Michael Flor's $1.1 Million Covid Bill: Who Actually Paid It

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-06-16.

A US COVID-19 Survivor's Million-Dollar Hospital Bill in 2020

Michael Flor, a 70-year-old man from Seattle, spent 62 days at Swedish Medical Center in Issaquah, Washington, fighting Covid-19 in the spring of 2020. He came so close to death that a nurse once held up a phone so his wife and children could say goodbye. He survived, and a few weeks after going home he received a 181-page hospital statement with a total of $1,122,501.04.

The figure made headlines around the world. What most of those headlines left out is that Flor was not expected to pay it. As a Medicare patient, nearly all of the charges were covered, and his share of roughly $6,000 was likely to be waived under federal Covid relief for hospitals. His story is still worth understanding, though, because it shows how American hospital billing works and why the price of care in the United States is so much higher than in other rich countries.

What was on the $1.1 million bill

According to reporting by NBC's TODAY, following the story first told by The Seattle Times, the largest items on the statement were:

  • Isolation intensive care room: $408,912 for 42 days, which works out at about $9,736 a day.
  • Mechanical ventilator: $82,215 for 29 days, or roughly $2,835 a day.
  • Drugs, tests and procedures: the rest of the total, spread across what was reported to be around 3,000 separate itemised charges. Drugs alone reportedly made up close to a quarter of the bill.

Those numbers reflect how sick Flor was. He spent weeks sedated in intensive care, much of it on a ventilator. Long stays like his were common for severe Covid cases in 2020, before vaccines and better treatment protocols became available.

Who actually paid

A hospital statement like Flor's is a list of charges, not a bill for what anyone will actually pay. Hospitals set list prices, often called the chargemaster, that are far above what insurers settle for. Medicare, the federal programme that covers most Americans aged 65 and over, pays hospitals fixed rates that are usually a fraction of those list prices.

In Flor's case, TODAY reported that Medicare and his other insurance would cover nearly everything. His remaining out-of-pocket cost was put at about $6,000, and even that was expected to be covered by the roughly $100 billion that Congress set aside in spring 2020 to support hospitals and insurers through the pandemic. Many US insurers also announced in 2020 that they would waive patient cost-sharing for Covid hospital treatment for a period of time.

So the shocking total did not fall on a 70-year-old pensioner. The money still came from somewhere, though: taxpayers, through Medicare and the relief funds, and insurance premium payers more broadly. That is why the story became a talking point in the debate about American health costs.

Survivor's guilt and the human side

Flor was candid about how strange it felt to see the cost of keeping him alive written down. He told reporters that he felt guilty about surviving, wondering why he deserved such expensive care when so many others had died.

That kind of reaction is common after a long ICU stay. Many survivors of critical illness report anxiety, low mood, memory problems or guilt in the months that follow, sometimes grouped under the term post-intensive care syndrome. If you or someone close to you has been through something similar and is struggling, talk to a doctor; recovery after intensive care often involves the mind as well as the body.

Why US hospital care costs so much

The United States spends far more on health care than any comparable country. In 2022 health spending was about 17.8% of the US economy, against an average of around 11.5% in other high-income countries. Yet Americans have shorter lives on average: US life expectancy fell to 76.4 years in 2021, well behind countries such as Switzerland and Japan.

Researchers point to several reasons. Prices for hospital stays, drugs and specialist care are higher in the US for the same services. Administrative costs are large because many insurers, each with different rules, deal with each hospital. And unlike most developed countries, the US does not have a single universal system: coverage comes from a mix of employer plans, private policies, Medicare for older people and Medicaid for many people on low incomes. Tens of millions of people remain uninsured or underinsured, and for them a bill like Flor's could be ruinous.

It is also fair to note what the US system does well in cases like this one. Flor received weeks of advanced intensive care in a well-equipped hospital at the height of the first wave, and he lived. The debate is mostly about price and access, not about the skill of the people delivering care.

What to do if you receive a huge hospital bill

Most people will never see a seven-figure statement, but surprise medical bills are common in the US. A few practical steps help:

  • Wait for your insurer's Explanation of Benefits. Compare it with the hospital statement before paying anything. The amount you owe is usually far lower than the total charges.
  • Ask for an itemised bill. Billing errors, duplicate charges and items you never received do happen, and you have a right to see the detail.
  • Ask about financial assistance. Non-profit hospitals in the US must have a financial assistance policy, and many reduce or forgive bills for patients on modest incomes.
  • Know your protections. Since January 2022 the federal No Surprises Act protects most patients from many unexpected out-of-network bills for emergency care.
  • Negotiate. If you are uninsured or face a large balance, hospitals often agree to discounts or interest-free payment plans.

The bigger lesson from one patient's story

Flor's bill did not ruin him, and it was never meant to be paid in full by him. But it put a number on something that usually stays hidden: what a long fight with severe Covid costs a health system. For readers outside the US it is a window into a very different way of paying for care; for Americans it raised a familiar question about whether the country gets good value for what it spends.

Mostly, though, it is a survival story. A man whose family had said goodbye walked out of hospital, and he chose to talk openly about both his gratitude and his unease. That honesty is what made the story stick.

Sources: TODAY, June 2020: Man gets $1.1 million bill after surviving 62 days in hospital with coronavirus; The Seattle Times (original report, June 2020); Wikipedia: Health care in the United States.

COMMENTS