Police Who Knelt and Marched With George Floyd Protesters

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-06-02.

Police Officers Joining US Protesters in 2020

In the days after George Floyd was killed by a Minneapolis police officer on 25 May 2020, a striking image spread across American news feeds: police officers kneeling, linking arms or marching alongside the very protesters who had gathered to denounce police violence. It happened in Camden, New Jersey; in Flint Township, Michigan; in Kansas City; and in cities including Miami, New York, Washington and Ferguson, Missouri.

Those gestures were welcomed by many as a sign that some departments understood the anger. Others saw them as public relations that did not match what officers were doing elsewhere on the same streets, sometimes on the same day. Both reactions are worth understanding.

What happened in late May 2020

Floyd, a 46-year-old Black man, died after officer Derek Chauvin knelt on his neck for more than nine minutes during an arrest in Minneapolis. Bystander video of the arrest circulated within hours. Protests began in Minneapolis and spread to more than 2,000 cities and towns, and polling that summer suggested that between 15 and 26 million people in the United States took part at some point, which would make them the largest protests in the country's history.

Most demonstrations were peaceful; one analysis by the Armed Conflict Location and Event Data Project put the share at well over 90 per cent. Some nights, though, brought fires, looting, mass arrests and deaths. Against that backdrop, police leaders in several cities looked for ways to signal that they shared the public's outrage at what the video showed.

Why taking a knee carries so much meaning

Kneeling as a protest became widely known after NFL quarterback Colin Kaepernick began taking a knee during the US national anthem in 2016 to protest racial injustice and police killings of Black Americans. The gesture was fiercely debated at the time. By 2020 it had become shorthand for solidarity with the movement against police brutality.

That history is why officers kneeling drew such strong reactions. In Ferguson, Missouri, where the 2014 police killing of unarmed Black teenager Michael Brown set off months of unrest, the sight of officers kneeling with demonstrators was met with applause from the crowd. Officers in Miami, New York and Washington were also filmed making the gesture.

Camden, New Jersey: a chief on the march

Camden County's police department marched with residents on 30 May 2020, with Chief Joe Wysocki among them. Officers carried a banner declaring that they stood in solidarity, and some were heard joining the familiar protest chant no justice, no peace.

Camden's participation drew particular attention because of the city's recent history. In 2013 the city's own police force was disbanded and replaced by a new county department. That department later adopted a use-of-force policy, drafted with help from New York University's Policing Project, which experts quoted by the Washington Post in 2019 called one of the most progressive in the country, and it reported a steep fall in excessive-force complaints. Commentators argued that Camden's march carried more weight because it came from a force that had already changed its rules, not one making a gesture for the first time.

Wysocki was blunt about the Minneapolis footage. Speaking to local reporters he said, "I think we watched a murder unfold on video." Chauvin was later convicted of murder in April 2021 and sentenced to 22 and a half years in prison; the three other officers present were also convicted of state or federal offences.

Flint Township and other departments

In Flint Township, Michigan, Genesee County Sheriff Chris Swanson reportedly removed his helmet, put down his baton and spoke with protesters before walking with them. Video of the moment, in which he was reported to tell the crowd that the officers there loved them, was widely shared and became one of the defining images of that weekend.

Amazing scene unfolding in Flint, Twp, Michigan. Genesee County Sheriff Chris Swanson has joined protesters in a peaceful march. Read More: https://t.co/4ioyUnymNv @MichStatePolice @GovWhitmer pic.twitter.com/nMCVuXQ0TZ

— Mid-Michigan NOW (@midmichigannow) May 31, 2020

(This post is no longer available on X.)

Other police leaders used words rather than marches. Phoenix Police Chief Jeri Williams said publicly that she was "absolutely outraged with what I saw" in the Minneapolis video, a view echoed by chiefs and sheriffs in many cities. Statements from police leaders openly condemning another officer's conduct were unusual at that scale.

Kansas City: one photo, two readings

Not every gesture was received warmly. In Kansas City, Missouri, a photograph of two officers, one white and one Black, holding a sign calling for an end to police brutality was shared thousands of times.

Some local residents pushed back. Local resident Erica Batton replied that police had been threatening protesters with pepper spray in the previous days, pointed to a viral video of an officer drawing a gun on a Black driver during a minor traffic stop, and described the photo as a nice image but only a snapshot. Her post is no longer online, but its message summed up a widespread suspicion that symbolic gestures were being used to soften coverage.

I want to point out that they’ve been threatening protesters w/ pepper spray for the last 2 days here. A video went viral of a KC cop coming up to a black man’s car w/ his gun drawn for not using a turn signal a few days ago.
This is a nice pic but just a snapshot.

— Erica Batton (@ericadrawsstuff) May 30, 2020

(This post is no longer available on X.)

Later in the protests, Kansas City police dispersed crowds using tear gas, pepper spray, projectiles and batons, which many demonstrators saw as confirming their doubts.

The other side of the picture

For every image of officers kneeling, there were others showing rubber bullets, tear gas, journalists injured and protesters pushed to the ground. In New York's Union Square, a video posted on 31 May 2020 appeared to show an officer making a hand sign that the poster interpreted as a white-power gesture. The post has since been removed, and the meaning of such hand signs is often contested, but the clip fuelled anger about whether departments were policing themselves.

NYPD officer throws up a white power sign in Union Square. 🤮Hey @NYPDnews @NYPDShea, come get ya boy. #BlackLivesMatter pic.twitter.com/CZrb9nzFEM

— Chad Loder (@chadloder) May 31, 2020

(This post is no longer available on X.)

Researchers and activists made a broader point: a single march does not change training, use-of-force rules, accountability systems or who gets stopped and searched. That is where trust is built or lost over years, not in one afternoon.

What the gestures did and did not change

Looking back, the kneeling officers of 2020 are best understood as a sign of how deeply the Minneapolis video shook even people inside policing. Their gestures helped calm some tense moments and showed protesters that not every officer saw them as an enemy.

Yet the communities that marched were asking for more than symbolism. Cities such as Camden show that lasting change tends to come from policy, oversight and day-to-day conduct. Whether a gesture of solidarity meant something is ultimately judged by what a department does long after the cameras have gone.

Sources: Wikipedia: Murder of George Floyd; Wikipedia: George Floyd protests; Wikipedia: Camden County Police Department; TAPinto: Camden chief addresses George Floyd's death; embedded posts by Camden County Police, CBS News, Mid-Michigan NOW, Dylan (@dyllyp), Erica Batton and Chad Loder on X.

COMMENTS