Iranian Site Melovaz Erased Women From 26 Album Covers

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Iranian Streaming Site Removed Women From Album Covers: The Results

In autumn 2019, users noticed that Melovaz, a popular Iranian music streaming and download site, was showing album covers by Lady Gaga, Beyoncé, Billie Eilish, Ariana Grande and dozens of other female artists with the women simply cut out. Male figures on the same covers were left in place. What remained were empty rooms, blank backdrops and floating hats.

The edits were not a glitch. In Iran, female singers have been barred from performing solo for male audiences since the 1979 revolution, women must cover their hair in public, and cultural products need approval from the Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance. Erasing women from imported artwork was a crude way of making Western pop look compliant while still offering the music itself.

Screenshots spread on Twitter and were picked up by photography and music sites worldwide. Below are 26 of the edited covers, with notes on each record and why it mattered in 2019, followed by the background to the censorship and what changed afterwards.

How the edits came to light

Image credits: cloudyrepsx, Melovaz

Iranian Streaming Site Removed Women From Album Covers: The Results

A Twitter user posted side-by-side comparisons at the end of September 2019, and other users began checking the site for themselves. According to DIY Photography, which browsed Melovaz and confirmed the edits, the women were removed entirely rather than covered up, and Insider reported that the site did not respond to a request for comment. In an earlier case from 2017, other Iranian outlets had digitally “dressed” women on covers instead of deleting them.

Albums and soundtracks by major stars

Lady Gaga - Joanne

Lady Gaga - Joanne

Gaga’s 2016 album is named after her aunt Joanne Germanotta, who died at 19 before Gaga was born. The original cover is a famous profile shot of the singer in a pink wide-brimmed hat. On Melovaz the singer vanished, leaving a stripped-back image that loses its whole point: a portrait of a woman remembering another woman.

Lana Del Rey - Nfr!

Lana Del Rey - Nfr!

Norman F***ing Rockwell!, released in August 2019, was produced largely with Jack Antonoff and became one of the most acclaimed albums of that year, later earning a Grammy nomination for Album of the Year. Its cover shows Lana on a boat with actor Duke Nicholson. The censored version kept him and removed her, turning her own album into a portrait of a man.

Lady Gaga - A Star Is Born

Lady Gaga - A Star Is Born

The soundtrack to Bradley Cooper’s 2018 remake paired Gaga and Cooper, and its single “Shallow” won the Academy Award for Best Original Song. Because Cooper also appears on the artwork, the edit left only the male co-star on a record that is built around Gaga’s voice.

Beyoncé - Spirit

Beyoncé - Spirit

“Spirit” was written for Disney’s 2019 remake of The Lion King, in which Beyoncé voiced Nala, and appeared on her companion album The Lion King: The Gift. The song went on to earn Golden Globe and Grammy nominations. Its cover without its singer is one of the starker examples in the set.

Avril Lavigne - Head Above Water Cover

Avril Lavigne - Head Above Water Cover

Lavigne wrote “Head Above Water” while seriously ill with Lyme disease, and released it in 2018 as her first single in several years. It became the title track of her 2019 album. A song about surviving a frightening illness lost the only person on its cover.

Little Mix Ft. Nicki Minaj - Woman Like Me

Little Mix Ft. Nicki Minaj - Woman Like Me

The British girl group’s 2018 single with Nicki Minaj was the lead track from their album LM5 and a top-five hit in the UK. A song openly celebrating confident women is an especially ironic target for a filter that deletes them.

Céline Dion - Ashes Steve Aoki Deadpool Demix

Céline Dion - Ashes Steve Aoki Deadpool Demix

“Ashes” was the dramatic power ballad written for Deadpool 2 (2018), with a tongue-in-cheek music video featuring the masked anti-hero dancing beside Dion. DJ Steve Aoki later produced this dance remix. Even a novelty remix cover was not spared.

Young artists and breakout records of 2019

Mxmtoon - The Masquerade

Mxmtoon - The Masquerade

mxmtoon, the stage name of Californian singer-songwriter Maia, built a following with ukulele songs posted online as a teenager. The Masquerade (2019) was her first full-length release. Her inclusion shows how far the filter reached, from global superstars to a young independent artist.

Billie Eilish - When We All Fall Asleep

Billie Eilish - When We All Fall Asleep

Eilish’s debut album, recorded with her brother Finneas in a bedroom studio, came out in March 2019 and later won the Grammy for Album of the Year. The original cover, of Billie perched on a bed with blank white eyes, is one of the most recognisable images of the decade. Without her, it is just a bed in a dark room.

Lizzo, Dababy - Truth Hurts

Lizzo, Dababy - Truth Hurts

Lizzo first released “Truth Hurts” in 2017, but it took off two years later and reached number one on the US Billboard Hot 100. The remix with rapper DaBaby arrived during that run. Lizzo’s body-positive image was a central part of the song’s appeal, which made her removal particularly pointed.

Billie Eilish - When I Was Older

Billie Eilish - When I Was Older

This quieter song, released in January 2019, appeared on a collection of music inspired by Alfonso Cuarón’s film Roma. It showed the more reflective side of Eilish’s writing. She is one of several singers, along with Lady Gaga, Lana Del Rey, Beyoncé, Céline Dion and Ariana Grande, who appear more than once in this set.

Katy Perry - Small Talk

Katy Perry - Small Talk

Perry released “Small Talk” in August 2019, a breezy single about the awkwardness of running into an ex, co-written with Charlie Puth. The censored artwork arrived only weeks after the song itself.

Pnb Rock, Nicki Minaj, Murda Beatz - Fendi

Pnb Rock, Nicki Minaj, Murda Beatz - Fendi

This 2019 collaboration brought together Philadelphia rapper PnB Rock, Nicki Minaj and Canadian producer Murda Beatz. According to DIY Photography, the filter even removed a sketched woman from a Nicki Minaj cover, which shows the edits applied to drawings as well as photographs.

Dua Lipa - Dua Lipa

Dua Lipa - Dua Lipa

The British-Albanian singer’s self-titled debut (2017) produced the global hit “New Rules”, and she won the Grammy for Best New Artist in 2019. A self-titled album exists to introduce its artist; this version introduces no one.

Melanie Martinez - K-12

Melanie Martinez - K-12

K-12, released in September 2019, came with a feature-length fantasy film that Martinez wrote and directed, set in a sinister boarding school. Its pastel artwork is tied tightly to her character, so the cover makes little sense without her.

Hit singles from the same season

Ariana Grande - Imagine

Ariana Grande - Imagine

“Imagine” came out in December 2018 as a single from the album thank u, next. It is a soft ballad about an idealised relationship, and one of three Grande covers in this collection.

Ariana Grande - Thank U, Next

Ariana Grande - Thank U, Next

Released in February 2019, only about six months after her previous album Sweetener, thank u, next broke streaming records and gave Grande several chart-topping singles. Its cover is one of the most widely shared images of that year.

Marina - Love Fear

Marina - Love Fear

Love + Fear (April 2019) was the Welsh singer’s fourth album and her first released simply as Marina, after years as Marina and the Diamonds. The double album split its songs between two emotions, a concept that depends on her presence on the art.

Kygo And Whitney Houston - Higher Love

Kygo And Whitney Houston - Higher Love

Norwegian producer Kygo reworked a version of Steve Winwood’s 1986 hit that Whitney Houston had recorded around 1990, and released it in June 2019, years after Houston’s death. It became a major international hit. Removing Houston from a tribute to her voice turns the cover into an odd blank.

Afro B - Afrowave 3

Afro B - Afrowave 3

Afro B, a London-based artist with Ivorian roots, became known for the Afrobeats hit “Drogba (Joanna)”. This cover from his Afrowave series is one of the few by a male artist in the set, which suggests the filter caught women in the artwork rather than targeting female singers alone.

Camila Cabello - Liar

Camila Cabello - Liar

“Liar” was released in September 2019 alongside “Shameless” as the first singles from Cabello’s album Romance. Its retro, playful style was part of a new image she was building that year.

Meghan Trainor - Badass Woman

Meghan Trainor - Badass Woman

Trainor’s empowerment anthem, later included on her album Treat Myself, is about self-worth and standing up for yourself. Deleting the woman from a song with that title says more about the filter than any commentary could.

Ariana Grande - Boyfriend

Ariana Grande - Boyfriend

“Boyfriend”, released in August 2019, was a duet with the American pop duo Social House. Because two men appear on the artwork, they remained after the edit, leaving a cover in which Grande’s own collaborators outrank her.

Lana Del Rey - Doin' Time Album

Lana Del Rey - Doin' Time Album

Del Rey’s 2019 cover of Sublime’s “Doin’ Time” was recorded for a documentary about the band and later added to Norman F***ing Rockwell!. Its playful video imagined her as a giant woman at a drive-in cinema.

Celine Dion - Courage

Celine Dion - Courage

Courage was Dion’s first English-language album in several years, with its title track and other songs released in September 2019 ahead of the full album in November. It also gave its name to her world tour, which was running when the edits appeared.

Beyonce - Homecoming

Beyonce - Homecoming

Homecoming: The Live Album (April 2019) captured Beyoncé’s 2018 Coachella performance, in which she became the first Black woman to headline the festival, alongside a Netflix concert film. A record about a historic moment of visibility ended up as one more empty frame.

Why women disappear from covers in Iran

After the 1979 revolution, the new government created the Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance to oversee cultural life, and musicians need its permits to release work, as Wikipedia’s summary of censorship in Iran explains. Women were banned from singing solo for male audiences, according to Wikipedia’s article on Iranian music, and compulsory hijab was enforced from the early 1980s. Iranian broadcasters had already cropped and edited foreign films to hide women’s faces and clothing.

Many foreign albums reach Iranian listeners through local download and streaming sites that operate in a legal grey zone. Removing women from the art appears to have been their way of avoiding trouble with censors while still offering the music itself, which is often sung by the very women who were erased.

What the empty covers tell us

The edits drew mockery around the world, and fans, along with at least one rapper, joked about them on social media. Behind the humour sits a serious point. Iranian women have long challenged these rules, from the 2015 “My Stealthy Freedom” photo campaign to the nationwide protests that followed the death of Mahsa Amini in police custody in September 2022 under the slogan “Woman, Life, Freedom”, as described on Wikipedia’s page on women in Iran.

Seen in that light, these 26 blank covers are a small, strange record of a much bigger struggle over who is allowed to be seen and heard.

Sources: DIY Photography: Iranian streaming website removes women from album covers; Wikipedia: Censorship in Iran; Wikipedia: Music of Iran; Wikipedia: Women in Iran. Edited covers: Melovaz; comparisons first shared by cloudyrepsx. Original album artwork belongs to the respective artists and labels.

COMMENTS