Odd Radio Circles: What Astronomers Have Learned Since 2020

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Odd Radio Circles: What Follow-up Observations Revealed

Odd radio circles, or ORCs, are huge, faint rings of radio emission that show up in radio telescope images but are invisible in ordinary light, infrared and X-rays. When Australian astronomers announced them in 2020, nobody could match them to any known kind of object. Since then, sharper radio images and new optical data have pointed to an answer: at least some ORCs appear to be vast shells of energised gas, hundreds of thousands of light years across, blown outward from a galaxy at their centre, probably by powerful galactic winds after a burst of star formation.

The story is a good example of how astronomy moves from "we have no idea" to a working explanation. Here is what was found, which ideas were ruled out, and what follow-up observations added.

What odd radio circles look like

In radio maps, an ORC is a near-perfect ring, brighter at the edge than in the middle. Each covers about one arcminute of sky, roughly a thirtieth of the width of the full Moon, and the ones found so far lie far from the band of the Milky Way, at what astronomers call high galactic latitude. That position was an early clue that they are not objects inside our own galaxy.

Distance changes everything about how big they are. Once host galaxies were identified about a billion light years away, the rings turned out to be around a million light years across, many times the diameter of the Milky Way. The radio light is thought to be synchrotron radiation, produced when fast electrons spiral around magnetic field lines.

How they were discovered

The first rings were spotted in late 2019 by Anna Kapinska while she was going through images from the pilot survey of the Evolutionary Map of the Universe (EMU) project. EMU uses CSIRO's Australian Square Kilometre Array Pathfinder (ASKAP), a set of 36 dish antennas in Western Australia designed to survey large areas of sky quickly. The project, led by Ray Norris, aims to catalogue tens of millions of radio sources and trace how galaxies have grown over cosmic time.

The team posted its paper, "Unexpected Circular Radio Objects at High Galactic Latitude", on the arXiv preprint server in June 2020, with 26 authors. It described several of the rings, including one that had been sitting unnoticed in archival data from an older radio survey taken in 2013. That mattered: an object that turns up in data from different instruments and years is very unlikely to be an imaging glitch. The paper was later published in Publications of the Astronomical Society of Australia in 2021.

Explanations that did not fit

Rings are common in astronomy, so the team first checked the familiar culprits. None matched well:

  • Supernova remnants. Expanding debris from exploded stars can form radio shells, but these sit within our galaxy, mostly close to its plane, and look different.
  • Planetary nebulae. The glowing shells puffed off by dying Sun-like stars are bright in optical light, which ORCs are not.
  • Ring galaxies and star-forming rings. These show stars and dust in optical and infrared images. ORCs do not.
  • Radio galaxy jets seen end-on. A pair of jets pointed almost straight at us might, in principle, look circular, but this did not explain the clean, edge-brightened shape and was soon considered unlikely.
  • Imaging artefacts. Ruled out by detections in more than one dataset.

The authors also floated more dramatic ideas, such as a spherical shock wave from a fast radio burst, a gamma-ray burst or a merger of neutron stars. Given how large the rings appear on the sky, any such event would have had to happen long ago. In the end the paper concluded that ORCs looked like a new class of astronomical object, and that none of the proposed mechanisms was a compelling fit. The nickname was chosen with a smile: "ORC" sounds like a creature from fantasy fiction.

MeerKAT's sharper view in 2022

The big step forward came from MeerKAT, South Africa's 64-dish radio telescope, which can produce much more detailed and sensitive images. In March 2022 Norris and colleagues published "MeerKAT uncovers the physics of an Odd Radio Circle" in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, focused on the first ring found.

The new images showed several things at once. A small blob of radio emission sits at the exact centre of the ring and coincides with a distant galaxy, which the team thinks produced it. Faint, cloudy emission fills the inside of the ring. Modelling suggested that what we see is really a three-dimensional sphere: looking through the edge of a shell, as with a soap bubble, takes your line of sight through much more material than looking through the middle, so the outline looks bright and the centre dim. Measurements of polarisation showed a magnetic field running along the edge, and curved filaments inside the ring remained unexplained.

CSIRO summarised the leading candidates as a shock wave from an explosive event in the central galaxy, a burst of star formation blasting hot gas outward, or the merger of two supermassive black holes. Both starbursts on that scale and black-hole mergers are rare, which could explain why ORCs are rare too. At that point five ORCs had been reported.

Galactic winds: the 2024 Keck result

Radio data alone cannot tell those possibilities apart, so a team led by Alison Coil at the University of California San Diego turned to optical spectroscopy. In January 2024 they reported in Nature on ORC 4, the first ring found that can be observed from the Northern Hemisphere, using an integral field spectrograph at the W. M. Keck Observatory in Hawaii.

They found an unusually large amount of bright, heated, compressed gas around the central galaxy, far more than in a typical galaxy. Its stars are about six billion years old, and a burst of star formation there appears to have ended roughly a billion years ago. In a starburst, many massive stars explode within a short time, and their combined supernovae can drive outflowing galactic winds at speeds of up to 2,000 kilometres per second.

Co-author Cassandra Lochhaas ran a simulation in which such a wind blew for 200 million years and then stopped. A forward shock kept pushing hot gas outward into a ring, while a reverse shock sent cooler gas falling back onto the galaxy, and the timescales were consistent with ORC 4's history. "I really do think this points to ORCs originating from some kind of outflowing galactic winds," Coil said.

What is settled and what is still open

It is fair to say that ORCs are no longer a complete mystery. The evidence for at least some of them points to giant spherical shocks driven by their host galaxies. It is less clear whether every ORC forms the same way: black-hole activity and mergers remain possible for others, and the strange filaments seen by MeerKAT still need explaining.

The sample is also small. By late 2025 about eight ORCs had been confirmed, with a few more candidates. Some show twin, overlapping rings. One of them, found by volunteers in the RAD@home citizen-science project using data from the European LOFAR telescope, was reported in 2025 as the most distant and powerful ORC known. As ASKAP, MeerKAT and LOFAR surveys cover more sky, astronomers expect to find more, which is the best way to test whether one explanation fits them all.

ORCs matter beyond their odd looks. Galactic winds help regulate how galaxies grow by blowing gas out and stopping new stars from forming. If ORCs are the radio footprints of those winds, they give astronomers a new way to watch that process at work, long after the starburst itself has faded.

Sources: Norris et al., Unexpected Circular Radio Objects at High Galactic Latitude (arXiv, 2020); CSIRO, March 2022: odd radio circles; UC San Diego Today, January 2024: Space oddity; Wikipedia: Odd radio circle; EMU project page.

COMMENTS