Originally published 2019-09-03.

PixaBay
How much would a stay-at-home parent earn if their work were paid? Salary.com, which has run this calculation for years, put the figure for a mother's work at $162,581 a year in the estimate widely reported in 2019. The number is not a real wage and nobody is paid it, but it became part of a wider debate that year, when presidential candidate Andrew Yang argued that unpaid caregiving should be recognised through his proposed $1,000-a-month "Freedom Dividend."
This guide explains where the estimate comes from, what Yang proposed, how other countries support families with children, and what the figure does and does not prove.
Where the $162,581 figure comes from
Salary.com builds its estimate by treating a parent's day as a bundle of paid jobs. The company picks occupations that resemble the tasks involved, looks up typical pay for each in its own salary database, and adds them up. The roles reported in 2019 included:
- Academic adviser
- Accountant
- Buyer
- CEO
- Coach
- Daycare center teacher
- Janitor
- Judge
- Marketing manager
- Plumber
- Photographer
- Psychologist
- Staff nurse
- Teacher
The figure has changed over time. Salary.com's current version still quotes $162,581 as the median annual value of a mother's work and says it rose by nearly $5,000 compared with its 2017 calculation. The company now frames it as recognition for all mothers, including those who also hold paid jobs, rather than a figure for stay-at-home parents alone. It does not publish detailed assumptions about hours or weighting, so the estimate is best read as an illustration rather than a precise valuation.
Andrew Yang's argument on The View
In the summer of 2019, Andrew Yang, then running in the Democratic presidential primary, made universal basic income the centre of his campaign. His Freedom Dividend would have given every American adult $1,000 a month, with no conditions on how it was spent. His main argument was that automation would disrupt many jobs, but he also presented the payment as a way to value work the market ignores.
On ABC's talk show The View, Yang pointed to his wife, Evelyn, who was at home raising their two sons, one of whom is autistic. As reported by Upworthy, he said: "right now the market values her work at zero." Co-host Joy Behar responded that paying people for work at home sounded like a good idea.
The #FreedomDividend would recognize the work that isn't valued by the market, like caregiving, that is performed disproportionately by women. Putting cash into the hands of women also would empower them to leave exploitative jobs or relationships. pic.twitter.com/4AvQcrOL0r
— Andrew Yang (@AndrewYang) July 9, 2019
Yang suspended his campaign in February 2020, after the New Hampshire primary, so the policy was never tested. The debate he raised about caregiving, however, has continued.
$12,000 a year versus $162,581
Commentators quickly noticed the gap between the two numbers. A $1,000 monthly payment adds up to $12,000 a year, roughly $150,000 short of the Salary.com estimate. That comparison is a little unfair to both sides. Yang's dividend was never designed as a salary for parents; it would have gone to every adult, working or not. Salary.com's figure, meanwhile, is a thought experiment about replacement cost, not a proposal for anyone to pay it.
Still, putting the two side by side made a point many parents feel strongly about: the work of raising children is enormous, and in national accounts it counts for nothing. Gross domestic product measures paid activity. A parent who cooks, cleans, drives, nurses and teaches at home adds nothing to GDP, while the same tasks done by paid workers do.
How unpaid care work is measured
Economists use two main methods to value unpaid household work. The replacement cost method asks what it would cost to hire someone to do each task, which is close to what Salary.com does. The opportunity cost method asks what the parent could have earned in paid work instead. The two can give very different answers, and both depend heavily on how many hours are counted.
The data behind these estimates usually comes from time-use surveys, where people record how they spend each part of the day. Across many countries those surveys show the same pattern: women do most of the unpaid caring and household work, a gap that research suggests widened further during the COVID-19 pandemic.
One common criticism of the Salary.com approach is that it values each task at professional rates. A parent helping with homework is not billing as a qualified teacher, and nobody hires a judge to settle a sibling squabble. That is why the estimate makes a good conversation starter but a poor basis for policy.
How other countries support families with children
Many wealthy countries pay a regular child benefit, often to every family regardless of income. A 2016 comparison published by Vox listed yearly payments for a family with two children in eleven Western European countries. The list, in US dollars at the time, was:
- Luxembourg: $8,750
- Belgium: $5,709
- Austria: $5,704
- Germany: $5,620
- Ireland: $4,060
- Sweden: $3,507
- Finland: $2,883
- Denmark: $2,794
- Norway: $2,576
- The Netherlands: $2,404
- France: $1,779
Those amounts have since changed. Germany's Kindergeld, for example, now pays €250 per child per month, and France's family allowances vary with the number and age of children. Some systems are not fully universal either: the Netherlands adds an income-tested supplement, and the UK withdraws Child Benefit from higher earners. Child benefits are also not a wage for caregiving. They go to families whether a parent stays home or not.
What the debate really comes down to
Strip away the headline number and the underlying question is simple: should a society that depends on unpaid care do more to support the people who provide it? Answers range from child benefits and paid parental leave to pension credits for years spent caring, affordable childcare and, in Yang's version, a basic income for everyone.
The $162,581 figure will never appear on anyone's payslip. Its real value is in making invisible work visible. And while the estimate is framed around mothers, the same logic applies to stay-at-home fathers and to anyone caring full time for a child or relative.
Sources: Salary.com: How much is a mom worth?; Upworthy (19 August 2019); Wikipedia: Andrew Yang; Vox comparison of European child benefits (May 2016); Wikipedia: Child benefit; Wikipedia: Unpaid work.

COMMENTS