Eyeball Jewellery Implants: How They Work and Why Doctors Warn

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published November 4, 2019.

People Are Getting Jewellery Implanted in Their Eyeballs

Eyeball jewellery is a tiny piece of platinum alloy, about 3 to 4 millimetres across, that a surgeon slips under the conjunctiva, the thin clear membrane covering the white of the eye. It is not a piercing: nothing goes through the eye, and the shape (often a heart or a star) sits flat on the white like a sticker under glass. It is a surgical procedure, and the American Academy of Ophthalmology has warned people not to have it done.

The trend drew global attention in 2018 when a New York eye surgeon, Dr Emil Chynn, began offering it and sharing videos of the operation on social media. Here is where the idea came from, how the surgery is done, what eye specialists say about the risks, and how it differs from eyeball tattooing.

Where eyeball jewellery came from

The implant was first developed in 2002 at the Netherlands Institute for Innovative Ocular Surgery, which marketed it under the name JewelEye. For years it remained a niche procedure in Europe. It reached a much wider audience in May 2018, when the Daily Mail and other outlets reported on Chynn's work at his Park Avenue practice in Manhattan and posted clips of the operation.

Social media did the rest. Posts in Turkish, Spanish and many other languages shared photos of the implants, usually alongside a warning from eye doctors.

New York'ta çalışan estetik cerrah Emil Chynn bir hastasının gözüne, aksesuar amaçlı platin implant yerleştirdi👀 (📷: Caters) pic.twitter.com/G6xJIXuHWr

— Şehriyârİst (@sehriyaroffice) May 21, 2018

(This post is no longer available on X.)

A Turkish news account shared this photo of one of Chynn's patients in May 2018, describing the implant as a platinum accessory; the image was credited to the Caters news agency. The post has since been removed.

[#PeriódicoElDecidor]
Fue defendida por su "creador" el cirujano neoyorkino, Emil Chynn, sin embargo, la Academia Americana de Oftalmología advirtió a los ciudadanos los riesgos de esta práctica

👉https://t.co/76BEIIZAoy#ElDecidorTeInforma pic.twitter.com/wEXJVBUkkm

— PeriódicoElDecidor (@ELDECIDOR_) May 22, 2018

(This post is no longer available on X.)

A day later the Chilean outlet El Decidor reported that, while Chynn defended the procedure, the American Academy of Ophthalmology had warned the public about its risks. This post is also no longer online.

How the procedure is done

According to Chynn's own descriptions and press reports, the patient lies back and receives numbing drops in the eye. The surgeon marks the spot where the jewel will go, makes a small cut in the conjunctiva and, in some techniques, injects a little fluid to separate the membrane from the tissue below. The implant is tucked into that pocket and the membrane settles back over it.

The whole operation reportedly takes about five minutes. Chynn has said the cut heals in a few days, that patients do not feel the implant when they blink and that the metal does not cause allergies. Reported prices in the United States ranged from about $3,000 to $5,000. Removing the jewel requires another short surgical procedure.

(The Instagram post originally embedded here is no longer available.)

An Instagram post by Chynn from June 2019 showed another finished implant; it is no longer available.

The surgeon's practice continued to post patient photos and clips on Instagram in 2019, including the one below.

PARK AVENUE LASEK (@parkavenuelasek) on

A Park Avenue LASEK post from April 30, 2019, one of several the practice used to promote the implants.

(The Instagram post originally embedded here is no longer available.)

(The Instagram post originally embedded here is no longer available.)

Two further Instagram posts by Chynn, from May 2018 and May 2019, showed implants in patients' eyes; both have since been taken down.

What eye specialists say about the risks

Every safety reassurance above comes from the person selling the procedure, which is not the same as evidence. In November 2013 the American Academy of Ophthalmology issued a public warning. Ophthalmologist Philip R. Rizzuto, the Academy's communications secretary, said the Academy had "not identified sufficient evidence to support the safety or therapeutic value of this procedure."

The Academy listed the main risks:

  • a serious eye infection or bleeding that could lead to loss of vision;
  • bleeding under the conjunctiva, which turns the white of the eye red;
  • perforation, meaning a puncture of the eyeball itself;
  • conjunctivitis.

The Academy's broader advice was to avoid putting any foreign body in the eye that is not medically needed. Because so few people have had eyeball jewellery fitted, its long-term effects are unknown. Several Canadian provinces, including Ontario and Saskatchewan, have banned the procedure on health grounds.

The Dutch institute that developed the implant has said it does not affect vision or eye movement and reported no side effects over more than a year of follow-up. That is a short window, and it comes from the developer, which is why independent eye doctors remain cautious.

Jewellery, tattoos and piercings: not the same thing

Viral posts often mix up three quite different practices.

Eyeball jewellery is a solid implant placed under the conjunctiva by a surgeon. It can, in principle, be removed.

Eyeball tattooing, also called scleral tattooing, involves injecting ink under the conjunctiva to colour the white of the eye. It is usually done by body-modification artists rather than doctors, is very hard to reverse and has been linked to serious complications, including vision loss.

Piercing means passing jewellery through tissue. Nobody pierces the eyeball itself; the word is used loosely in headlines. Eyebrow and eyelid-area piercings exist, but they do not involve the eye.

Keeping these straight matters, because the risks, the people performing the work and the chances of undoing it differ a great deal.

Common myths about eyeball jewellery

"It is just a fancy piercing." It is surgery on the surface of the eye, with surgical risks.

"A doctor does it, so it must be safe." A qualified surgeon can reduce some risks, but the procedure itself has no evidence base, and the main professional body for eye doctors in the US has warned against it.

"You can do it at home or at a tattoo studio." Absolutely not. Any attempt outside an operating setting adds serious risk of infection and injury to the eye.

"It is permanent." It can be removed, but removal is another operation with its own risks.

Thinking about it? Talk to an ophthalmologist first

Body modification is a personal choice, and plenty of people enjoy unusual piercings and tattoos. The eye is a different matter: small mistakes can cost sight, and there are no spare eyes. Anyone tempted by eyeball jewellery should get an independent opinion from an ophthalmologist who is not selling the procedure, and ask plainly about infection, scarring, removal and what happens if something goes wrong years later.

The video below shows the procedure for those who want to see how it is done. It is not for the squeamish.

Sources: Photos and videos by Dr Emil Chynn / Park Avenue LASEK and Caters News, as originally reported by the Daily Mail (2018); American Academy of Ophthalmology: Academy cautions consumers about eyeball jewelry (2013); Wikipedia: Eyeball jewelry

COMMENTS