Esther Garcia is a Chicago tattoo artist best known for one striking idea: she fills a whole area of skin with solid black ink, then paints flowers, birds and butterflies on top of it so they seem to glow. Sweet peas, garden roses, cherry blossoms and moths appear in soft pinks, creams and reds, edged with lace-like ornament where the black meets bare skin.
The look began as a practical answer to cover-up work. When a client wanted an old tattoo hidden, a dense black base could erase it completely and give her a clean surface for something new. Clients soon asked for the same effect on untouched skin, and it became her signature.
From cover-up fix to signature style
Garcia had been tattooing for around twenty years when her black-background pieces went viral in 2019, and she has described herself as largely self-taught. She told Colossal that laying the black base felt calming: she found it meditative to make a smooth, saturated surface where there was chaos before. That surface is what lets pale petals read as light rather than as skin.
A full arm sleeve of magenta sweet peas and ferns climbs from wrist to shoulder. Notice the black lace border at the top of the shoulder and the patterned cuff at the wrist: Garcia frames each piece so the black field has a deliberate edge instead of simply stopping.
On this forearm a large pink peony or garden rose sits among dark leaves, with a small butterfly hovering above. The ornamental cuff near the wrist is a recurring motif in her work and makes the tattoo look like a sleeve of embroidered fabric.
Here a pale moth spreads its wings over a stylised, scale-patterned blossom and clusters of orange flowers. Moths and butterflies give her compositions a sense of movement, and their light wings stand out especially well against the black.
A side view shows a full sleeve with a mourning dove perched among pink blossoms. Birds are rarer than flowers in her portfolio, and the soft grey plumage is a good example of how she uses muted tones, not only bright ones, against black.
A Dutch still-life feeling on skin
Garcia has named the Dutch flower paintings of the seventeenth century as an influence. Artists such as Rachel Ruysch and Jan van Huysum set lush bouquets against near-black backgrounds, so that petals and fruit seem to step forward out of the darkness. She saw the same richness and depth in a dark tattoo base, and also found it was a good way to make delicate subjects look delicate.
A sleeve of cherry blossoms in two shades of pink, with deep magenta leaves. Because there is no outline-heavy linework around each flower, the blossoms look painted rather than drawn, much like brushwork on a dark canvas.
Not every piece is an arm. This lower-leg design runs a tall stem of pale phlox-like flowers up the shin, with a carved, arch-shaped border at the knee and another at the ankle. The cream tones are among the hardest to make visible on black, which is why so few artists attempt them.
A creamy garden rose and pink buds wrap around the calf, finished with a band of lace-like ornament above the ankle. The photo was taken in the studio, and you can see how the black field follows the natural line of the leg.
A close-up of two pink roses with red-tinged leaves shows her shading in detail. Highlights are built up gradually, so each petal has a lit edge and a shadowed fold, the same way a painter models a flower.
Sleeves, legs and the ornamental frame
Pale pink tulip-like flowers with fine white outlines sit on a black ground softened by dotwork at the edges. The stippled border is a gentler alternative to her lace frames and lets the black fade into the skin.
One of the most ornamental pieces in the set: a full sleeve of red, stylised blooms that recall printed chintz or Indian textile patterns, with butterflies and trailing leaves. It shows that her black-background style works with flat, decorative flowers as well as realistic ones.
Roses and wildflowers spread across the thigh and knee. Large leg pieces like this are usually completed over several long sessions, because a dense black base has to be packed evenly across a big area.
More recent work from her Instagram
Garcia shares finished pieces and work in progress on her Instagram account, @butterstinker. These three posts are from the summer of 2019, the period when her floral sleeves were being shared by art and design sites around the world.
Esther Garcia (@butterstinker) on
Posted on 27 August 2019, this is one of the pieces that circulated with the first wave of coverage of her black-background style.
Esther Garcia (@butterstinker) on
Posted in July 2019. Her captions often credit the client and note whether the piece covered an older tattoo.
Esther Garcia (@butterstinker) on
Posted in May 2019, a reminder that this approach was already well developed before it reached a wider audience.
Beyond the studio
Garcia opened her Butterfat Studios in Chicago's Logan Square around 2010. In 2016 the shop lost its lease as rents rose in the neighbourhood, and DNAinfo Chicago reported that she planned to work as a guest artist in friends' studios in the US and abroad, with occasional Butterfat pop-ups. By 2019 she was also branching out from skin: she was working on a textile and commercial design collaboration with Chicago designer Kyle Letendre, and teaching workshops that help younger tattooists develop a personal style and a sustainable business.
Thinking about a blackout floral tattoo?
If this style appeals to you, a few points are worth weighing before you book. Solid black is permanent in a very real sense: it is the hardest colour to rework later, so the decision is bigger than for an outline tattoo. A large blackout area also takes several sessions and a longer healing period than a small piece.
Choose an artist whose portfolio shows healed black-background work, not only fresh photos, because pale colours over black can change as they settle. Ask how they plan the edges, since the frame is what makes this style look finished. If you have a skin condition, a history of keloid scars or any health concern, talk to a doctor before committing to a large tattoo.
Esther Garcia: Website | Instagram
Sources: Colossal: Esther Garcia's botanical tattoos (2019); DNAinfo Chicago: Butterfat Studios closing in Logan Square (2016); Esther Garcia: Butterfat Studios website; Esther Garcia on Instagram. All tattoos and photographs: Esther Garcia (@butterstinker).
Related articles
COMMENTS