardian.
- Other rights changes. The death penalty was abolished for people under 18 and over 70, torture and forced confessions were banned, and the intelligence service lost its powers of arrest and detention.
Abdulbari said the aim was to dismantle discrimination written into law under the old regime. In the same period, Nimat Abdullah Khair became Sudan's first female chief justice.
How common FGM is in Sudan
Sudan has one of the highest FGM rates in the world. A 2014 national household survey (MICS) found that about 87% of women aged 15 to 49 had undergone some form of the practice. Most had experienced the most severe kind, infibulation, in which the outer genitals are cut and the vaginal opening is narrowed by stitching. In the same survey, mothers reported that around a third of their daughters had been cut, which suggests attitudes were slowly shifting even before the law.
Most girls are cut between the ages of five and nine. Increasingly, the procedure is done by midwives or other health workers rather than traditional cutters, a trend known as medicalisation. Health bodies such as the World Health Organization stress that this does not make it safe or acceptable.
The harms are well established. FGM can cause severe pain, bleeding, infection and, in some cases, death at the time it is done. Over the long term it is linked to chronic pain, urinary problems, difficulties in childbirth and psychological trauma. Anyone affected by these issues should talk to a doctor; specialist clinics exist in many countries.
A long history of failed bans
The 2020 law was not the first attempt. During British colonial rule, Sudan passed legislation against infibulation in 1946, but it was widely ignored. When Sharia-based law was introduced in 1983 under President Jaafar Nimeiry, even that limited ban disappeared. Later efforts, including a proposed clause in the National Child Act of 2009, were dropped after opposition from conservative religious figures.
Some states within Sudan passed their own local bans in the 2000s, and national campaigns such as the "Saleema" initiative, backed by UNICEF, tried to change the language around uncut girls, presenting them as whole and healthy rather than shameful. Those efforts laid the ground for the 2020 change.
Religion and the FGM debate
FGM predates Islam and Christianity and is practised by communities of several faiths across parts of Africa, the Middle East and Asia. It is not required by the Quran, and many Muslim scholars and religious bodies have spoken against it. In Sudan, however, some clerics argue that a milder form is religiously recommended, which is one reason earlier bans stalled.
Not everyone welcomed the 2020 package. The cleric Abdulhai Yousif called the reforms a "war against virtue," and other critics objected that the laws were passed by an unelected transitional body without a parliament or public consultation.
Why the reforms happened when they did
Omar al-Bashir ruled Sudan for three decades after seizing power in a 1989 coup. His government enforced a strict interpretation of Islamic law, including public order rules that restricted women's dress and movement. Months of street protests, in which women played a highly visible role, led the army to remove him in April 2019. A power-sharing deal between military and civilian leaders then created the Sovereign Council and Hamdok's civilian cabinet.
The transitional government wanted to show change at home and win back international support. Sudan was still on the US list of state sponsors of terrorism at the time, and its economy had never recovered from losing most of its oil revenue when South Sudan became independent in 2011. Legal reform was a relatively low-cost way to signal a new direction.
From law to practice
Human Rights Watch called the reforms a positive first step and noted that they should improve human rights "if implemented and used properly." It also urged the authorities to go further: end corporal punishment such as flogging, repeal the crime of adultery, reform family laws that discriminate against women and ratify the UN conventions against torture and on women's rights.
Enforcement was always going to be the hard part. FGM is usually carried out in private, often by relatives or trusted health workers, and families may see it as essential for a daughter's marriage prospects. Laws elsewhere in Africa show that change tends to come when legal bans are paired with community education, support from religious leaders and health workers who refuse to perform the procedure.
Sudan's own transition has since been badly shaken. A military takeover in October 2021 removed the civilian government, and in April 2023 fighting broke out between the army and the Rapid Support Forces, causing a vast humanitarian crisis. In that setting, protecting girls and enforcing the 2020 reforms has become far more difficult, but the law remains an important marker for activists working to end the practice.
Sources: Human Rights Watch: Sudan's Law Reforms Positive First Step (16 July 2020); Global Voices: Sudan's sweeping reforms usher in justice and freedom (14 July 2020); Wikipedia: Female genital mutilation in Sudan.

COMMENTS