Macron Urges EU Sanctions on Turkey Over Greek and Cypriot Waters

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published July 25, 2020.

Macron's July 2020 Call for EU Action Over Eastern Mediterranean Tensions

Emmanuel Macron greets Cypriot President Nicos Anastasiades at the Élysée Palace in Paris on July 23, 2020. Photo: Benoit Tessier/Reuters.

On July 23, 2020, French President Emmanuel Macron used a meeting with Cyprus's President Nicos Anastasiades to call for European Union sanctions against Turkey. He accused Ankara of violating the sovereignty of Greece and Cyprus through its plans to search for oil and gas in waters both countries claim, and he criticised arms flows into Libya. Turkey rejected the demand the same day. The EU did not adopt broad sanctions, but it did tighten an existing, narrowly targeted sanctions regime later that year.

Below is what Macron said, why the Eastern Mediterranean had become so tense, how Turkey answered, and what the EU actually did next.

What Macron said in Paris

Standing beside Anastasiades at the Élysée, Macron expressed France's full solidarity with Cyprus and Greece and said the maritime areas of EU member states must not be threatened. On those responsible, he was blunt, as reported by Al Jazeera: "Those who contribute must be sanctioned."

He also argued that the EU had not done enough on energy and security in the region, which he described as an arena of power struggles involving Turkey and Russia. Europe, he said, could not leave the security of its southern flank to the frontline states alone, and he announced plans to host a summit of southern EU countries in late summer. Anastasiades welcomed the initiative, saying Europe had left a void in the region and that Macron's approach offered hope that the Mediterranean would not be dominated by Turkey or any other single power.

Macron coupled the maritime dispute with Libya. Foreign powers, whoever they were, should stop breaking the United Nations arms embargo on the country, he said, adding that arms sanctions were needed to reach a ceasefire and a political settlement.

Why the Eastern Mediterranean was so tense in 2020

Large natural gas discoveries off Egypt, Israel and Cyprus over the previous decade had turned overlapping maritime claims into a contest over valuable seabed. Cyprus had licensed blocks in its exclusive economic zone to international energy companies. Turkey, which does not recognise the Republic of Cyprus and has occupied the island's north since its 1974 invasion, disputes parts of that zone and argues that Turkish Cypriots must share in any resources.

Turkey also rejects the maritime boundaries Greece claims around its islands, including Kastellorizo and Crete, arguing that islands should carry limited weight against the Turkish mainland's continental shelf. In late 2019 Ankara signed a maritime boundaries memorandum with Libya's Tripoli-based Government of National Accord that ignored Crete altogether; Greece and Cyprus called it legally void. Days before Macron spoke, Turkey announced seismic research near a Greek island in an area it claims as its own continental shelf, and the Greek navy put ships on heightened readiness.

Libya added a further layer. Turkey backed the UN-recognised government in Tripoli with weapons, drones and fighters, while Egypt, the United Arab Emirates and Russia supported eastern commander Khalifa Haftar. France denied backing Haftar but had long been suspected of sympathising with him. In June 2020 a French navy ship trying to inspect a Libya-bound cargo vessel said it had been targeted by a Turkish frigate's fire-control radar, an incident Turkey disputed and which deepened distrust between two NATO allies.

How Turkey responded

Ankara's answer was swift. Presidential spokesman İbrahim Kalın told an online briefing that Turkey favoured a fair sharing of the region's resources but would not bow to pressure: "We never accept threats or sanctions," he said, according to Hürriyet Daily News. He accused Macron of pursuing an aggressive policy in Libya that, in his view, endangered NATO's southern security.

The Turkish Foreign Ministry said the French president's remarks had no value for Turkey, urged France to stop supporting Haftar, and repeated that Turkey would defend what it considers its rights under international law while remaining open to dialogue. A spokesman for the governing AKP added that Macron should correct France's own course before lecturing others.

What the EU actually decided

A call from one head of state is not the same as an EU sanctions package. Sanctions require unanimity among member states, and several governments, notably Germany, which then held the rotating Council presidency and was trying to mediate, preferred dialogue with Ankara.

The legal tool already existed. In November 2019 the EU created a framework allowing travel bans and asset freezes on people and entities responsible for unauthorised drilling in Cyprus's waters. In February 2020 it was used for the first time against two senior officials of Turkey's state oil company, TPAO.

On July 13, 2020, EU foreign ministers asked for options for possible further measures and said technical work on additional listings would continue, while declaring that Turkey's unilateral actions in the Eastern Mediterranean had to end. Tensions peaked in August, when the Turkish survey ship Oruç Reis began work in waters claimed by Greece between Crete and Cyprus, escorted by warships. France temporarily reinforced its naval presence in support of Greece.

The ship returned to port in late November 2020. At their summit on December 10–11, EU leaders agreed to prepare additional listings under the existing Cyprus drilling framework, which had been renewed in November, but they stopped short of the broader economic sanctions France, Greece and Cyprus had pressed for. In short, Macron's July call helped keep the issue on the agenda; the outcome was limited, targeted measures rather than a sweeping package.

The wider backdrop: Turkey under Erdoğan

European frustration with Ankara in 2020 went beyond the sea. In October 2019 Turkey had launched a military offensive into north-eastern Syria against Kurdish-led forces, drawing condemnation across the EU and arms-export restrictions from several member states. At home, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan's government had concentrated power after the 2017 constitutional referendum and pursued sweeping prosecutions after the failed 2016 coup attempt.

Press freedom groups recorded the effect on journalism. The Committee to Protect Journalists ranked Turkey the world's leading jailer of journalists in several years, including 2016, when it held more media workers behind bars than any country had in a single year. In later counts China moved ahead, with Turkey still among the worst offenders. Some outlets in 2020 also circulated what were described as leaked Turkish military contingency plans involving Greece and Armenia; these were not independently verified and should be treated with caution.

Why the episode still matters

The July 2020 exchange captured a lasting dilemma for Europe: how to defend the sovereign rights of member states such as Greece and Cyprus while keeping a working relationship with a large neighbour that is also a NATO ally, a major trading partner and a key player on migration. Macron argued that credibility required consequences. Others feared escalation. The compromise of targeted listings, diplomacy and a ship that eventually went home lowered the temperature without resolving the underlying boundary disputes or the division of Cyprus, which remain open today.

For readers following the story, the useful distinction is the one between rhetoric and decisions. A leader's demand, a ministers' request for options and formally adopted Council measures are three different things, and only the last carries legal force.

Sources: Al Jazeera, "Macron slams Turkey's 'violation' of Greek, Cypriot sovereignty" (July 23, 2020); Hürriyet Daily News, "Turkey slams France's sanction threats about East Med"; S&P Global, EU foreign ministers on July 13, 2020; S&P Global, EU leaders' December 2020 decision; Wikipedia: Media freedom in Turkey. Photo: Benoit Tessier/Reuters.

COMMENTS