This 'Lyric Discussion' Patent Is The Craziest Thing We've Seen

This 'Lyric Discussion' Patent Is The Craziest Thing We've Seen

Have you ever discussed the lyrics of a song you liked with a friend? Perhaps that discussion took place online? It may surprise you to discover that you have gotten pretty darn close to infringing a US patent.


In January 2019, EFF's Stupid Patent of the Month feature has singled out Patent No. 9,401,941, owned by CBS Interactive, that has claimed its monopoly to "processing user interactions with song lyrics." The patent's great reveal is a "computer-implemented system" for "processing interactions with song lyrics." Supposedly, that adds to existing technology by allowing a user to select particular parts of songs, see a menu, and then write an interpretation of a selected line.


Even if such an idea was patent-worthy, there were of course already websites offering the feature before the patent's priority date of 2011. The most notable is maybe Rap Genius, a site founded in 2009 that is now merely called Genius.


The patent examiner pointed out Rap Genius to the applicant, compelling CBS lawyers to narrow their claims. They added a clause saying their technology would suggest comments to users based on what type of comments have been written in the past. This narrower definition is unlikely to be infringed by many lyrics sites. However, even the narrower definition should not have resulted in a patent grant, argues EFF lawyer Daniel Nazer, who wrote the blog post.


This 'Lyric Discussion' Patent Is The Craziest Thing We've Seen

Some observations, according to Medium:


  • The patent name is Song lyric processing with user interaction. Rather vague and all-encompassing.
  • It claims the invention of a method to provide to the client device the lyrics for display. All lyrics websites on the web in some way.
  • It claims the invention of methods to process these annotations to display the ‘right’ one to another user and extract valuable insights.
  • It also claims the invention of methods to allow selecting a segment of the lyric and annotating them with meanings, interpretations, ‘mishearings’, sharing on social media. There go Musixmatch and Rapgenius.
  • Many complicated figures like this one below:

This 'Lyric Discussion' Patent Is The Craziest Thing We've Seen

Faced with the prospect of a never-ending search for an exact list of features proposed by the applicant, the examiner eventually gives up and grants the patent. This might be what happened here.


Aside from older technology, the patent which was filed in 2015, should have been rejected under the Supreme Court's Alice precedent, Nazer argues. It is a series of routine Web development decisions, and that is precisely the type of "generic" computer technology the 2014 Alice decision should've rendered unpatentable.


The "song discussions" patent is listed at the bottom of songs published by MetroLyrics, a site which was acquired by CBS Interactive in 2011.

This 'Lyric Discussion' Patent Is The Craziest Thing We've Seen This 'Lyric Discussion' Patent Is The Craziest Thing We've Seen Reviewed by Katerina Papakyriakopoulou on 4:49 AM Rating: 5

7 comments

  1. if you are looking for technical assistance for your laptop then you can contact Geek squad Support for help. They have the best agents who can help you to sort your issues with the best possible solution. You can contact geek Squad support through helpline no. or you can chat with an agent.you can visit this for further details.
    https://customerservices.us/geek-squad-tech-support/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I hope you continue to have such quality articles to share with everyone! I believe a lot of people will be like to read this article!
      By LyricSoUp

      Delete
  2. Hey everyone!
    Today I come to you with so much excitement!
    My Ex and I broke up 1 year and 2 months ago and i was six months pregnant. We both love each other and it was a shock to me and it really broke my heart. I tried to call him and both of his lines were disconnected. I tried to reach him on social networks but he deleted me off of them. I tried to reach his parents and they told me that their son said that he does not love me and does not want to see me and they do not know what is wrong. I cried and cried everyday because I loved him very much. Until I gave birth and the baby was one year old, I could not get my love back. Again, I was confused. I do not know what to do and I also lost my job and I have no money to take care of the baby. I was miserable in life so I cried to my sister and told her my problem and said that she knew of one powerful spell caster that helped her when she could not get pregnant. I contacted him by email and he said he will help me and told me that a woman cast a spell upon my man and said he will help me break the spell so my man will come back to me and be mine forever. It was a great surprise to me that everything that he said came to pass. My man came back to me immediately, saying that I should forgive him. I am sending a very big thank you to this powerful and real spell caster. I pray for him to live long and do more of his wonderful work. If you have any kind of problem disturbing you in life, you have to contact this powerful spell caster! He can help you. He will not disappoint you, I give you 100% guarantee that he will help you, Here’s his contact:
    Email him at: Ahmedutimate@gmail.com
    Call or Whats-app him: +2348160153829

    ReplyDelete
  3. I am looking for some good blog sites for studying. I was searching for search engines and found your blog site bouncing balls , red ball

    ReplyDelete
  4. The 53rd Academy of Country Music Awards™ take place tonight. Here's how you can watch the ACM Awards 2019 Live via live ACM Awards 2019 Live Streamor TV as country music

    superstar Reba McEntire hosts the annual awards show. The ACM Awards will be broadcast live from

    MGM Grand Garden Arena in Las Vegas on Sunday, April 15 on CBS at 8/7c. ACM Awards 2019 Live Streaming The show will include

    performances by country favorites Carrie Underwood, Jason Aldean, Kelsea Ballerini, Dierks

    Bentley, Luke Bryan, Florida Georgia Line, Miranda Lambert, Maren Morris and Thomas Rhett. The

    country music awards show will be live from Las Vegas tonight. ACM Awards 2019 Live Stream It's been just over six

    months since Aldean's performance at a music festival was tragically cut short, when a gunman

    opened fire on the crowd from the 32nd floor of the Mandalay Bay hotel.Jason Aldean talked to

    CBS News' Vlad Duthiers on Friday and talked about returning to Las Vegas for the ACM Awards 2019 Live Aldean had been on stage when the shooting started.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks for this useful information, Really amazing. Thanks again Regard-bluehost review

    ReplyDelete
  6. The most notable is maybe Rap Genius, a site founded in 2009 that is now merely called Genius. 7495X exam dumps

    ReplyDelete

Don't show again. Close

Like us on Facebook?