Does Gentle Touch Shape a Baby's Brain? What the 2017 Study Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published November 4, 2019.

A Study Linked Early Touch Experiences With Infant Brain Responses

Does holding and cuddling a baby really shape the brain? A 2017 study from Nationwide Children's Hospital in Columbus, Ohio, offers part of an answer. Researchers tested 125 newborns and found that babies who had more gentle, supportive touch in hospital, such as skin-to-skin contact with a parent, showed stronger brain responses to light touch. Babies who had gone through more painful medical procedures showed weaker responses.

That is a meaningful finding, but it is narrower than many headlines suggested. The study did not measure intelligence, and it did not show that extra hugs make children "smarter". Here is what the researchers actually did, what they found, and what parents can reasonably take from it.

The study in brief

The paper, led by neonatologist Dr. Nathalie Maitre, was published online in the journal Current Biology on 16 March 2017 under the title "The Dual Nature of Early-Life Experience on Somatosensory Processing in the Human Infant Brain". Maitre worked at Nationwide Children's Hospital and Vanderbilt University Medical Center, and the project received funding from the US National Institutes of Health and Swiss research bodies.

The team studied 125 infants. Some were born very early, between 24 and 36 weeks of pregnancy, and others at full term, between 38 and 42 weeks. Many of the premature babies had spent weeks in a neonatal intensive care unit (NICU).

How brain responses to touch were measured

Shortly before each baby went home, the researchers fitted a soft net of sensors on the head to record brain activity, a method called electroencephalography (EEG). They then delivered a gentle puff of air to the skin, a standard way of imitating light touch, along with a "fake" puff that made the same sound but did not touch the baby. Comparing the two shows how strongly the brain reacts to the touch itself.

The researchers also went through hospital records to count each baby's experiences: how much time was spent in supportive contact such as skin-to-skin holding or breastfeeding, and how many painful procedures, such as heel pricks, blood draws or tube insertions, the baby had undergone.

What the researchers found

Three results stood out.

  • Premature babies responded less. Babies born early were more likely than full-term babies to show a reduced brain response to gentle touch, and the earlier the birth, the weaker the response tended to be at discharge.
  • Supportive touch went with stronger responses. Among premature babies, more time in gentle contact with parents or nurses was linked to a stronger response.
  • Pain went with weaker responses. More painful procedures were linked to a weaker later response to gentle touch, even though the babies had received pain relief and sugar solution during those procedures.

The last point surprised the team most. Maitre said that ensuring premature babies receive "positive, supportive touch such as skin-to-skin care by parents is essential". The researchers also noticed that many babies in the study received very little supportive touch, and some received almost none.

What the study does not show

It is easy to stretch a result like this too far, so the limits are worth spelling out.

It measured a brain response, not intelligence. A stronger EEG signal to a puff of air tells us how the brain processes touch at that moment. It is not an IQ score, and the study did not follow the children for years to see how they did at school.

It found links, not proof of cause. Sicker babies tend to need more procedures and may be held less, so illness itself could explain part of the pattern. Studies like this try to adjust for such factors statistically, but an observational design cannot settle cause and effect on its own.

It was mostly about hospital newborns. The clearest findings concern premature babies in intensive care. They do not tell us that a healthy toddler who is hugged less will have a "less developed brain".

An outside expert quoted by HealthDay, Dr. Deborah Campbell of Children's Hospital at Montefiore, described the work as part of an emerging body of evidence on how early painful experiences may affect the developing brain. That is a fair summary of where the science stands.

What we know about skin-to-skin care

The Ohio study fits into a much larger body of research on skin-to-skin contact, often called kangaroo care, in which a baby wearing only a nappy is held against a parent's bare chest. The World Health Organization has recommended kangaroo mother care for small and premature babies since 2003, and its current guidance says it should begin as soon as possible after birth.

The evidence here is stronger than for any single brain study. A 2016 Cochrane review of 21 trials involving more than 3,000 low-birth-weight babies found that kangaroo care reduced the risk of death, serious infection and dangerously low body temperature compared with conventional care. Babies held skin to skin also tend to have steadier temperature, heart rate and breathing, and early contact is associated with higher breastfeeding rates.

Practical takeaways for parents

If your baby is in a NICU, ask the nursing team when and how you can hold your baby skin to skin. Even short sessions count, and staff can help with wires and tubes. Maitre's team suggested that when parents cannot be there, hospitals might involve occupational or physical therapists to provide gentle touch.

If your baby needs painful procedures, that is not your fault and does not mean lasting harm. Talk to your baby's doctor or nurses about comfort measures; holding, swaddling and feeding during or after procedures are often encouraged.

At home, there is no special technique or quota. Holding, rocking, carrying and responding when your baby cries are normal parts of care, and they help babies feel safe. Parents who cannot always be physically close, for medical or practical reasons, should not feel guilty: many caring routines matter, and any concerns about your child's development are best discussed with a doctor.

The real message of the study is a gentle one. Touch is the first sense to develop, and for the most fragile newborns in particular, kind and comforting touch appears to matter for how the brain learns to process it.

Sources: Nationwide Children's Hospital: A Prescription for Touch (16 March 2017); Maitre et al., Current Biology (2017); HealthDay: For preemies, human touch may be a brain booster; Wikipedia: Kangaroo care.

COMMENTS