Alaska's 2019 Ice-Free Waters: What Happened and Why It Matters

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-09-11.

Alaska's 2019 Sea-Ice Conditions and the Meaning of Ice-Free Waters

Jeremie Richard / AFP / Getty Images

In late summer 2019, reports spread that Alaska's sea ice had "completely melted for the first time in recorded history." The headline was dramatic, and only partly right. What happened was that the waters off Alaska's coasts became ice-free unusually early in the season, with meteorologists reporting no sea ice within roughly 150 miles of the shore. That had happened before, in 2017, so 2019 was not a first. It was, however, the earliest such clearing on record, and it arrived in a summer full of other climate milestones.

This article explains what the Alaska observation did and did not mean, then places it alongside the other events of that year: the hottest month ever measured, a record day of melting in Greenland, a memorial for a lost Icelandic glacier and heatwaves across Europe. The photograph above, credited to Jeremie Richard of AFP, comes from the period when Iceland marked the loss of its Okjökull glacier.

What "ice-free Alaska" actually meant

The fact-checking site Lead Stories rated the "first time ever" headline false. It noted that Alaska's coastal sea ice had also melted away entirely in the summer of 2017, although the 2019 melt finished earlier in the season. Alaska climatologist Rick Thoman, quoted by Mashable at the time, put it simply: the ice had "cleared earlier than it has in any other year."

Scope matters here. The observation concerned a band of ocean around Alaska during the summer melt season, mainly in the Bering and Chukchi seas. It did not mean all Arctic sea ice had disappeared. The Arctic Ocean still held a large ice pack; its September 2019 minimum extent was about 4.15 million square kilometres, close to the 2007 figure and among the lowest in the satellite record, with only 2012 clearly lower. Ice returned to Alaskan waters with the autumn freeze, as it does each year.

Why does an early clearing matter if the ice comes back? Sea ice in the Bering region supports fish, seals, walrus and seabirds, and coastal communities rely on it for travel, hunting and as a buffer against autumn storms. Open water also absorbs more sunlight than ice, which warms the ocean further, a feedback that helps explain why the Arctic is warming faster than the global average. Across the satellite era, summer Arctic ice cover has fallen by more than half.

A record-breaking summer of heat

The Alaska observation came during a summer that set several global records. According to NOAA, July 2019 was the warmest month in its 140-year record, about 1.71°F (0.95°C) above the 20th-century average. Nine of the ten warmest Julys on record had occurred since 2005, and it was the 43rd July in a row above the long-term average. Arctic sea ice in July 2019 was nearly 20 percent below normal, a record low for that month.

Europe felt the heat directly. On 28 June France reached 46.0°C at Vérargues, a national record, and in a second heatwave on 25 July Belgium, the Netherlands, Luxembourg and the United Kingdom all set new all-time highs. Belgium peaked at 41.8°C and the Netherlands at 40.7°C.

Greenland's record day of melt

That same European air mass then drifted north over Greenland. On 1 August 2019 the ice sheet lost about 12.5 billion tons of ice in a single day, the largest one-day loss since records began in 1950, according to the American Geophysical Union's news site Eos. On 31 July, a record 56.5 percent of the ice sheet's surface showed signs of melting, and for the year as a whole Greenland lost several hundred billion tonnes of ice.

The stakes are large. If the entire Greenland ice sheet melted, global sea level would rise by about 7.4 metres, roughly 24 feet. That would take many centuries, but the melt already under way adds to sea-level rise this century, with projections of several centimetres to around a third of a metre from Greenland alone by 2100 depending on emissions.

Iceland's funeral for Okjökull

A few weeks before the Alaska headlines, Iceland held a memorial for Okjökull, a glacier on the Ok volcano in the west of the country. Glaciologist Oddur Sigurðsson had declared it dead in 2014, when it became too thin to keep flowing. On 18 August 2019, scientists, officials and residents climbed the mountain to unveil a plaque proposed by Rice University anthropologists Cymene Howe and Dominic Boyer.

Its inscription, "A letter to the future," was written by Icelandic author Andri Snær Magnason. It closes with two lines that were widely quoted: "This monument is to acknowledge that we know what is happening and what needs to be done. Only you know if we did it." The plaque also records the atmospheric carbon dioxide level of the time, 415 parts per million.

Other warning signs reported that year

Many other studies and reports in 2019 pointed in the same direction, though they vary in how strong their evidence is.

Food security. The UN's 2019 food-security report estimated that about two billion people faced moderate or severe food insecurity. The report's main focus was economic slowdowns, alongside conflict and climate extremes, so warming is one contributor rather than the main cause.

Wildlife. A 2019 study in Nature Communications concluded that many bird species are shifting their breeding times in response to warming, but probably not fast enough to keep up. Beluga whales are a more mixed case: the species as a whole is listed as Least Concern, while Alaska's small Cook Inlet population, of around 300 animals, is critically endangered and faces several pressures including a changing ocean.

Health. Researchers writing in the journal mBio proposed that warming may have helped the drug-resistant fungus Candida auris adapt to human body temperature, which could explain why it appeared on three continents at roughly the same time. This is a hypothesis, not an established finding.

Water and fire. The World Resources Institute reported that 17 countries, home to a quarter of the world's population, face extremely high water stress. In California, research reported in 2019 found that the area burned each year had grown roughly fivefold since the early 1970s, with warming and drying a major driver.

Policy. Politico reported in July 2019 that the US Department of Agriculture had not publicised a completed climate-adaptation plan, and debates over climate in the Democratic presidential primary drew criticism from activists. Global energy-related emissions, meanwhile, reached a record high in 2018.

Reading climate headlines carefully

The Alaska story is a useful lesson. The underlying trend was real and serious, yet an exaggerated headline handed critics an easy correction and distracted from the actual news, which was an ice-free coast arriving earlier than ever. When you meet a dramatic climate claim, check three things: the exact place, the exact date or season, and whether "record" means first ever, earliest, or largest. Primary sources such as NOAA, the US National Snow and Ice Data Center and national weather services usually state these clearly.

Accurate reporting does not make the picture less worrying. A summer that combined record global heat, Greenland's biggest melt day and an early ice-free Alaskan coast is a clear sign of the direction of travel. The plaque on Ok mountain makes the same point more quietly: the outcome is still being decided.

Sources: Lead Stories fact check; NOAA, July 2019 hottest month on record; Eos, Greenland one-day melt record; Wikipedia, Okjökull; Wikipedia, 2019 European heatwaves; Wikipedia, Greenland ice sheet; Wikipedia, Arctic sea ice decline; Wikipedia, Beluga whale; Wikipedia, Candida auris; Wikipedia, 2019 in climate change. Photo: Jeremie Richard / AFP / Getty Images.

COMMENTS