Originally published 2020-07-25.
On 22 July 2020, Israel's parliament took its first formal step towards outlawing so-called gay conversion therapy. In a preliminary reading, the Knesset approved a bill against the practice by 42 votes to 36. The vote did not create a ban on its own: the proposal still had to clear a committee and three further readings. Even so, it was the first time a parliament in the Middle East had backed legislation of this kind, and it opened a sharp political fight inside Israel's governing coalition.

The July 2020 vote advanced a bill; it did not yet make conversion therapy illegal. Photo credits: Reuters.
What the Knesset actually voted on
The bill was put forward by Nitzan Horowitz, leader of the left-wing Meretz party and one of six openly gay members of that Knesset, a record at the time. According to the Times of Israel, its text targeted psychotherapists and other licensed practitioners who offer to change a person's sexual orientation. It did not reach rabbis or religious counsellors who carry out similar sessions outside a clinical setting.
A preliminary reading is the very first hurdle for a private member's bill in Israel. Passing it means a majority agreed the idea deserves further work. After that, a bill goes to a committee, where it can be rewritten, before returning to the full chamber for first, second and third readings. Only after the final reading does it become law.
That is why some headlines at the time, which said Israel had "banned" conversion therapy, went further than the facts. The accurate description is that lawmakers backed the principle of a ban and sent the bill onward.
Why the vote shook the coalition
The result was surprising because of who voted for it. Israel was then governed by an uneasy unity coalition between Benjamin Netanyahu's Likud and Benny Gantz's Blue and White. Likud told its members to vote against. Blue and White, a coalition partner, backed the bill anyway, with Gantz urging his lawmakers to support it. The Labor party also broke ranks with the coalition line.
Gantz, then Defence Minister and Alternate Prime Minister, welcomed the outcome publicly. In a statement widely quoted in Israeli and international media, his line was blunt: "Conversion therapy was born in sin and its place is outside of the law and the public norm."
One Likud minister, Amir Ohana, who is openly gay, defied his party's instruction and voted in favour, while several other Likud figures stayed away from the chamber. Likud sources accused Blue and White of breaking the coalition agreement. Israeli media widely read the move as payback in a separate dispute over a proposed inquiry into Supreme Court judges.
The ultra-Orthodox backlash
The strongest anger came from the ultra-Orthodox parties. United Torah Judaism (UTJ) had tried to derail the bill and said afterwards it would stop cooperating with Blue and White. Shas responded by boycotting other votes in the plenum that day and pressing Likud to reconsider. For these parties, and for some religious conservatives outside them, homosexuality conflicts with their reading of Jewish law, and they see legislation like this as the state intruding into matters of faith.
This is not a fringe tension in Israeli politics. Religious parties have often been kingmakers in coalition talks, which gives them real leverage over social legislation. The 2020 vote showed how a single bill on a sensitive issue could test an already fragile government.
The Rafi Peretz controversy that came before
The debate had been building for a year. In July 2019, Rafi Peretz, then interim Education Minister and a former chief military rabbi, said in an interview that he supported conversion therapy and claimed to have practised it himself. Netanyahu said the remarks did not reflect government policy. Thousands of teachers signed a petition calling for Peretz to be removed, and more than a thousand people protested in Tel Aviv.
Peretz later called conversion therapy "inappropriate" but said gay people had a right to seek professional help. In a separate interview reported by the Jerusalem Post, asked about the possibility of having a gay child, he answered: "Thank God my children grew up naturally and healthily." The comments prompted hundreds of LGBTQ Israelis to share accounts of their own harmful experiences with conversion efforts.
What science says about conversion therapy
Conversion therapy covers a wide range of methods, from talk therapy and group programmes to religious counselling, all aimed at changing someone's sexual orientation or gender identity. The scientific consensus is clear that these efforts do not change sexual orientation. Studies summarised on Wikipedia's well-sourced overview find that people who went through them report higher rates of depression and substance use, and suicide attempts at roughly twice the rate of peers who did not.
Major professional bodies, including the American Psychiatric Association, warn practitioners against it. In 2020, the UN Independent Expert on sexual orientation and gender identity called for a global ban and said some of these practices may amount to torture, depending on the suffering involved.
Israel's own institutions had already moved in this direction before the bill. In 2014 the Health Ministry said conversion therapy creates a false impression of scientific validity and may cause harm. In January 2019, the Israel Medical Association barred its members from offering it. But professional rules only cover professionals, which is one reason activists pushed for a law. An earlier bill to ban the practice for minors had failed in 2016, by 37 votes to 45.
What happened next
The bill's momentum did not last. The Netanyahu-Gantz government collapsed when it failed to pass a state budget, and the Knesset dissolved on 23 December 2020, sending Israel to its fourth election in two years in March 2021. We could find no record of the 2020 bill passing its further readings before that happened, and the practice was still legal in Israel at the time of the vote, although discouraged by the Health Ministry.
Elsewhere, national bans have spread. Countries with criminal bans now include Canada, France, Germany, Malta, Mexico and Spain, while others such as Brazil and Taiwan restrict health professionals from offering it. The picture is not uniform: in March 2026 the US Supreme Court struck down state laws banning conversion therapy for licensed counsellors on free-speech grounds.
The wider context: LGBT rights and the "pinkwashing" debate
Israel decriminalised same-sex relations in 1988 and is generally considered the most open country in the Middle East on LGBT rights, a region where same-sex relations remain criminalised in many states and can carry the death penalty in some. Tel Aviv hosts one of the region's largest Pride events.
That record has its critics. Some Palestinian rights advocates accuse Israel of "pinkwashing", meaning promoting its LGBT-friendly image to deflect attention from its policies in the occupied Palestinian territories. They point, for example, to UN Security Council Resolution 2334 of December 2016, which described Israeli settlement activity as a flagrant violation of international law. Supporters of Israel reply that LGBT rights are real gains for real people and should not be dismissed as public relations.
For LGBTQ Israelis themselves, the 2020 vote was a meaningful signal even though it did not finish the job. It showed that a majority of the lawmakers present were willing to say, on the record, that efforts to "cure" sexual orientation have no place in licensed practice.
If you or someone you know has been affected by conversion efforts and is struggling, talking to a doctor or a qualified mental-health professional is a good first step.
Sources: The Times of Israel, 22 July 2020; Wikipedia: LGBTQ rights in Israel; Wikipedia: Conversion therapy; Wikipedia: 2021 Israeli legislative election; Wikipedia: UN Security Council Resolution 2334. Photo: Reuters.

COMMENTS