Originally published 2019-05-14.

Can reading Harry Potter make people more open-minded? A peer-reviewed study published in 2015 suggests it can nudge attitudes in that direction. Researchers led by the Italian social psychologist Loris Vezzali found that young readers who engaged with the books, and especially those who identified with Harry, showed more positive attitudes toward groups that often face prejudice, such as immigrants, refugees and gay people. The effect was real but modest, and it came with conditions that are worth understanding before anyone claims that Potter fans are simply “better people”.
What the study found
The paper, titled The greatest magic of Harry Potter: Reducing prejudice, appeared in the Journal of Applied Social Psychology (volume 45, pages 105–121). Its authors were Loris Vezzali, Sofia Stathi, Dino Giovannini, Dora Capozza and Elena Trifiletti, working across universities in Italy and the United Kingdom.
According to the summary in Princeton's Prejudice Reduction database, the team ran three studies. All three pointed the same way: engagement with the Harry Potter books was linked to better attitudes toward stigmatised groups. Two factors shaped the result. Readers who identified with Harry, and readers who distanced themselves from Voldemort, showed the clearest effects. The mechanism the authors identified was perspective taking, the ability to imagine a situation from someone else's point of view.

How the three experiments worked
Study 1: primary school children in Italy
The first study was an experiment. Elementary school pupils answered a questionnaire about immigrants, then took part in weekly small-group sessions over several weeks in which they read and discussed passages from the books. One group worked with passages that deal directly with prejudice, such as the scene in which Draco Malfoy calls Hermione a “Mudblood” because her parents are not wizards. A comparison group read neutral passages, such as Harry buying his wand at Ollivanders. Afterwards, children in the prejudice-related group who identified with Harry showed improved attitudes toward immigrants.

Studies 2 and 3: teenagers and university students
The second and third studies were surveys rather than experiments. High school students in Italy and university students in the UK reported how much of the series they had read or watched, how strongly they identified with characters, and how they felt about different groups. In Italy the target group was gay people; in the UK it was refugees. Again, more engagement with Harry Potter went together with more positive attitudes, especially among those who identified with Harry or rejected Voldemort.

Why a fantasy story could change real attitudes
The research builds on one of the best-tested ideas in social psychology: the contact hypothesis. In 1954 Gordon Allport argued that, under the right conditions, contact between groups reduces prejudice. A 2006 meta-analysis by Thomas Pettigrew and Linda Tropp, covering 515 studies, broadly supported him.
Later researchers found that contact does not always need to be face to face. In “extended contact”, simply knowing that someone from your own group is friends with someone from another group can soften attitudes. Vicarious and “parasocial” contact through stories and media can work in a similar way. Vezzali's team treated reading a novel as a form of this indirect contact: you spend hundreds of pages alongside characters who befriend, defend and stand up for people who are excluded.

Harry Potter offers unusually rich material for this. The central villain is obsessed with “pure-blood” ancestry. Hermione is insulted for being Muggle-born, the Weasleys are mocked for being poor, Neville is underestimated for being awkward, Hagrid is treated with suspicion because of his giant heritage and was expelled from Hogwarts as a boy, Lupin hides being a werewolf, and house-elves are kept in servitude. The heroes form friendships across all these lines, and the story rewards them for it.

Harry himself grows up as an outsider, neglected by the Dursleys, made to sleep in a cupboard under the stairs and bullied by his cousin Dudley. Readers live inside that experience before they ever reach Hogwarts, which may be one reason identification with him mattered so much in the results.
What the study does not prove
It is easy to turn research like this into a catchy headline, so a few cautions help:
- The samples were small. Each study involved classroom-sized or modest groups, not thousands of people.
- Two of the three studies were correlational. People who are already open-minded may simply be more drawn to the books, rather than the books making them so.
- The effect depended on identification. Reading alone was not enough; it mattered how readers related to Harry and Voldemort.
- It measured attitudes, not behaviour. Answering a questionnaire more kindly is not the same as acting differently in everyday life.
- It does not grade individuals. No study can show that a particular fan is a better person than someone who never opened the books.
None of that makes the finding trivial. It fits a wider body of research suggesting that fiction which invites us into other people's experiences can make us a little more willing to see things from their side.

Using the books to talk about prejudice
For parents and teachers, the practical lesson is that discussion matters. In the Italian experiment, children did not just read; they talked about the passages in groups. A few questions can turn a favourite chapter into a conversation:
- How do you think Hermione felt when she was called a “Mudblood”, and why did that word hurt so much?
- Why do some wizards believe that blood status matters? Do we see similar ideas in the real world?
- Which characters stand up for others who are treated unfairly, and what does it cost them?
- Who is left out of the story's point of view, such as house-elves or goblins, and how might they see events?
The series also gives readers a line they can carry with them. Speaking at the end of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, as the wizarding schools prepare to part, Dumbledore says: “Differences of habit and language are nothing at all if our aims are identical and our hearts are open.”
The bottom line
A 2015 study found that engaging with Harry Potter was linked to more tolerant attitudes toward immigrants, refugees and gay people, mainly among readers who identified with Harry, and that perspective taking explained the change. It is a hopeful finding about the power of stories, best read as “fiction can help” rather than “fans are better people”.
Sources: Vezzali et al. (2015), Journal of Applied Social Psychology; Princeton Prejudice Reduction database entry; Contact hypothesis (Wikipedia). Film stills: Harry Potter films, Warner Bros.

COMMENTS