Wrong Reasons to Get Married: 4 Motives to Question Before You Wed

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-05-13.

Four Reasons to Reconsider Your Motivation for Marriage

The wrong reasons to get married are the ones that come from outside pressure or fear rather than from the relationship itself: marrying because your friends are, because it feels like the obvious next step, because you have reached a certain age, or because you doubt you could find anyone better. None of these guarantees an unhappy marriage, but each can push people into a lifelong commitment without asking whether this partner and this life are what they actually want.

Most people still hope to marry at some point, even in countries where divorce is common. In a 2019 Pew Research Center survey of married Americans, 90% said love was a major reason they wed, followed by companionship (66%) and the wish to make a formal commitment (63%). Far fewer named finances or convenience. Those are healthy motives. The trouble starts when they are crowded out by others.

1. Because everyone around you is getting married

There is a stage of life when the invitations arrive one after another. Watching close friends get engaged can make you feel left behind, as if you are failing a test nobody told you about. That feeling is real, and it can make saying yes to a proposal seem like a way to belong again.

But a wedding lasts a day, and the marriage that follows is yours alone. If you mainly want to stop feeling like the odd one out, you risk tying yourself legally and financially to someone you are not sure about.

Family pressure works in a similar way, especially in cultures or households where marriage is expected by a certain point. Parents and grandparents often mean well, but they will not be the ones sharing a home, a budget and a bed with your spouse.

Try this: imagine that nobody you know would ever find out whether you married this person. Would you still want to? If you find it hard to resist the opinions of others in general, a counsellor can help you practise saying what you want calmly and clearly.

2. Because it feels like the next step

Many relationships follow a familiar script: dating, moving in, getting engaged, marrying. The script is so common that couples can drift along it without ever making a clear choice. Relationship researchers Scott Stanley and Galena Rhoades describe this as "sliding" rather than "deciding": after sharing a lease, a pet and a social circle, staying together becomes easier than asking hard questions.

A relationship can be loving and good for years without needing to end in marriage, and some long, happy partnerships never do. Marriage works best as a decision both partners make on purpose, not as a box to tick because the previous box has been ticked.

Try this: ask each other why you want to marry, in your own words. If the main answer is "it's what comes next", talk more before setting a date.

3. Because you think you are running out of time

Some people, and women in particular, are told they should be married by 30 or 35. The deadline might come from family, from friends or from films and social media. Biological questions about having children are real and worth discussing with a doctor, but marrying the wrong person to meet a deadline rarely solves them.

Research on age and divorce is more nuanced than the deadlines suggest. University of Utah sociologist Nicholas Wolfinger, analysing US survey data from 2006 to 2010, found that the odds of divorce fell with each year people waited to marry, up to about the age of 32, and then began to rise slowly. That pattern likely reflects who marries at which age as much as age itself, and the differences are modest. The clearest finding is that very early marriages, in the teens and early twenties, carry the highest risk.

People marry for the first time in their forties, fifties and later, and many of those marriages are happy. The right time is when you have found a partner you trust and are ready to build a life with.

4. Because you fear you cannot do better

Settling is the most painful reason of all, because it starts from a belief that you do not deserve more. Some people stay with a partner who does not treat them well, or who wants a very different life, because they are afraid of being alone.

A closely related trap is marrying in the hope that the wedding will fix things: that a partner will drink less, become more reliable or finally want children once you are married. Marriage tends to amplify what is already there rather than change it.

Being single is not a failure. A life without a spouse can be full of friendship, family, purpose and love, and it is far better than a marriage built on fear. If you notice that you are staying mostly out of fear, a therapist can help you sort out what you really want.

Try this: write down what you would need from a partner to feel respected and safe. Then honestly ask whether your current relationship meets that list.

Good reasons, and questions to ask before you marry

Healthy reasons to marry are usually simple: you love and like each other, you want to share a life, you trust each other in hard times, and you want the commitment that marriage represents. Practical motives such as legal rights or shared finances are not wrong either, as long as they sit alongside the relationship itself rather than replacing it.

Before committing, it helps to talk through the subjects that most often cause conflict later:

  • Money: debts, savings, spending habits and who pays for what.
  • Children: whether you want them, how many, and how you would raise them.
  • Work and home: where you will live, and how you will share housework and care.
  • Family: how involved in-laws will be, and how you will handle holidays.
  • Conflict: how each of you behaves when you disagree, and how you make up.

Premarital education programmes cover exactly these topics. Research reviews suggest their clearest benefit is better communication between partners, even if effects on long-term satisfaction are mixed. Many couples find that the conversations alone are worth it.

Signs you may be marrying for the right reasons

No checklist can predict a happy marriage, but some signs are encouraging. You can disagree without feeling afraid. You both want broadly the same things from life. You feel free to be yourself, and you would choose this person even if nobody else were watching. Your friends and family may have opinions, but the decision feels like yours.

If you recognise yourself in one of the four warning signs above, that does not mean you must end the relationship. It means it is worth slowing down, talking honestly and, if needed, getting help from a counsellor before you say "I do". Waiting a little longer costs far less than a marriage entered for the wrong reasons.

Sources: Pew Research Center: Why people get married or move in with a partner (2019); University of Utah: Nicholas Wolfinger on age at marriage and divorce; Wikipedia: Premarital counseling.

COMMENTS