
Stock Photos from mirtmirt/Shutterstock
Governments around the world have recently been taking extra steps to ensure the well-being of younger generations. 18-year-olds in Italy are given a “culture bonus” in order to boost their engagement with the arts. Students in Oregon are encouraged to take mental health days. In a February 2019 government statement, Singapore described removing class and level positions from students’ report books as part of changes to school-based assessment.
For years, primary and secondary school students in Singapore have been ranked according to their standardized test scores. This, though, fostered an unhealthy environment fueled by competition—a system that Education Minister Ong Ye Kung views as an inherent threat to education.
So how will students be assessed from now on? For younger students, teachers will use “qualitative descriptors” to evaluate each one’s discussion participation, homework, and other less competitive means. On the other hand, older students will still receive grades; these marks, however, will be rounded off as whole numbers and given without decimal points. With this new approach, Ong Ye Kung believes students will still find the motivation to do their best—but, hopefully, in themselves rather than in others.
Rank and feedback answer different questions
A rank tells a pupil where they sit relative to classmates, while feedback can explain what they understand and what needs more work. Those are different kinds of information. Removing a position from a report book therefore does not mean that assessment has disappeared or that a teacher has stopped identifying gaps. The 2019 report also distinguishes younger pupils' descriptive feedback from older students' numerical marks. Its broad headline should be read in that narrower context, rather than as a claim that all Singapore examinations, selection processes or academic comparisons were abolished.
What would make the change meaningful?
Consider two comments on the same piece of work: one reports a place in the class; the other identifies a sound argument and an unsupported conclusion. The second gives the pupil something to act on. A useful evaluation of a reform would look at that everyday experience: do students understand the next step, and do families receive enough information to help? It would also ask whether informal comparisons simply replace published ranks. A February 2019 government statement explicitly described removing class and level positions from report books. That establishes the historical discussion and its scope; individual assessment changes still need their specific implementation documents.

COMMENTS