Originally published 2020-06-16.

Minneapolis did not abolish its police department in 2020. After George Floyd was murdered by a city police officer on 25 May 2020, nine of the thirteen city council members publicly pledged to dismantle the department, and on 12 June the full council voted unanimously to begin a year-long process to design a new model of public safety. The idea eventually went to voters as a charter amendment, and on 2 November 2021 about 56 percent of them rejected it. The Minneapolis Police Department still exists.
Here is how that happened, what "defund" and "abolish" actually meant to the people using those words, and what changed in the city afterwards.
Pledge, resolution, ballot: three different steps
Much of the confusion in June 2020 came from treating several separate events as one. They are worth separating.
- The Powderhorn Park pledge, 7 June 2020. At a rally in south Minneapolis, nine council members, a veto-proof majority, promised to begin dismantling the police department and build a new public safety system. It was a political commitment, not a law, and its exact goals were never fully defined.
- The council resolution, 12 June 2020. The council voted unanimously to start what WCCO/CBS Minnesota described as a year of community engagement and research into a new public safety model. It did not cut the budget or disband anything on the day.
- The charter question. Because the city charter requires Minneapolis to fund a police force of a minimum size, real structural change needed voters. The Charter Commission blocked a November 2020 vote, and a revised proposal, Question 2, reached the ballot in November 2021.
The council's statement in June 2020 explained its reasoning: council members said Floyd's killing showed that years of reforms had not prevented lethal violence by some officers, especially against Black residents and people of color. That was the core argument. Not that crime would go unanswered, but that the existing model kept failing the same communities.
What "defund the police" meant to its supporters
The slogan was used in different ways, which is part of why it caused so much argument. For many supporters it meant moving money and responsibilities away from armed officers toward services that might prevent harm in the first place. Black Lives Matter co-founder Alicia Garza told NBC News that the demand was really about investing in the resources communities need.
Others went further. Organiser Mariame Kaba, in a New York Times opinion essay in June 2020, argued for eventually abolishing police departments, and was careful to add that this did not mean leaving communities exposed to violence. In her words, "We don't want to just close police departments. We want to make them unnecessary." She proposed redirecting money to health care, housing, education and jobs, and using trained community workers and restorative-justice approaches for problems that police are poorly suited to handle.
In practice, many of the ideas on the table were more modest than the slogan suggested: sending mental-health professionals to mental-health calls, moving traffic enforcement or noise complaints away from armed officers, and funding violence-prevention workers who try to stop retaliation shootings. Examples of such non-police responder programmes already existed in a few US cities, and the 2021 American Rescue Plan later offered federal money to local governments that wanted to build them.
Opposition from the mayor and the White House
Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey supported major reform but publicly opposed abolishing the department, a position that put him at odds with the council majority. Under the existing charter the mayor, not the council, controlled the police, which was one reason the council needed a charter change to act.
President Donald Trump, then running for re-election, seized on the slogan and accused Democrats of wanting to leave law-abiding citizens unprotected. On 7 June 2020 he tweeted:
Sleepy Joe Biden and the Radical Left Democrats want to “DEFUND THE POLICE”. I want great and well paid LAW ENFORCEMENT. I want LAW & ORDER!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) June 7, 2020
Polling at the time suggested the phrase itself was unpopular nationally even when some of the underlying ideas, such as shifting some funding to social services, drew more support. That gap between slogan and policy shaped the debate in Minneapolis for the next eighteen months.
Question 2 and the 2021 vote
Question 2 would have removed the police department from the city charter and replaced it with a "public-health oriented" Department of Public Safety. It would have ended the charter's minimum staffing requirement, abolished the office of police chief, and moved oversight from the mayor towards the council. The new department could still employ licensed police officers "if necessary," wording that opponents said left far too much undefined.
Supporters argued the change would give the city flexibility to send the right responder to each call. Opponents said there was no clear plan for what would replace the existing department, and concern about a rise in violent crime after 2020 weighed heavily on the campaign. On 2 November 2021, 56.2 percent of voters said no and 43.8 percent said yes, according to official results summarised on Wikipedia. NPR reported the result as a national test of the "defund" movement. Frey, who opposed the measure, was re-elected the same day.
What actually changed in Minneapolis
The pledge itself faded within months; by September 2020 some of the council members who signed it said they had backed it in spirit or that its meaning had been misunderstood. Change came in smaller steps instead:
- For 2021, the council shifted a few percent of the roughly $179 million police budget to violence prevention and non-emergency services.
- The city expanded its Office of Violence Prevention and funded mental-health responders who can attend some crisis calls instead of police.
- By the end of 2021, police funding was back at about $191 million, close to pre-2020 levels, and a court ordered the city to restore officer staffing to the charter minimum.
The criminal cases moved forward too. Derek Chauvin was convicted of murder and manslaughter in April 2021 and sentenced to 22.5 years, and later received a concurrent federal sentence for civil-rights violations. The other three officers, Tou Thao, J. Alexander Kueng and Thomas Lane, were convicted on federal charges and later convicted of, or pleaded guilty to, state charges of aiding and abetting manslaughter. In March 2021 the city agreed to pay Floyd's family $27 million to settle their civil lawsuit.
Why the Minneapolis story still matters
Minneapolis became the place where "defund the police" moved from a protest chant to a concrete ballot question, and the result was instructive on both sides. Voters rejected removing the department, but the city did keep and fund several of the alternatives that reformers had championed, especially non-police responses to mental-health crises.
For anyone trying to understand the debate, the most useful lesson is to look past the slogan and ask what a specific proposal actually does: who answers which calls, who controls the budget, and how residents will know whether the change is making them safer.
Sources: CBS Minnesota (12 June 2020): Minneapolis City Council votes unanimously to explore new model for public safety; Wikipedia: 2021 Minneapolis Question 2; NPR (2 November 2021): Minneapolis voters reject a measure to replace the city's police department; Wikipedia: Defund the police; Wikipedia: Murder of George Floyd.

COMMENTS