Western Monarch Butterfly Decline: The Counts Since the 1980s

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-02-07.

Western Monarch Decline: Understanding the Historical Count

The western monarch butterfly, the population that spends winter along the California coast, has fallen by more than 99% at its worst since the 1980s. Volunteers with the Xerces Society counted just 28,429 monarchs at overwintering sites over Thanksgiving 2018, compared with an estimated 4.5 million in the 1980s. Two years later the count dropped below 2,000. Numbers have since swung wildly, with partial recoveries followed by new lows, and in December 2024 the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service proposed listing the monarch as a threatened species.

That is a serious warning, but it is not the same as the whole species being extinct or certain to vanish. Here is what the counts measure, what is driving the decline, and what anyone can do to help.

Two migrations, one species

North American monarchs are famous for migrating thousands of kilometres. They fall into two broad groups. Monarchs east of the Rocky Mountains fly to the mountain forests of central Mexico for the winter. Monarchs west of the Rockies mostly gather in groves along the coast of central and southern California, clustering on eucalyptus, pine and cypress trees in their thousands. Despite the different routes, there is no genetic difference between the two groups.

That distinction matters when you read the headlines. The dramatic 2018 figures describe the western population at California sites, not every monarch in North America. The eastern population has also declined, but it is far larger.

How the western monarch count works

The Xerces Society for Invertebrate Conservation coordinates the Western Monarch Count, which began in 1997. Each year volunteers visit known overwintering sites and estimate how many butterflies are clustered there. In 2018, its 22nd season, volunteers covered more than 200 sites. A second count around New Year shows how the population changes through the winter.

Because the same method is repeated at the same places, the count is a good guide to trends, even though it cannot tally every butterfly. Comparing like with like, one year's Thanksgiving count against another's, is the fairest way to read it.

The numbers, year by year

  • 1980s: an estimated 4.5 million western monarchs.
  • 1997: more than 1 million.
  • 2017: about 192,000.
  • 2018: 28,429, roughly 0.6% of the historic figure and an 86% fall in a single year.
  • 2020: fewer than 2,000, the lowest on record.
  • 2021 to 2023: a surprising rebound to 247,246, then 335,479, then 233,394.
  • 2024: 9,119, the second-lowest total since the count began.
  • 2025: about 12,260, according to figures summarised on Wikipedia.

Xerces said the 2018 total had already dropped below the level projected as a threshold for the collapse of the western migration. Biologist Emma Pelton, who oversees the survey, told reporters: "We think this is a huge wake-up call." The rebound after 2020 showed the population can bounce back in good years, but the later crashes show how fragile it remains.

Why monarchs are declining

No single cause explains the losses. Scientists point to several pressures acting together:

  • Loss of milkweed. Monarch caterpillars can only eat milkweed. Widespread herbicide use on crops, including herbicide-tolerant corn and soybeans, has removed much of it from farmland, especially in the U.S. Midwest.
  • Habitat loss and damage. Development, logging and changes to overwintering groves remove the places monarchs breed, feed and shelter. In Mexico, illegal logging of oyamel fir forests has been a long-standing problem.
  • Pesticides. Insecticides can kill caterpillars and adults directly.
  • Climate and weather. In 2018 the West saw drought, late storms and a severe wildfire season with heavy smoke. Extreme weather during migration can be devastating.
  • Disease and parasites. These can spread faster where monarchs breed in the same place all year.

The eastern population shows the same mix of threats. The area of Mexican forest occupied by wintering monarchs fell to just 0.67 hectares in the winter of 2013-14, against a historical average of about 6, and was measured at 2.93 hectares in 2025-26.

Is the monarch going extinct?

The species as a whole is not extinct, and it lives in many parts of the world beyond North America. The worry is about the migrating North American populations, especially the western one. When it proposed the threatened listing in December 2024, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service estimated a 99% probability that the western population would go extinct within 60 years, and a 56-74% probability for the eastern population. The proposal included critical habitat in seven units along the California coast, and the public comment period closed in May 2025. You can check the agency's monarch page for the current status of the listing.

Some reports described the monarch as caught in an "extinction vortex," where a population becomes so small that it struggles to recover. That is a real risk for very small populations, but the swings since 2018 show it is not yet a foregone conclusion.

The bigger picture

Many scientists describe the present as a period in which human activity is the dominant force shaping the planet, often called the Anthropocene. The term is widely used, although geologists' formal bodies decided in 2024 not to adopt it as an official epoch. Whatever the label, monarchs are a visible example of how farming, building and climate change add up for wildlife.

How you can help monarchs

  • Plant native milkweed and nectar flowers suited to your region. In coastal California, experts discourage planting tropical milkweed, which can encourage butterflies to breed through winter and spread parasites.
  • Avoid pesticides in your garden, especially systemic insecticides.
  • Volunteer for the count. The Western Monarch Count trains volunteers each year, and you can report sightings of monarchs, caterpillars and milkweed to community science projects.
  • Protect overwintering groves. Support local efforts to keep and manage the trees monarchs use, even when they are non-native eucalyptus.
  • Back conservation groups such as the Xerces Society that work with farmers and cities to restore habitat.

Small gardens add up. A patch of native milkweed and flowers along a migration route can give monarchs places to lay eggs and refuel, and the count shows that in a good year, numbers can climb quickly when conditions allow.

Sources: Xerces Society: Western Monarch New Year's Count (2019); Yale Environment 360: Western U.S. monarch population declined sharply in 2018; Monarch Joint Venture: 2020 Thanksgiving Count; DTN Progressive Farmer: monarch count nears record low (February 2025); Wikipedia: Monarch butterfly; Wikipedia: Monarch butterfly conservation in California.

COMMENTS