Breastfeeding Mom Told to Cover Up Put the Blanket on Her Head

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-08-21.

Melanie Dudley's Cover-Up Response While Breastfeeding Went Viral

Melanie Dudley keeps nursing her baby in a Cabo San Lucas restaurant, with the blanket she was told to use draped over her own head. Photo taken by her husband.

When a man told Melanie Libson Dudley to “cover up” while she was feeding her baby in a restaurant in Cabo San Lucas, Mexico, she did exactly that, just not in the way he meant. She asked her husband to pass her the nursing cover, then put it over her own head and carried on feeding. Her husband took a photo, and within days it had been shared around the world.

Dudley, a stay-at-home mother from Austin, Texas, with four-year-old twin boys and a baby son of about three to four months, was on a family holiday in the summer of 2018. The picture went viral after a family friend posted it on Facebook at the end of July 2018, and it was covered by CBS News, ABC and Good Morning America in early August.

What happened in the restaurant

By Dudley’s account, it was a hot, humid day, about 95°F according to one interview, and she was seated with her back to the room. She had started feeding her son under a cover but took it off because it was too hot and sticky for both of them.

That was when a man asked her to cover herself because people did not want to see her breast. Reports differ slightly on who he was: one says he was part of her own dinner party, another simply describes him as a man in the restaurant. Dudley said she was speechless, and that she is usually discreet when nursing.

Rather than argue, she made her point with humour. She told her husband to hand her the cover, placed it over her face and kept feeding. She later described the move as a sarcastic gesture, not the start of a fight.

How the photo spread

Her husband’s snapshot first went to family. It was then posted publicly by Carol Lockwood, a friend of Dudley’s mother-in-law who had never actually met her. Lockwood captioned it with a simple joke: Dudley had been told to cover up, so she did. She added that she was tired of seeing women shamed for nursing and asked people to share it.

They did. ABC reported that the post was shared more than 200,000 times, and it drew tens of thousands of comments. Exact reaction counts changed by the day and varied between outlets, so they are best read as a sign of scale rather than a precise figure.

Most commenters backed Dudley, though not everyone. Some argued that a cloth is a small courtesy to strangers; others answered that a baby’s hunger comes before anyone’s discomfort. Dudley told Good Morning America that the reaction showed how many women are tired of having breastfeeding in public treated as a topic for debate.

She was not the first to try this response. In September 2017, a mother in Washington state named Nicolle Blackman went viral for doing much the same thing while feeding her two-month-old in a McDonald’s.

Why the image resonated

The photo works because it needs no explanation. A mother sits calmly with a blanket over her head while the baby feeds in plain view, and the absurdity of the request is obvious. It turned a moment that could have been humiliating into a joke shared by millions.

It also touched a widely shared experience. Many parents who breastfeed describe stares, comments or requests to move, even in places where the law clearly protects them. A light-hearted image gave people a way to talk about that without anger.

What the law says about breastfeeding in public

Every country and state has its own rules, but in much of the world nursing in public is legally protected. In Dudley’s home state of Texas, for example, the Health and Safety Code says a mother is entitled to breastfeed her baby in any location where she is otherwise allowed to be.

Laws in the United States vary by state in scope and wording, and some also cover expressing milk at work. If you are unsure of your rights while travelling, a local health service or the relevant national health ministry is the best place to check.

Breastfeeding in Mexico: the bigger picture

The incident happened in a country that has long had some of the lowest breastfeeding rates in Latin America. In 2015, reports based on national survey data said only about one in seven Mexican mothers breastfed exclusively for the first six months. That year the Mexican government banned the free distribution of baby formula in hospitals, while keeping formula available in shops and on medical request, to encourage more mothers to breastfeed.

Rates have improved since then, but slowly. According to UNICEF México, the national health and nutrition survey ENSANUT 2021–2023 found that 34.2% of babies under six months were exclusively breastfed, about one in three. UNICEF also reported that 27.2% of babies were given formula or other liquids from their first days of life, and that formula marketing remains widespread.

The World Health Organization recommends exclusive breastfeeding for the first six months where possible. At the same time, families feed their babies in many ways for many reasons, and none of them should be judged from a single photo. Anyone with questions about feeding their own child should talk to a doctor, midwife or qualified lactation consultant.

Practical tips for nursing in public

If you breastfeed and feel nervous about doing it in public, a few simple steps can help. Choose a seat where you feel comfortable, whether that is facing the room or turned away. Wear layers that are easy to adjust, and use a cover only if it suits you and your baby; in hot weather, many babies simply refuse one.

If someone comments, you do not owe them an explanation. A calm “I’m feeding my baby” is enough, and in many places staff are expected to support you rather than the person complaining. And if, like Dudley, you can find the funny side, it may defuse the moment better than any argument.

For everyone else, the lesson is even simpler. A parent feeding a hungry child is not a performance aimed at you. Looking elsewhere costs nothing.

Sources: Photo: Melanie Dudley’s husband, shared on Facebook by Carol Lockwood. CBS News, Aug 2018; ABC13, Aug 2018: Austin mom’s creative cover-up; NextBillion/BBC, Aug 2015: Mexico bans formula giveaways at hospitals; UNICEF México, May 2025; NCSL: Breastfeeding state laws; World Health Organization: Breastfeeding.

COMMENTS