Philip Alston's 'Climate Apartheid' Warning to the UN Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published July 9, 2019.

UN Expert Philip Alston Warned of “Climate Apartheid” in 2019

Konrad Bak

Headlines in 2019 claimed a UN report said "only the rich will survive" the climate crisis. That is not quite what it said. In June 2019 Philip Alston, then the UN Special Rapporteur on extreme poverty and human rights, presented a report to the UN Human Rights Council warning of a "climate apartheid": a future in which wealthy people pay to escape heat, hunger and disaster while the poor are left to bear the damage.

The report's central numbers were stark. Alston warned that climate change could push more than 120 million additional people into poverty by 2030 and could undo decades of progress on development, health and poverty reduction. Below is what the report argued, how its claims compare with other research, and what has been said since.

The stock image above, a child peering through torn sacking, is illustrative and is not connected to any person or place mentioned in the report.

Who Philip Alston is

Alston is an Australian-born international law scholar who teaches at New York University. He held the UN mandate on extreme poverty from 2014 to 2020, an independent role in which experts report to the Human Rights Council rather than speaking for the UN as a whole.

He was known for blunt language. His 2017 investigation of poverty in the United States described Los Angeles's Skid Row as concentrated human humiliation, and his 2018 visit to the United Kingdom concluded that austerity had caused great misery. The climate report, one of his final major reports, followed the same pattern: detailed, deliberately provocative and aimed at governments.

What "climate apartheid" means

The phrase describes a world split by the ability to buy protection. Richer households and companies can afford sea walls, air conditioning, backup generators, insurance, private healthcare and, if necessary, a move to somewhere safer. Poorer people often cannot, even though they have contributed least to the emissions that drive warming.

Alston's best-known example came from New York. When Hurricane Sandy struck in 2012, many low-income and vulnerable residents were left for days without electricity or access to healthcare, while the headquarters of Goldman Sachs stayed protected by its own sandbags and ran on its own generator power. His point was not that the bank did anything wrong, but that relying on private resources produces protection for those who can pay and very little for everyone else.

Migration is part of the same picture. Moving away from a drought-hit farm or a flood-prone coast costs money, and legal routes across borders are limited. People with the fewest resources are often the least able to leave.

The numbers behind the warning

According to reporting on the report by Al Jazeera, Alston cited several figures to show the scale of the problem:

  • 120 million more people in poverty by 2030 as a result of climate change, without stronger action.
  • 241 weather and climate disasters in the United States since 1980 that each caused at least $1 billion in damage, adding up to about $1.6 trillion.
  • $5.2 trillion a year in subsidies to fossil fuel industries worldwide, a figure based on an IMF estimate that includes unpriced environmental costs.

Other research supports the general direction while showing how uncertain the exact numbers are. A 2020 World Bank analysis estimated that climate change could push between 32 million and 132 million additional people into extreme poverty by 2030, depending on how development unfolds. The gap between those figures is a reminder that projections depend heavily on policy choices made now.

The unfairness Alston described is also well documented. People living in poverty account for only a small fraction of global emissions, yet developing countries suffer the overwhelming majority of deaths linked to climate-related disasters, according to the UN Development Programme.

Who Alston blamed

The report was sharply critical of governments. Alston argued that, despite scientific warnings going back to the 1970s, many states had done little more than send officials to conferences to make speeches. He said that warming thresholds once described as catastrophic now looked like best-case outcomes.

He named specific examples: China continuing to finance coal-fired power plants abroad, Brazil's then-president Jair Bolsonaro pledging to open the Amazon to mining and weaken environmental protection, and the Trump administration in the United States rolling back regulations and sidelining climate science. He also warned that leaving adaptation to the private sector would lead to large-scale human rights violations.

He did not argue that nothing was working. The report noted that emissions had fallen in dozens of countries and that thousands of cities, regions and companies had made climate commitments. His complaint was that the pace and scale fell far short of what was needed.

Common misunderstandings

"The UN said only the rich will survive." No. The warning was about unequal protection and suffering, not a forecast that every wealthy person lives and every poor person dies.

"The sun is driving recent warming." This claim still circulates. NASA notes that the amount of solar energy reaching Earth has shown no upward trend since satellite measurements began in 1978, while temperatures have risen sharply. Human greenhouse gas emissions are the main driver.

"Climate policy always hurts the poor." Carbon taxes and fuel price changes can be regressive if designed badly, which is why Alston insisted that the shift away from fossil fuels must protect people in poverty rather than load new costs onto them. Many economists argue that returning carbon revenue to households as rebates can leave lower-income families better off. Design, not the existence of climate policy, decides who pays.

What Alston proposed

Alston said the world was sleepwalking towards catastrophe and called for a "major re-engineering of the economies" and a broader societal transformation. In practice that meant cutting emissions far faster, ending subsidies to fossil fuels, investing in public infrastructure that protects everyone rather than only those who can afford private solutions, and making sure that the transition creates decent jobs instead of new hardship.

For readers, the useful takeaway is the framing. Climate change is often discussed as a single global problem, but its effects arrive through very local inequalities: who has a cool home in a heatwave, who can rebuild after a flood, who has savings to move. Seeing it through that lens makes it easier to judge which policies actually reduce harm.

Sources: Al Jazeera, June 2019: 'Climate apartheid': World's poor to suffer most from disasters; reporting by The Independent (June 2019); Wikipedia: Philip Alston; Wikipedia: Climate change and poverty; NASA: Is the Sun causing global warming?. Image: Konrad Bak via 123RF.

COMMENTS