Originally published 2020-07-11.

On 6 July 2020, US District Judge James Boasberg ordered the Dakota Access Pipeline (DAPL) to stop pumping oil and be emptied within 30 days, while the US Army Corps of Engineers carried out a full environmental review. It was a landmark win for the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe, which had fought the pipeline since 2016. The victory proved short-lived: an appeals court froze the order a week later and overturned the shutdown in August, and oil has kept flowing ever since.
Below is what the judge decided and why, how the tribe got there, how politicians and industry reacted, and how the legal fight unfolded afterwards.
What the court ordered
The ruling built on an earlier decision. In March 2020, Boasberg had found that the Army Corps broke the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) when it approved the pipeline's crossing under Lake Oahe, a reservoir on the Missouri River just upstream of the Standing Rock reservation. The Corps, he said, had not properly dealt with serious questions about leak detection, the risk of a major spill and the impact on the tribe, so it had to prepare a full environmental impact statement.
The remaining question was whether the pipeline could keep running in the meantime. In July the judge said no. He gave operator Energy Transfer until 5 August to shut the line down and drain it, concluding that, given how serious the NEPA error was, "the flow of oil must cease." He acknowledged that the decision would cause real disruption for the company and for North Dakota's oil industry, but noted that Dakota Access had knowingly taken on much of that risk when it built the line before the legal challenges were settled.
DAPL TO BE SHUT DOWN!
— Lakota Law Project (@lakotalaw) July 6, 2020
Congrats to @Earthjustice and @StandingRockST for this significant win. https://t.co/DfW6lnHPhU
The pipeline and why Standing Rock opposed it
Dakota Access runs about 1,172 miles from the Bakken oil fields near Stanley, North Dakota, through South Dakota and Iowa to a tank farm near Patoka, Illinois. It cost about $3.78 billion and began commercial operation on 1 June 2017. Energy Transfer later expanded its capacity towards 750,000 barrels a day.
The section that drew the most opposition is the short stretch drilled beneath Lake Oahe, about half a mile from the reservation boundary. The lake is the tribe's main source of drinking water, and it also holds deep cultural meaning. The tribe argued that a spill there could poison its water supply, and that it had not been properly consulted about a route through lands and waters tied to its treaties.
Opposition grew into one of the largest Native American protest movements in modern US history. In 2016, thousands of people from hundreds of tribes and their allies camped near the construction site. Many protesters called themselves water protectors, and clashes with police and private security that autumn drew worldwide attention.
Today a federal judge shut down Dakota Access pipeline for 13 months. Joy and power to the Standing Rock Sioux Nation [and 300+ sovereign Indigenous nations in solidarity] who protested the 1172 miles of proposed $3.78b DAPL since 2014. Never yield that which is your human right. pic.twitter.com/5oTTv5u3t7
— Karishma Mehta for No Cops In Schools (@karish4va) July 6, 2020
(This post is no longer available on X.)
From Obama's pause to Trump's approval
In December 2016, the Obama administration refused to grant the easement for the Lake Oahe crossing and called for a full environmental impact statement. On his second day in office in January 2017, President Donald Trump directed agencies to speed up approval, and the Corps granted the easement weeks later. Construction finished that spring.
The tribe, represented by the environmental law group Earthjustice, kept going in court. In 2017 Boasberg found the Corps' environmental analysis inadequate but let the pipeline run while the agency redid it. The Corps then concluded that nothing needed to change, and the tribe challenged that too, leading to the March and July 2020 rulings.
Earthjustice attorney Jan Hasselman, who represented the tribe, welcomed the shutdown order, saying that after four years "justice has been served at Standing Rock." Tribal Chairman Mike Faith called it a historic day and said the pipeline should never have been built where it was.
How supporters and critics reacted
Environmental and Indigenous groups celebrated online, and many saw the decision as proof that persistent legal work could beat a project already in the ground. Activists also linked it to a wider wave of setbacks for fossil fuel infrastructure that same week, as the developers of the Atlantic Coast Pipeline abandoned their project the day before.
┏┓
— Fire Drill Fridays (@FireDrillFriday) July 6, 2020
┃┃╱╲ in
┃╱╱╲╲ this
╱╱╭╮╲╲house
▔▏┗┛▕▔ we
╱▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔╲
cheer when fossil fuel
execs cry over lost profits
╱╱┏┳┓╭╮┏┳┓ ╲╲
▔▏┗┻┛┃┃┗┻┛▕▔ https://t.co/MTEKNHwCon
The pipeline's backers were furious. North Dakota Senator Kevin Cramer, a Republican ally of President Trump, warned that a shutdown would hurt his state and US energy security and urged a quick appeal. Energy Secretary Dan Brouillette told Fox Business he was unsure what opponents were cheering, other than lost jobs. The Trump administration had made expanding domestic oil and gas a central goal, so the ruling cut against its agenda.
Energy Transfer said it would appeal and argued that the pipeline had operated safely. It estimated that fully draining the line would take around three months, far longer than the court's deadline.
What happened after the ruling
On 14 July 2020, the US Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit put a temporary hold on the shutdown order while it considered the case. Hasselman called the hold routine. On 5 August, the appeals court lifted the order to empty the pipeline, so oil continued to flow, though it left the environmental review requirement in place.
In January 2021, the D.C. Circuit agreed with the tribes that the Corps had to carry out a full environmental impact statement for the Lake Oahe crossing, and found the easement had been granted unlawfully. It still did not order the pipeline closed. In February 2022, the US Supreme Court declined to hear Dakota Access's appeal, leaving that decision standing.
The new environmental review has taken years. Through all of it, the pipeline has remained in operation, a reminder that a court can find a permit flawed without stopping the project it covers.
Why the case still matters
The Standing Rock fight changed how tribes, lawyers and activists approach energy projects. It showed that NEPA can be a powerful tool when an agency cuts corners, and that tribal concerns about water and consultation can carry legal weight. It also showed the limits: a project that is already built and running is far harder to stop than one still on paper.
For anyone following similar disputes, the key questions are usually the same. Was a full environmental impact statement done? Were affected tribes consulted in a meaningful way? And can the court order operations to pause while the problems are fixed? In the Dakota Access case, the answers to the first two went the tribe's way, but the third did not.
Sources: Earthjustice press release, 6 July 2020; E&E News, 15 July 2020; Wikipedia: Dakota Access Pipeline; Reuters; Office of Sen. Kevin Cramer. Embedded posts by Lakota Law Project, Karishma Mehta and Fire Drill Fridays.

COMMENTS