Foucault’s Pendulum: A Physicist’s Answer to a Flat-Earth Question

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

How can you show someone that the Earth is round if they refuse to trust photos from space? One of the most memorable answers on Quora came from Pedro Teles, who lists a PhD in physics from the University of Porto (2007). Instead of arguing, he sent the questioner on a trip: watch a Foucault pendulum in Paris, then repeat the experiment at the North Pole and on the equator. The way the pendulum behaves in each place only makes sense on a rotating, roughly spherical planet.

Below are screenshots of his answer, followed by an explanation of the physics, a few corrections, and other simple pieces of evidence anyone can check.

A Flat-Earth Argument and the Role of Physical Evidence

The question and the answer, screen by screen

The question was blunt: suppose I do not believe the world is round, so prove it to me. Teles answered with a step-by-step itinerary that reads like a travel guide with a physics lesson hidden inside.

The question and the trip to Paris

The world is not round?

The answer opens with detailed directions from Charles de Gaulle airport across Paris by RER and metro. The joke is deliberate: rather than asking for trust, it asks the sceptic to go and look in person.

Foucault’s pendulum at the Musée des Arts et Métiers

Foucault’s Pendulum

The destination is the Musée des Arts et Métiers, home of a Foucault pendulum. Teles explains that Léon Foucault built the device in 1851 as an easy way to show that the Earth turns on its axis, and that the swing slowly turns clockwise as you watch.

Still sceptical? Wait a day

Skeptical

Stay long enough, he says, and the swing will complete a full circle in a little over a day, about 31 to 32 hours at the latitude of Paris. Then he raises the stakes: fly to Oslo and join an expedition to the North Pole.

The North Pole

North Pole

At the pole the same experiment completes its turn in about one day. The rate has changed simply because you moved north, which is the first big clue.

The equator

Foucault’s Experiment

Next stop is São Tomé and Príncipe, an island nation on the equator. Here the pendulum’s swing does not rotate at all.

The explanation, and a question about the South Pole

A Flat-Earth Argument and the Role of Physical Evidence

Finally he gives the rule: the rate of rotation depends on the sine of the latitude. That is why the turn takes longer than a day in Paris, about a day at the pole, and never happens at the equator. He ends by asking what would happen at the South Pole.

How a Foucault pendulum works

A Foucault pendulum is a heavy weight hung from a very long wire that is free to swing in any direction. Once it is set moving, nothing pushes it sideways, so the direction of its swing stays fixed relative to the distant stars. The Earth, however, keeps turning underneath it. To a person standing on the floor, it looks as though the pendulum’s swing is slowly rotating, knocking over small pegs arranged in a circle.

Léon Foucault made the first famous public demonstration in 1851. At the Panthéon in Paris he hung a 28-kilogram bob from a wire 67 metres long. Visitors could see the plane of the swing turn clockwise at about 11 degrees per hour, which works out to roughly 32 hours for a complete circle.

The key detail is that the rate changes with latitude. At the North Pole the floor turns once underneath the pendulum every sidereal day (about 23 hours 56 minutes), so the swing appears to make one full clockwise turn. At the equator the floor does not twist underneath the pendulum, so there is no turning at all. In between, the time for a full circle equals one sidereal day divided by the sine of the latitude.

Small corrections to the viral version

The answer is entertaining and its physics is sound, but a few details are worth putting straight.

  • The name. Many reposts called him “Dr. Petro Teles”. His Quora profile, shown in the screenshots, reads Pedro Teles.
  • Which pendulum is the original. The answer says the original is in the Panthéon. In fact Foucault’s original bob was moved to the Conservatoire des Arts et Métiers in 1855, and an exact copy has swung under the Panthéon dome since 1995. In April 2010 the cable of the museum’s pendulum snapped and the original bob was badly damaged; it is now displayed in a case beside the current pendulum.
  • Coriolis “force”. Physicists describe the pendulum’s apparent turn as a Coriolis effect, which is not a real push but a result of observing from a rotating floor. The effect is the same either way.
  • What it proves. Strictly, the pendulum demonstrates rotation. It is the pattern across latitudes, together with the opposite direction in the south, that fits a rotating sphere and does not fit a flat disc.

What happens at the South Pole?

This was Teles’s bonus question, and the answer is the strongest part of the argument. In the Southern Hemisphere the swing turns counterclockwise instead of clockwise. At 30 degrees south, for example, the full circle takes two days. At the South Pole it takes about one day, in the opposite direction to the North Pole.

This has actually been tested. Researchers at the Amundsen-Scott South Pole Station hung a pendulum 33 metres long, with a 25-kilogram bob, in a stairwell of a new station building, where there were no air currents to disturb it. They confirmed a rotation period of about 24 hours.

Popular flat-Earth maps place the North Pole at the centre of a disc and spread Antarctica around the rim as an ice wall. On such a map there is no single south pole, so there is no place where a pendulum could turn once a day counterclockwise. A sphere predicts exactly what is observed.

Other evidence you can check yourself

You do not need a museum or a polar expedition. Several other observations point to the same conclusion:

  • Lunar eclipses. When the Earth’s shadow falls on the Moon, its edge is always curved, whatever the time of night. Only a sphere casts a round shadow from every angle.
  • Different stars in different places. Travellers heading south see new constellations rise over the horizon while familiar northern ones sink out of view.
  • Ships and distant coasts. With binoculars, the lower parts of faraway ships and buildings disappear first behind the curve of the sea.
  • Time zones. When it is noon in one country, it is night on the other side of the world, which is easy to confirm with a video call.
  • Circumnavigation. The expedition begun by Magellan and completed by Elcano sailed around the world between 1519 and 1522, and countless flights and voyages have done so since.

Scientists add one refinement: the Earth is not a perfect ball. Its spin makes it bulge slightly at the equator, so it is an oblate spheroid, flattened by about one part in 298.

Why this answer persuades better than a put-down

Much of the online coverage framed the exchange as a professor “destroying” a flat-Earther. That misses what makes the answer good. It does not mock the questioner or ask them to trust authority. It describes an experiment, says what you would see, and invites you to check. Each step can be repeated by anyone with enough patience.

That is how science works at its best: a claim makes predictions, and observations either match or they do not. If you want to talk with someone who doubts the shape of the Earth, offering a test they can watch with their own eyes will usually get further than winning the argument. For more on the elegance behind physical laws, see Beautiful Equations: Looking Beyond the Symbols.

Sources: Screenshots of Pedro Teles’s answer on Quora; first shared by Rear Front and Truth Theory; Wikipedia: Foucault pendulum; Wikipedia: Spherical Earth.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 2
  1. The "Foucault pendulum" is just a FREEMASONIC HOAX. This has been exposed and debunked.
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JlkeVHfAEfA

    ReplyDelete
  2. Your brain is a freemasonic hoax.

    ReplyDelete