A Thought Experiment in the Abortion Debate

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-02-22.

An argument's assumptions matter

The question is designed to test moral intuitions. It can clarify priorities without logically settling every legal, medical or ethical issue in the debate.

A Thought Experiment in the Abortion Debate

One of the main arguments used by ‘pro-lifers’ in the fierce abortion debate is one we have all heard before – ‘life begins at conception.’ Whereas scientists and lawmakers are still at odds concerning how exactly the ‘beginning of life‘ is determined, the greatest issue at hand remains that people think they're entitled to tell others what to do with their own bodies, without being that interested in dealing with the aftermath. When we see pro-lifers adopting several of the disadvantaged children they so desperately wanted to be born, then we will talk about hearing out their side.


The idea of people claiming to be ‘pro-life,’ but only being pro-childbirth and pro-dominance-over-female-bodies is central to a Twitter argument from The Ark Trilogy author Patrick S. Tomlinson that went viral after he posted it in October 2017. In a thread of just nine tweets, Tomlinson proposes a simple question that is intended to challenge a particular argument about the moral status of embryos.


Scroll down below to find out what he wrote, and let us know if you agree with his point of view in the comments.


More info: Twitter


An argument's assumptions matter

An argument's assumptions matter

An argument's assumptions matter

An argument's assumptions matter

An argument's assumptions matter

An argument's assumptions matter

An argument's assumptions matter

An argument's assumptions matter

An argument's assumptions matter

An argument's assumptions matter

An argument's assumptions matter

Of course, he was challenged, resulting in a few intense rebuttals:

An argument's assumptions matter

An argument's assumptions matter

An argument's assumptions matter

An argument's assumptions matter

Others, however, completely supported his message:

An argument's assumptions matter

An argument's assumptions matter

An argument's assumptions matter

An argument's assumptions matter

A hypothetical isolates one choice rather than the entire debate

Tomlinson’s scenario asks readers to compare priorities under a constructed set of conditions. A response can reveal a moral intuition, but additional conclusions depend on the assumptions used to connect that intuition with law or medical practice. Presenting the argument clearly is more useful than declaring in advance that nobody on the other side can answer.

The scenario Tomlinson posed

Tomlinson posted the scenario as a series of tweets on 17 October 2017. You are in a fertility clinic when a fire alarm sounds. Behind one door a five-year-old child is crying for help; in another corner is a frozen container labelled “1000 Viable Human Embryos”. You can save only one before the smoke overcomes you, and there is no third option. Tomlinson said he had been asking the question for about ten years and that “no one has EVER answered it honestly”. Critics replied that it was a loaded question; the RedState writer Jim Jamitis, for example, said he would save the child but disputed Tomlinson’s framing.

Sources: RedState, 17 October 2017: Pro-abort author asks dumb question, declares victory over pro-life movement

COMMENTS