Australia's Mandatory Minimum Sentences for Child Sex Offences

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-06-14.

Australia's 2020 Child-Sex-Offence Sentencing Changes

Then Prime Minister Scott Morrison and then Opposition Leader Anthony Albanese in Australia's federal parliament.

In June 2020 Australia's federal parliament passed a law that introduced mandatory minimum prison sentences for the most serious Commonwealth child sex offences and for repeat offenders. The Crimes Legislation Amendment (Sexual Crimes Against Children and Community Protection Measures) Act 2020 received Royal Assent on 22 June 2020, and its sentencing changes took effect the next day.

Headlines at the time claimed that every "paedophile" in Australia would now face life in prison. That was never what the law said. It applies only to federal offences, which mostly cover online abuse, child abuse material and offences committed overseas, and it sets minimum terms rather than automatic life sentences. Here is what changed, why the government acted, and the debate around mandatory sentencing.

What the 2020 law changed

The Act amended the Crimes Act 1914 and the Criminal Code. Its main sentencing measures were:

  • Minimum terms for the gravest federal offences. A new section 16AAA of the Crimes Act lists offences for which courts must impose at least five, six or seven years in prison, depending on the offence (text of the Act). These include sexual offences against children committed overseas and some of the most serious online and child abuse material offences.
  • Minimum terms for repeat offenders. Under section 16AAB, a person convicted of a Commonwealth child sexual abuse offence who already has a previous conviction for child sexual abuse faces a minimum of between one and four years, depending on the new offence.
  • A presumption against bail for the most serious federal child sex offences, and for repeat offenders.
  • A presumption in favour of cumulative sentences, so that terms for multiple offences are generally served one after another.
  • New offences, including running websites that distribute child abuse material and subjecting a child outside Australia to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment.
  • Protection for child witnesses, who can no longer be cross-examined at committal hearings.

Life imprisonment became available as the maximum for the very worst offences, but it is a ceiling that judges can reach, not a standard penalty.

Federal versus state offences

Australia's criminal law is split. Most child sexual abuse that happens within the country, for example abuse by a family member or someone in a position of trust, is prosecuted under state and territory law. Those cases were not affected by the 2020 Act.

Federal law covers areas the Commonwealth controls: the internet and telecommunications, the postal service, imports, and offences by Australians abroad. That is why the government framed the bill as a response to online predators and child sex tourism. As the Macleay Argus reported at the time, states handle most child sex offences, so the federal changes aimed squarely at online and overseas offending.

Why the government acted

Attorney-General Christian Porter argued that sentences for federal child sex offenders had been far too light. He said a large share of people sentenced for these offences in 2019 spent no time in prison (he put it at nearly a third in one statement, and close to 40 per cent according to AAP), and that those who were jailed often received short terms; figures quoted at the time put the average at around 18 months. In a statement he said it "simply beggars belief" that so many offenders avoided custody.

Home Affairs Minister Peter Dutton linked the bill to rising detection of online abuse by the Australian Federal Police and the financial intelligence agency AUSTRAC. He told parliament that serious penalties were needed, "not simply a slap on the wrist which is often the case." He also cited a recent police operation in which 14 children had been rescued from abuse.

Safeguards built into the law

The mandatory minimums are not completely rigid. Under section 16AAC:

  • They do not apply to anyone who was under 18 when the offence was committed, which addresses concerns about teenagers caught up in "sexting" cases.
  • A court may go below the minimum by up to 25 per cent to reflect an early guilty plea, and by up to 25 per cent for cooperation with law enforcement, or up to 50 per cent where both apply.

The Act also requires courts to consider rehabilitation, including whether a sentence is long enough for an offender to complete treatment programmes in custody. The law also required a statutory review of how the new sentencing provisions were working.

Political support and the debate over mandatory sentencing

The bill had broad public support and was not blocked by the opposition. Labor, under Anthony Albanese, expressed reservations about mandatory minimums and proposed amendments, but said it would not stand in the way of measures to protect children.

That reservation reflects a long-running argument among lawyers and criminologists. Mandatory sentencing is less common in Australia and other Commonwealth countries than in the United States, where minimum terms are widely used.

Arguments in favour

  • It sends a clear, public signal about how seriously society views certain crimes.
  • It reduces inconsistency between judges and prevents very lenient outcomes.
  • It keeps dangerous offenders in custody for longer, which protects children during that time.

Arguments against

  • Research on deterrence generally finds that the certainty of being caught matters more than the length of the sentence.
  • Minimums can produce unjust results in unusual cases, because judges cannot fully weigh the circumstances.
  • They may discourage guilty pleas, forcing more child victims to give evidence at trial, which is one reason the plea discount was included.

What this means in practice

For people working to protect children, the 2020 Act mattered most in the online space, where federal police investigate abuse material, grooming and live-streamed abuse. Tougher bail rules mean that people charged with the most serious offences are more likely to stay in custody while awaiting trial.

Parents and carers can help by talking with children about online safety, keeping devices in shared spaces for younger children, and knowing how to report concerns. In Australia, online child sexual exploitation can be reported to the Australian Centre to Counter Child Exploitation (ACCCE), and anyone in immediate danger should call 000.

Other countries have tried different approaches to sentencing sex offenders, from Alabama's chemical castration law to Thailand's voluntary programme. Australia chose longer minimum prison terms, combined with a requirement that courts still think about rehabilitation.

Sources: Federal Register of Legislation: Crimes Legislation Amendment (Sexual Crimes Against Children and Community Protection Measures) Act 2020; Proctor (Queensland Law Society), September 2020; Macleay Argus (AAP), 11 June 2020: Anti-abuse laws set to pass parliament; Daily Mail Australia, June 2020.

COMMENTS