Originally published 2020-05-10.
https://www.facebook.com/PapaFranciscoPontifex/posts/3133734529991012:0
Alma Clara Corsini was 95 when she caught COVID-19 in the first, frightening weeks of Italy's epidemic. She was admitted to the hospital in Pavullo nel Frignano, in the hills of Modena province, on 5 March 2020, recovered without antiviral drugs and went home to her village of Fanano. When her story was reported around 21 to 22 March, she was described as the oldest woman in Italy known to have recovered from the disease.
Her case travelled around the world because it arrived at a dark moment. On the same weekend, Italy was counting hundreds of deaths a day and had just overtaken China as the country with the most recorded COVID-19 deaths.
Who Alma Clara Corsini is and what happened to her
Corsini came from Fanano, a small town in the Apennine mountains south of Modena. She arrived at the Pavullo hospital with symptoms of the new coronavirus in early March, just as the outbreak that began in Lombardy and Veneto in late February was spreading across northern Italy.
The local paper, the Gazzetta di Modena, reported on 18 March that she had recovered. According to that report, she did not need antiviral therapy, and doctors noted that her body had reacted strongly to the infection. She was also the first person in the province of Modena to be declared recovered.
Asked how she felt, she was characteristically brief. She told reporters the staff "were good people who looked after me well." A photograph showing her in a hospital bed, giving a thumbs-up with members of the team that treated her, was shared widely, including by Fabio Massimo Castaldo, a vice-president of the European Parliament, on 21 March.
Was she really the first or the oldest to recover?
Some early headlines, including this site's original web address, mixed up details, so it is worth being precise.
- Age: Corsini was 95. The figure of 97 that appeared in some posts belongs to a different patient, a 97-year-old man who had recovered earlier and was then believed to be the oldest person in Italy to do so.
- "First" patient: She was not the first person in Italy to recover. She was reported as the oldest woman to recover, and the first recovered patient in Modena province.
- The Pope's words: A message praising her, signed with Pope Francis's name, circulated on a Facebook page. Pope Francis does not have an official Facebook account (his official social channels are the @Pontifex accounts on X and Instagram), so the quote should be treated as unconfirmed rather than as a Vatican statement.
None of this takes away from the story. A woman in her mid-nineties survived an infection that killed many people her age, at a time when hospitals around her were overwhelmed.
Italy in March 2020: the backdrop to her recovery
Italy was the first European country hit hard by COVID-19. Clusters were identified in Lombardy and Veneto on 21 February 2020, and the first deaths followed the next day. By 4 March the country had recorded 100 deaths and closed all schools and universities.
The response then escalated quickly. On 8 March the government placed Lombardy and 14 other northern provinces under quarantine, and on 9 March Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte extended the lockdown to the whole country, affecting about 60 million people. Leaving home required a valid reason, such as work, health or buying food.
Deaths kept climbing. On 19 March, the same day army trucks were sent to Bergamo to carry coffins the city could no longer handle, Italy's recorded death toll passed China's. On Sunday 22 March, Italian authorities reported 651 new deaths, bringing the total to about 5,400. A few days later, when the international press carried Corsini's story, Italy had 74,386 confirmed cases and 7,503 deaths, more than double China's official toll.
The people dying were overwhelmingly elderly. Italian public health data at the time put the average age of those who died at close to 79, and most had one or more existing illnesses. That is exactly why a recovery at 95 felt so remarkable.
Why some older people survived COVID-19
Age was the single strongest risk factor for dying of COVID-19 in 2020, but it was never a death sentence. Many people in their eighties and nineties recovered, sometimes after mild illness. Doctors pointed to several factors that shape the outcome:
- Underlying health. Heart disease, diabetes, lung disease, kidney disease and obesity raised the risk sharply. An older person in otherwise good health often did better than a younger person with several conditions.
- The immune response. Severe COVID-19 is partly driven by an excessive inflammatory reaction. Some patients mount an effective response without tipping into that dangerous phase.
- Timely care. Good nursing, oxygen when needed and close monitoring all mattered, and were harder to provide when hospitals were overloaded.
- Chance. The dose of virus, the timing of care and individual biology still made outcomes hard to predict.
Since 2020, vaccines and better treatments have greatly reduced the risk for older people, though they still face the highest risk of serious illness from COVID-19 and other respiratory infections. Anyone with questions about their own risk, vaccines or treatment should talk to a doctor.
Why stories like hers mattered
In late March 2020, Italian news was dominated by numbers: daily deaths, intensive care beds, positive tests. Stories of individual recoveries gave people something else to hold on to. Corsini's case, along with those of other very old survivors around the world, showed that the illness could be beaten even at the far end of life.
Her story was also a reminder of the work of local hospitals far from the big headlines. Pavullo nel Frignano is a small hospital serving mountain communities, and its staff were coping with the same pressures as larger centres in Lombardy and Emilia-Romagna.
At the same time, one recovery does not mean the disease was harmless for older people. The same week Corsini went home, care homes across northern Italy were losing many residents, and families were unable to visit or hold funerals. Both things were true at once.
The short version
- Alma Clara Corsini, 95, from Fanano, was admitted to hospital in Pavullo nel Frignano on 5 March 2020 with COVID-19.
- She recovered without antivirals and returned home; she was reported as Italy's oldest woman known to have recovered at that point.
- Her recovery was reported as Italy's death toll overtook China's, during the national lockdown that began on 9 March 2020.
- A Facebook post attributed to Pope Francis praising her could not be confirmed as coming from the Pope.
Sources: Inquirer.net (AFP/Metro): 95-year-old grandmother is oldest woman to recover from COVID-19 in Italy; Gazzetta di Modena (18 March 2020); Wikipedia: COVID-19 pandemic in Italy; photo shared via Facebook.
COMMENTS