First published July 18, 2020.

The Turkish drillship Yavuz, which began drilling off north-east Cyprus in June 2019 in waters Cyprus counts as its exclusive economic zone.
In mid-July 2020, Greek Foreign Minister Nikos Dendias warned Turkey that Greece would defend its sovereign rights if Turkish ships began drilling for oil and gas in waters that Greece and Cyprus regard as their exclusive economic zones (EEZs). "There is no possibility of retreating," he said, and he urged the European Union to prepare tough economic sanctions in advance.
The warning came during a tense summer in the eastern Mediterranean. Within weeks, a Turkish survey ship escorted by warships was operating south of the Greek island of Kastellorizo, and Greek and Turkish naval vessels were shadowing each other at sea. This article explains what the dispute is about, what the legal terms mean, and how it fits into a much longer history.
What Greece said in July 2020
Dendias's comments, reported by Greek media on 16 July 2020, were unusually direct. He said Greece had nothing left to negotiate on the principle, that Turkey must respect international and maritime law, and that relations had been pushed into a dead end by what he called unacceptable acts. He added that Greece would act as its Constitution requires.
He also argued that the EU should draw up a list of harsh sanctions that would hurt the Turkish economy, so that Ankara would know the cost in advance. His core message to European partners was simple: "Greek territory is also European territory and the EU must defend its own territory."
EEZ, territorial sea and continental shelf explained
Much of the confusion in this dispute comes from legal terms that sound similar but mean different things. All three come from the 1982 UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).
- Territorial sea: up to 12 nautical miles from the coast. Here a state has full sovereignty, much as it does over land.
- Exclusive economic zone: from the edge of the territorial sea out to 200 nautical miles. A state does not own these waters, and ships of other countries may pass freely, but it has exclusive sovereign rights to explore and exploit resources such as fish, oil, gas and wind.
- Continental shelf: rights over the seabed and what lies beneath it, which can overlap with the EEZ and in some cases reach further.
So when Greece and Cyprus object to Turkish drilling, they are not claiming the open sea as land. They are saying that only they may licence drilling in their zones. Where two coastlines face each other at less than 400 nautical miles apart, as they do across most of the eastern Mediterranean, the zones have to be divided by agreement or by an international court.
Why Turkey disputes the maritime map
Turkey has not ratified UNCLOS. It argues that small islands lying close to its coast, such as Kastellorizo, which sits about two kilometres off southern Turkey, should not generate a full 200-mile EEZ, and should have only a territorial sea or a reduced zone. Most states and international practice reject that position; under UNCLOS, inhabited islands generally have the same maritime rights as the mainland.
In November 2019 Turkey signed a maritime boundary memorandum with the Tripoli-based Libyan government that drew a line across waters south of Crete. Greece, Cyprus, Egypt and the EU said the deal ignored Crete's own rights and had no legal effect on third countries. In August 2020 Greece answered with its own partial EEZ agreement with Egypt.
Turkey also backs the Turkish Cypriot administration in the north of Cyprus, which claims a share of offshore resources and has issued its own exploration licences overlapping blocks licensed by the Republic of Cyprus.
Turkish drilling off Cyprus
The Greek warning built on events off Cyprus the year before. In May 2019 the Turkish drillship Fatih arrived west of the island, and in June the Yavuz, shown above, began drilling to the north-east, both in areas Cyprus considers its EEZ. Cyprus issued arrest warrants for crew members of the ships.
The EU responded in stages. In July 2019 it suspended about $163 million in funding for Turkey, and in November 2019 EU foreign ministers approved a framework allowing travel bans and asset freezes for people and companies involved in unauthorised drilling. The United States also urged Turkey to stop.
The stakes are real. Large gas discoveries have been made in the region, including Cyprus's Aphrodite field, found in 2011, and Egypt's giant Zohr field. Whoever controls the seabed controls the licences, the revenue and the routes for future pipelines.
The summer of 2020 at sea
In July 2020 Turkey announced survey work by the research ship Oruç Reis south of Kastellorizo, then paused it amid diplomatic efforts led by Germany. On 10 August the ship resumed seismic surveying under naval escort. Greece kept its fleet on alert, and on 13 August President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan warned that any attack on the vessel would come at a high price. There were reports, never fully confirmed, of a minor collision between the Greek frigate Limnos and a Turkish warship.
The ship's movements continued on and off into the autumn, while the EU repeatedly debated sanctions. France sent ships to the region, and Germany led mediation. The episode showed how quickly a legal disagreement over the seabed can turn into a military standoff between two NATO allies.
The longer history: Cyprus and the Aegean
The maritime quarrel sits on top of older, deeper disputes. Greece and Turkey have argued for decades over airspace, territorial waters and the status of islands in the Aegean Sea.
Cyprus is the most painful chapter. The island became an independent republic in 1960. In July 1974, after a coup backed by the military junta then ruling Greece, Turkey invaded in two stages and took control of about 36 to 37 percent of the island. Around 150,000 or more Greek Cypriots were forced from their homes in the north. The UN Security Council called for the withdrawal of foreign troops, and in 1983 declared the breakaway "Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus" legally invalid. Only Turkey recognises it, and Turkish troops remain in the north today. The European Court of Human Rights has found Turkey responsible for numerous violations arising from the occupation.
In 2019, Turkey also launched a military operation into northern Syria against Kurdish-led forces, which was widely criticised by European governments. Under President Erdoğan, critics in Greece and the EU see the eastern Mediterranean policy as part of a wider, more assertive foreign policy.
What it means for readers following the dispute
When you read news about this region, it helps to ask three questions: Is the incident in a territorial sea or an EEZ? Is the activity drilling, which extracts resources, or a seismic survey, which maps them? And which agreements do the countries involved actually accept? The answers explain why the same event can be described by one side as routine research and by the other as a violation of sovereign rights.
The underlying legal position of Greece and Cyprus rests on UNCLOS, which most of the world has ratified. Lasting solutions are likely to come only from negotiated boundaries or a ruling by an international court, both of which require all sides to agree to the process.
Sources: Proto Thema (16 July 2020); Wikipedia: Cyprus–Turkey maritime zones dispute, RV MTA Oruç Reis, Exclusive economic zone, Turkish invasion of Cyprus.

COMMENTS