Originally published 2019-07-17.
In July 2019 an 18-year-old posted on Reddit's relationship advice forum that the conversation he expected to be about college plans turned into something else entirely. The man he had always called Dad told him he was the result of his mother's affair and would not be paying for his studies, even though he had covered every cost for the two older siblings. The teenager had about $400 saved, no job history and no idea how loans worked. Thousands of strangers replied, and the most useful part of the thread was not the outrage but the practical help: how to apply for financial aid, what to do about health insurance and a phone plan, and how to think about a family that had suddenly changed shape.
This article retells the account in our own words, explains what the US financial aid system actually allows in a situation like this, and looks at the emotional side that so many readers recognised.
What the young man described
The poster, writing under the throwaway name u/throwawaynocollege01, explained that his brother had finished college two years earlier and his sister was halfway through, both at the same school. Their father had paid for everything: tuition, rent, food, cars and spending money. His brother now had a job, a home and a fiancée; his sister had a well-paid job and still received support.
The youngest had been accepted to that same college, which had always been the family plan. He assumed money had been set aside for him too. Instead, he was told the story of his mother's infidelity and that support would stop.
According to the post, the father said the mother had had eighteen years to prepare her son and had not done so, and that it had never been his place to interfere with her parenting. The grandparents apparently knew. The siblings did not, and were as stunned as he was.
What hurt most was the contrast with his memories. He described going to games and fishing together, being tutored in maths by the father (an engineer), learning to drive with him, and hearing him proudly explain the meaning of the name he had chosen for his son. The mother, he wrote, could only cry and apologise. He had spent days in his room, unsure whether he was still welcome at home, and asked the forum a heartbreaking question: should he apologise to his dad?
In a later edit he said comments were arriving faster than he could read them, and that he was building a list of advice on financial aid, health insurance and getting his own phone plan, "things I didn't even think about before."
Why the story struck such a nerve
Readers reacted to two separate injuries. The first is the secret itself. Discovering in adulthood that a parent is not your biological parent is now common enough that researchers and support groups have a name for it: a misattributed parentage experience, or "NPE" in many online communities. Consumer DNA tests have made such discoveries far more frequent, and people who go through them often describe grief, anger and a shaken sense of identity, even when the relationship with the parent who raised them was loving.
The second injury is the timing and the money. Being told at 18, at the exact moment of launching into adult life, that the safety net will not be there turns an emotional shock into a practical emergency. Many commenters pointed out that the young man had done nothing wrong; he was paying for adult choices made before he was born.
It is worth remembering what we cannot know. This is one anonymous, unverified post, told from one person's perspective. We do not hear from the father, the mother or the grandparents, and families in pain rarely tell the same story twice. The account is valuable less as a verdict on anyone than as a mirror for a situation many people face in some form.
Paying for college when parents will not help
Much of the best advice in the thread was about money, and it is worth setting out clearly, because the US system has a trap here. For federal aid purposes, most students under 24 are treated as dependent, which means the FAFSA application asks for parents' financial information whether or not the parents actually intend to pay. A parent simply refusing to contribute is generally not, on its own, a reason to be treated as independent.
There are still routes forward:
- Talk to the college's financial aid office early. Aid administrators can, in unusual circumstances such as abandonment or an unsafe home, grant a "dependency override." They need documentation, often letters from a counsellor, teacher or other professional.
- Ask about unsubsidized loans. If parents refuse to provide information or support, schools can in some cases allow a dependent student to receive federal Direct Unsubsidized Loans without the parents' data, although grants are not available on that basis.
- Compare cheaper starting points. A year or two at a community college while working can cut the total cost sharply, and credits often transfer.
- Look beyond federal aid. State grants, the college's own scholarships and local community scholarships all have their own rules and deadlines.
- Handle the basics. As commenters told him: get your own phone plan, know whether you are still on a parent's health insurance (in the US, children can usually stay on a parent's plan until 26 if the parent allows it), and keep copies of your ID documents.
Rules change from year to year, so the official Federal Student Aid website and the school's own aid office are the places to confirm what applies.
Should he apologise to his father?
Almost every reply gave the same answer: no. There is nothing to apologise for when you did not cause the situation. But many readers also suggested that a calm conversation could still help, framed around questions rather than blame. Does the father still see him as a son, even if he will not fund college? Is he welcome at home over the summer? Can they keep doing the things they used to do together?
Family therapists often point out that people who have carried a secret for years can say harsh things when it finally comes out, and that the first conversation is rarely the last. Some relationships recover over time; some do not. A counsellor, including the free counselling services many colleges offer, can help a young person sort through which relationships to work on and how.
The mother's role also came up repeatedly. Readers felt that apologies were not enough and that she needed to take practical responsibility now, whether that meant helping with money, paperwork or simply being present.
Common misunderstandings about situations like this
"Legally, a father has to pay for college." In most of the United States, parents have no general legal duty to pay for an adult child's college. A few states allow courts to order contributions in divorce cases, but that would not normally apply to a married couple.
"He can just declare himself independent." As explained above, independence for aid purposes depends on specific criteria, such as age, marriage, military service or being a ward of the court, or on a case-by-case override from the aid office.
"Finding out ruins the relationship with the dad forever." Not necessarily. Many people in similar circumstances say the bond with the parent who raised them remained real, even if it changed. Biology did not create the fishing trips and driving lessons the poster remembered.
What readers can take from it
If you are a parent holding a secret like this, the kindest moment to share it is earlier, with support, and never at the same time as a major financial decision. If you are a student facing college without family help, start with the aid office, keep every document, and accept that the path may be slower but is still open. And if someone you know is going through it, practical help (a spare room, a lift, help with a form) often means more than opinions about who was right.
The young man's own edit captured the turn many people hope for: within hours, strangers had given him a to-do list, and he was already working through it.
Sources: the original post by u/throwawaynocollege01 on Reddit (as first reported by Powerful Mind); Federal Student Aid (US Department of Education).
COMMENTS