Malaysian Wife Who Found a Second Wife for Her Husband

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-11-08.

One Malaysian Family's Account of Plural Marriage and Caregiving

In 2019, a family from Shah Alam, Malaysia, drew international attention after a pregnant wife, Khuzatul Atiqah, found and proposed a second wife for her husband, Samuel Dzul. Struggling with a difficult fifth pregnancy and at times using a wheelchair, she worried about how her husband would cope with work, housework and four young children. Her answer was to invite a friend, single mother Nur Fathonah, to join the family through marriage.

The story was widely shared as a curiosity, often with mocking or outraged headlines. Looked at more calmly, it raises real questions about caregiving, women's choices and how polygamy works under Malaysian law. Here is what the family described, what the law actually says, and why the practice remains debated.

How the arrangement came about

Khuzatul and Samuel married in 2011. According to Malaysian reports summarised by The Independent Singapore, she became unwell during her fifth pregnancy and found moving around increasingly hard. Samuel came home tired from his job yet still took on housework and childcare, and she began to fear what would happen to him and the children if her health got worse.

One Malaysian Family's Account of Plural Marriage and Caregiving

A family photo shared on Khuzatul's Facebook account, where she posts as TiQa Ummimerahjambu, shows Samuel with one of his wives. The couple had been married for about eight years when their story became public, and they have four children together with a fifth on the way at the time.

In 2018 she got to know Nur Fathonah on social media, and the two became close friends. Khuzatul eventually asked her whether she would consider becoming Samuel's second wife. Fathonah hesitated at first, but accepted an invitation to break the fast with the family. She found a warm household and felt at ease with everyone, and she agreed. The marriage took place in a simple ceremony.

A household of three adults

One Malaysian Family's Account of Plural Marriage and Caregiving

The two wives with Samuel between them in a close-up selfie. Malaysian coverage described the women as being like sisters and best friends, a contrast to the rivalry many people assume such arrangements involve.

One Malaysian Family's Account of Plural Marriage and Caregiving

The same three adults in an evening photo shared on Samuel Dzul's Facebook page. According to the reports, the three of them also opened and run a recording studio together in Shah Alam.

Khuzatul had once rejected polygamy outright. She later explained on Facebook that her view changed after watching her father-in-law live peacefully with his three wives. That post is no longer online.

(The Facebook post originally embedded here is no longer available.)

One Malaysian Family's Account of Plural Marriage and Caregiving

A wedding-day photo shared by Nur Fathonah Abdul Rahim: the bride in white and grey, Samuel in a black songkok, a small child in an orange headscarf and a guest in pale blue beside them. The simple ceremony matches how the family described the marriage in Malaysian media.

What Malaysian law says about polygamy

Malaysia has two marriage systems. For non-Muslims, the Law Reform (Marriage and Divorce) Act 1976 allows only monogamous marriage; any further marriage is unlawful. For Muslims, state Islamic family laws permit polygyny, meaning a man may have up to four wives at the same time.

That permission is not automatic. In Selangor, where Shah Alam is located, Section 23 of the Islamic Family Law Enactment 2003 requires a husband to obtain written permission from the state Syariah Court before marrying again. The court considers whether he can support all his wives and dependants and treat them fairly, and whether the new marriage would cause harm to the existing wife. Scholar Nurul Huda Mohd. Razif has noted that these financial tests tend to favour wealthier men, and that some couples bypass them by marrying across the border in southern Thailand, which is an offence under Malaysian Syariah law.

Why the practice is debated

Supporters point to religious permission and to cases where families say the arrangement works for everyone, as this one reportedly does. Critics, including many Muslim women's rights advocates, argue that polygyny often leaves wives and children financially and emotionally exposed. Mohd. Razif's research describes cases of husbands failing to pay maintenance, competition between co-wives, and limited state enforcement, and links the system to patriarchal interests at the expense of women and children.

Both things can be true at once. A single family describing harmony does not settle the wider question, and the existence of harmful cases does not mean every adult in a plural marriage was coerced. What matters most is whether each person has a real, informed choice and whether the law protects those who end up worse off.

The caregiving question behind the headlines

Strip away the novelty and the core of this story is familiar: a mother in poor health worrying about who will look after her family. Many households in that situation turn to relatives, paid help or community support. Khuzatul chose a route that is legal for her family's faith and that she says she came to see positively.

For readers, the useful takeaway is less about polygamy than about support. Pregnancies that bring serious mobility problems or other complications deserve proper medical care, so anyone in a similar position should talk to a doctor early. Families also benefit from having a plan for childcare and housework before a crisis hits, whether that means sharing tasks more evenly, asking relatives for help or finding local services.

Reading stories like this fairly

Viral posts about other cultures often lean on shock. A fairer approach is to let the people involved describe their own lives, check the legal facts, and keep one family's experience separate from claims about all Malaysians or all Muslims. This family's account is one of choice and friendship; the debate about polygamy's wider effects on women is real and ongoing. Holding both in view gives a more honest picture than either outrage or applause.

Sources: Photos from the Facebook accounts of TiQa Ummimerahjambu (Khuzatul Atiqah), Samuel Dzul and Nur Fathonah Abdul Rahim, credited above. The Independent Singapore (30 July 2019), drawing on The Reporter and mStar; Wikipedia: Polygamy in Malaysia; Nurul Huda Mohd. Razif, Woolf Institute: The changing face of polygamy in contemporary Malaysia.

COMMENTS