Trump's 2020 Section 1557 Rule on Transgender Health Care Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-06-14.

Trump’s Heathcare Reforms Allow Providers To Discriminate Against Transgender Individuals

On 12 June 2020, the Trump administration's Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) issued a final rule reinterpreting Section 1557 of the Affordable Care Act, the law's main anti-discrimination provision. The rule removed gender identity from HHS's definition of sex discrimination in health care, returning to a definition based on biological sex. Supporters said it restored the plain meaning of the law; LGBTQ groups and many doctors warned it would encourage discrimination against transgender patients. Within days the Supreme Court handed down a ruling that undercut the rule's reasoning, and in August 2020 a federal judge blocked its key changes before they could take effect.

What Section 1557 says

Section 1557 was part of the Affordable Care Act passed in 2010, often called Obamacare. It bars discrimination on the basis of race, colour, national origin, sex, age or disability in any health programme or activity that receives federal funding, as well as in programmes run by federal agencies and the ACA insurance marketplaces. HHS describes it as the first federal civil rights law to prohibit sex discrimination in health care. In practice it covers most hospitals, many doctors' practices and a large share of health insurers.

The law itself does not define "sex". That question was left to regulators and courts, which is why the meaning has changed with each administration.

It helps to separate three layers here. The statute is the text Congress passed, and only Congress can change it. Regulations are an agency's reading of that text, telling hospitals and insurers how HHS intends to enforce it. Court decisions sit above both: a judge can block a regulation that misreads the law, and people can sometimes sue directly under the statute whatever the current regulation says. The 2020 rule changed the middle layer. It did not amend the Affordable Care Act itself, which is why its effect depended so heavily on how judges later read the word "sex".

The 2016 Obama-era rule and the 2020 reversal

In 2016 the Obama administration issued regulations stating that sex discrimination under Section 1557 included discrimination based on gender identity and on termination of pregnancy. Gender identity was described as a person's internal sense of being male, female, neither or a combination. In practice, this meant a covered hospital could not refuse to treat a transgender patient, and insurers could not automatically exclude care related to gender transition.

Those provisions were challenged almost immediately. In December 2016 a federal judge in Texas, in a case brought by religious health providers and several states, blocked the gender identity and pregnancy-termination parts of the rule, and in 2019 the same court struck them down.

The 2020 rule went further. It dropped HHS's own definitions of sex and gender identity, signalling that "sex" should be read as biological sex. The director of the HHS Office for Civil Rights, Roger Severino, told NPR, "We're going back to the plain meaning of those terms, which is based on biological sex." The rule also narrowed which health insurers were covered, and removed requirements for providers to send nondiscrimination notices and translated taglines with important documents. HHS estimated these changes would save about 2.9 billion dollars over five years.

Why supporters welcomed it

The change had long been sought by religious and conservative groups, including the Christian Medical Association, the Heritage Foundation and the anti-abortion Susan B. Anthony List. Their main argument was that the 2016 rule went beyond what Congress had written, and that doctors should not be compelled to provide procedures they consider medically or morally wrong. The Christian Medical Association's Dr. Jeff Barrows said he hoped the rule would "help steer consideration of gender issues in health care back toward science and away from politics and ideology."

The administration also stressed that existing protections based on race, disability, age and national origin were not affected, and that it would continue to enforce the law within what it saw as its proper scope.

Why critics opposed it, and the timing

LGBTQ organisations, the American Civil Liberties Union, Lambda Legal and many medical groups argued that the rule would make it easier for insurers and providers to turn transgender people away, and could also affect people seeking reproductive care. They pointed out that transgender Americans already report high rates of poverty, lack of insurance and mistreatment in health settings, which can lead people to delay care.

Mari Brighe, a transgender writer from Detroit, told NPR the rule was "terrifying" and described the uncertainty patients face: "We walk into any given health care situation not knowing whether doctors are going to treat us well."

The timing drew particular anger. The rule was released during Pride Month, in the middle of the COVID-19 pandemic, which had by then killed more than 100,000 Americans, and on the fourth anniversary of the Pulse nightclub shooting in Orlando, where a gunman killed 49 people at a gay club on 12 June 2016. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi both condemned it, with Pelosi calling on the administration to abandon the plan.

Trump is doing this during pride month on the anniversary of the pulse nightclub shooting. these are not coincidences, this man is doing everything he can to remove all progress towards basic human rights for all. VOTE HIM OUT! YOUR VOICE COUNTS!!! https://t.co/Nj8UXlCzXM

— Alyson🧘🏻‍♀️ (@alysonglick_) June 13, 2020

(This post is no longer available on X.)

Bostock and the court challenges

Three days after the rule was announced, on 15 June 2020, the Supreme Court decided Bostock v. Clayton County. In a 6–3 opinion written by Justice Neil Gorsuch, the court held that firing someone for being gay or transgender is a form of sex discrimination under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. Although Bostock concerned employment, its reasoning about what discrimination "because of sex" means was directly relevant to Section 1557, which borrows from similar civil rights laws.

The Human Rights Campaign had announced on the day of the rule that it would sue, and it did so on behalf of two transgender women, Tanya Asapansa-Johnson Walker and Cecilia Gentili. On 17 August 2020, one day before the rule was due to take effect, Senior Judge Frederic Block of the federal court in the Eastern District of New York issued a preliminary injunction blocking its changes to the definitions of sex, gender identity and sex stereotyping. He relied heavily on Bostock and criticised HHS for finalising the rule without reconsidering it in light of that decision. Several other challenges were pending at the same time, and a federal judge in Washington, DC, blocked further parts of the rule a few weeks later.

What happened after 2020

The meaning of Section 1557 has continued to change with each administration. In 2021 the Biden administration announced that HHS would again treat discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity as sex discrimination, citing Bostock, and in 2024 it issued a new final rule restoring those protections. Parts of that rule were in turn blocked by federal courts in several states. After returning to office in 2025, the Trump administration again moved to define sex in federal policy as biological sex. The result is that protections can depend on the state a person lives in and on ongoing litigation.

What patients can do

For anyone worried about discrimination in health care, a few practical steps help regardless of the current rules:

  • Check your state's law. Many states have their own bans on discrimination by insurers and providers based on gender identity, which apply whatever the federal rule says.
  • Read your insurance policy. Look for explicit exclusions and ask the insurer in writing how a specific treatment is covered.
  • Keep records. Note dates, names and what was said if you are refused care.
  • File a complaint. The HHS Office for Civil Rights accepts complaints under Section 1557, and legal advocacy groups can advise on options.
  • Talk to a doctor you trust about any medical decision, and seek a second opinion if you feel you are not being treated fairly.

The 2020 rule was short-lived in its most controversial parts, but it was one chapter in a long legal argument over a simple-sounding question: what the word "sex" means in American civil rights law.

Sources: NPR, 12 June 2020: Transgender health protections reversed by Trump administration; California Health Care Foundation, 20 August 2020: Court blocks federal rule rolling back ACA protections for LGBT individuals; HHS: Section 1557 of the Affordable Care Act.

COMMENTS