Sharpiegate: Trump’s Altered Hurricane Dorian Map and the Memes

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

“Sharpiegate” was the September 2019 controversy over a hurricane forecast map that President Donald Trump displayed in the Oval Office with a hand-drawn black loop extending Hurricane Dorian’s possible path into Alabama. Official forecasts at the time did not show Alabama in the storm’s path. The marker line appeared to be an attempt to back up a claim Trump had made days earlier, and it set off a scientific, political and comic reaction that ran for weeks.

Below is what happened, day by day, what investigators later found, why altering a forecast matters, and a gallery of the memes that turned a black marker into one of the year’s biggest jokes. The memes were collected at the time by Bored Panda from posts on Twitter, now X.

What happened: a timeline

1 September 2019. Hurricane Dorian made landfall on Great Abaco in the Bahamas as a Category 5 storm with sustained winds of about 185 mph (295 km/h). The same day Trump tweeted that Florida, South Carolina, North Carolina, Georgia and Alabama would “most likely be hit (much) harder than anticipated”. Alabama was not in the National Hurricane Center (NHC) forecast; several NHC updates over the previous day had shown Dorian moving away from it. Around ten minutes later the National Weather Service (NWS) office in Birmingham, Alabama, which had been fielding worried calls, posted that Alabama would see no impacts.

2 to 3 September. Dorian stalled over Grand Bahama for about a day, causing catastrophic damage. Trump continued to repeat that Alabama had been at risk.

4 September. In an Oval Office briefing Trump showed the NHC’s track map from 29 August, five days out of date. A black line had been added to the forecast cone, bulging it westward over southern Alabama. Meteorologists spotted it immediately, and weather writer Dennis Mersereau’s post comparing it to the original spread widely.

The President of the United States altered a National Hurricane Center map with a sharpie to falsely extend the official forecast toward Alabama so he didn't have to admit he was wrong in a tweet. https://t.co/i0CJcYV4yq pic.twitter.com/pR57IL6WfT

— Dennis Mersereau (@wxdam) September 4, 2019

(This post is no longer available on X.)

Asked by reporters who had changed the map, Trump said: “I don’t know.” He did not say who drew the line. The Washington Post later reported, citing an unnamed White House official, that Trump had made the mark himself; that was never officially confirmed.

Scientists and former officials responded with alarm rather than amusement. Disaster researcher Samantha Montano, the March for Science group and former NOAA official Monica Medina all criticised the altered map.

I— he extended an old track into Alabama with a sharpie. If this wasn’t so dangerous I’d be laughing. 😳😳 https://t.co/DtIzKZ7YKs

— Dr. Samantha Montano (@SamLMontano) September 4, 2019

(This post is no longer available on X.)





6 September. NOAA, the agency that runs the NWS and the hurricane center, issued an unsigned statement saying the Birmingham tweet had spoken in absolute terms that did not match the forecast probabilities available at the time. Many forecasters saw it as a rebuke of their colleagues for telling the truth. The same day, Dorian made landfall at Cape Hatteras, North Carolina, as a Category 2 hurricane, then went on to strike Nova Scotia and Newfoundland.

What the investigations found

The Commerce Department’s inspector general, Peggy Gustafson, opened an inquiry within days. Her report, released on 9 July 2020, found that NOAA’s unsigned statement followed pressure from the White House: acting chief of staff Mick Mulvaney had emailed Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross late at night saying the NWS appeared to have contradicted the president and asking why, and Commerce staff then exchanged calls and messages into the early hours to prepare the statement.

The inspector general concluded that the department had unnecessarily rebuked NWS forecasters for doing their jobs, and that the statement risked undermining public trust in forecasts. A separate review by the National Academy of Public Administration, published in June 2020, found that acting NOAA administrator Neil Jacobs and another senior official had violated the agency’s scientific integrity policy. The Commerce Department disputed parts of the findings.

It is worth being precise about Alabama’s real risk. By 1 September it was outside the forecast cone, although earlier forecasts had included it, and one NHC graphic still showed a small chance of tropical-storm-force winds in a corner of the state. That small probability is the basis of later claims that Trump had been “right”. But no forecast showed Dorian hitting Alabama hard, and the hand-drawn extension did not reflect any official forecast.

Why altering a forecast matters

US federal law, 18 U.S.C. § 2074, makes it a crime to knowingly issue or publish a counterfeit weather forecast while presenting it as an official one from the Weather Bureau, the predecessor of the NWS. The penalty is a fine and up to 90 days in prison. No one was charged over the Sharpie map, and legal experts disagreed about whether the law would apply, but it explains why some meteorologists took the episode so seriously.

The deeper concern is trust. Hurricane forecasts only save lives if people believe them. A false alarm in one state can lead people to ignore a real warning later, and a forecaster who fears political punishment may hedge when clarity is needed. Dorian was a deadly storm: the Bahamas confirmed 74 deaths, hundreds more were listed as missing, and damage there was estimated at about 3.4 billion US dollars, the costliest disaster in the country’s history.

How the internet answered: 33 Sharpie memes

Once the photo of the altered map spread, people began “improving” other images with a black marker. Each joke below takes a Trump claim, controversy or wish and makes it come true with a few strokes of a pen.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

The original moment: Trump in the Oval Office on 4 September 2019 holding up the outdated 29 August forecast map. Officials from his administration sit beside him. This press photo became the template for everything that followed.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

A close-up of the NHC forecast cone, the shape the Sharpie loop was added to. The white cone shows where the centre of the storm might travel, with dots marking positions for each day. Comparing it with the doctored version shows how far the extra loop strayed from the official forecast.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

One user circled Trump himself on the map photo and labelled him the biggest disaster in the picture. Jokes like this turned the story from weather science into political commentary within hours. It was one of the most shared early responses.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

The 2017 inauguration crowd, “filled in” with marker dots. The White House had insisted in January 2017 that the crowd was the largest ever, despite photos showing a smaller turnout than in 2009. The meme suggested the Sharpie could fix that too.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

A border wall drawn across an empty desert. Building a wall on the southern border was Trump’s signature 2016 campaign promise, and in 2019 progress was still a matter of dispute. The marker version is finished instantly.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

A golf ball that missed the hole, with a marker line looping round it to bring the hole to the ball. Trump’s frequent golf outings were a long-running topic of criticism. The joke mirrors the map: if reality does not match, redraw it.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

Smokestacks with rainbows, clouds and a unicorn drawn into the smoke, captioned as “clean coal”. Trump often promoted what he called clean coal as part of his energy policy. Critics argued there is no such thing as clean coal power at scale.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

A widely circulated photo of Trump at a party with Jeffrey Epstein, with Epstein crossed out. Epstein had died in jail in August 2019, only weeks before Sharpiegate. The joke imagines the photo being “corrected”.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

A hand-drawn cheque from Mexico to the USA “for wall”. Trump promised during his campaign that Mexico would pay for the border wall, which Mexico refused to do. Here the payment is simply written into existence.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

Trump and Barack Obama standing together on the Capitol steps, with Trump’s hair drawn taller so he towers over his predecessor. Comparisons of height and stature were a running theme in jokes about the two men. This one was among the most liked in the collection.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

Marker lines drawn from wind turbines to suggest something harmful coming off them. In 2019 Trump claimed that noise from wind turbines causes cancer, a statement with no scientific support. The meme shows the “evidence” being added by pen.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

A photo of Trump holding an umbrella while Melania Trump walks without one, now with a scribbled umbrella over her head. Images of the president keeping the umbrella to himself had circulated before. The marker settles the matter.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

A label inside a Trump-branded cap rewritten in marker to read “Made in USA”. Reports during his presidency noted that some Trump-brand merchandise had been manufactured abroad. The joke targets the gap between slogan and supply chain.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

Trump and Melania walking apart, with a marker line connecting their hands. Moments when the first lady appeared to avoid holding his hand drew wide attention in 2017. The meme simply draws the connection in.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

A wide marker grin added to Melania Trump’s face in an official photo. The caption joked that she had never looked happier. It played on speculation about the first couple’s relationship that followed them throughout the presidency.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

Huge cartoon hands drawn over Trump’s own. The size of his hands became a joke in the 2016 Republican primaries after Marco Rubio mocked them, and Trump defended them in a televised debate. Three years later the Sharpie made them enormous.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

A dog sketched on a leash beside Trump as he walks on the White House grounds. He was the first president in more than a century not to keep a pet at the White House. The marker gave him one in a few seconds.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

Darts that missed the board, with marker lines bending them all into the bullseye. It is the cleanest visual summary of the whole affair: move the target, not the arrow. It needs no political knowledge to get the joke.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

Barack Obama’s birth certificate with “Nambia” scrawled over the place of birth. Trump spent years promoting the false claim that Obama was not born in the US; Obama was born in Honolulu, Hawaii. “Nambia” refers to Trump’s 2017 mispronunciation of Namibia at a UN lunch.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

A sparsely filled arena where a crowd of stick figures has been added in marker. Attendance at rallies was another number the administration often disputed. Here the solution is the same as for the forecast: draw more.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

A TV graphic of the 2016 popular vote, with Trump’s total “corrected” by a marker stroke so it overtakes Hillary Clinton’s. In the certified results Clinton won the national popular vote by about 2.9 million votes, while Trump won the Electoral College. Trump had claimed, without evidence, that millions voted illegally.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

John Trumbull’s painting Surrender of Lord Cornwallis, showing the British surrender at Yorktown in 1781, with aeroplanes doodled in the sky. In a 4 July 2019 speech Trump said the Continental Army had taken over the airports, more than a century before powered flight. He later blamed a broken teleprompter.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

The Daily Show’s version: the Oval Office photo with the marker loop grown to swallow most of North America. The comedy programme posted it the same evening. Its caption asked someone to take the president’s Sharpie away.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

Trump on a golf course with a muscular six-pack drawn over his shirt. Trump’s physical health and doctors’ reports were frequent subjects of jokes. The marker sculpts the physique in seconds.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

A forecast cone scribbled over with lines and the word “BOOM”, showing the storm hitting everything at once. Note the real warning printed at the top of every NHC cone graphic: impacts can occur outside the cone. That nuance is exactly what gets lost when a map is redrawn by hand.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

Mount Rushmore with a Trump face drawn on the bare rock beside Lincoln. Jokes about Trump wanting to be added to the monument circulated throughout his presidency. In marker, it takes one outline.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

The Oval Office photo beside a picture of adviser Stephen Miller, whose hairline has been filled in with marker. The caption suggested Miller had supplied the pen. It is one of many jokes speculating about who in the White House drew the loop.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

Another take on the hands joke: Trump pointing upward with an oversized drawn finger. The caption parodies his habit of describing everything as the biggest and best. Repetition of themes shows how quickly the memes built on each other.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

Trump on a golf course surrounded by stick-figure grandchildren drawn in marker. The caption joked about quality family time while the storm was under way. Trump was criticised for golfing during the Dorian response.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

A family photo of Trump with his adult children Eric, Ivanka and Donald Jr., with a stick figure labelled “Tiffany” added at the edge. Tiffany Trump was often noted as absent from family events. The joke “fixes” her exclusion.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

Trump mid-swing, with a curving marker line taking his shot straight into the hole. It is a hole-in-one by Sharpie. Trump’s claims about his golf game had long been teased.

Hurricane Dorian's Altered Map and the 2019 Meme Response

A map of the North Atlantic with Greenland circled and a caption announcing the purchase was done. In August 2019 Trump said he was interested in buying Greenland, an autonomous territory of Denmark; Denmark said it was not for sale, and he cancelled a planned state visit. A marker loop makes the deal.

What Sharpiegate tells us about memes and misinformation

Memes are not evidence, but they can be a sharp form of media criticism. The best Sharpiegate jokes worked because they made an abstract issue, changing official data to fit a statement, instantly visible. Anyone can understand moving a dartboard.

The episode also shows how easy it is to alter an image and how important it is to check the source. Before sharing any forecast or map, look for the issuing agency, the date and the time on it. The doctored Dorian map was five days old before anyone touched it with a pen. For hurricane information in the US, the National Hurricane Center and the local National Weather Service office remain the official sources.

Sources: Hurricane Dorian–Alabama controversy, Wikipedia; Hurricane Dorian, Wikipedia; Associated Press via KMPH, 9 July 2020. Memes by the Twitter users named in each image, collected by Bored Panda; Oval Office photo from White House press coverage.

Explore the related article: Queen Elizabeth II's Brooches and the 2018 Trump Theory.

COMMENTS