Why Japan Left the IWC and Resumed Commercial Whaling

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-01-12.

Japan's 2019 Return to Commercial Whaling

On 26 December 2018 the Japanese government announced that it would leave the International Whaling Commission (IWC). The withdrawal took effect at the end of June 2019, and on 1 July 2019 Japanese boats set out on the country's first openly commercial whale hunts in more than three decades. At the same time Japan ended the long-running Antarctic expeditions it had carried out under the label of scientific research. The hunts now take place only in Japan's territorial waters and its exclusive economic zone.

This article explains what changed, why Japan made the move, why whales matter for healthy oceans, how other countries reacted and what has happened since.

What Japan decided and when

The IWC was set up in 1946 to manage whale stocks. As many populations collapsed under industrial hunting, its members voted in 1982 for a pause on commercial whaling, which took effect from the 1986 season. Japan initially objected, then withdrew its objection and ended commercial hunts by 1988.

It did not stop whaling altogether. Article VIII of the whaling convention lets governments issue special permits to kill whales for research, and Japan used that rule for about thirty years, catching several hundred whales in a typical season. The meat was sold in Japan afterwards, which the convention also allows, and critics argued that the research was a cover for a commercial trade.

At the IWC meeting in Florianópolis, Brazil, in September 2018, Japan proposed reopening commercial catches of species it considered abundant and creating a separate committee on sustainable whaling. The proposal was voted down. Three months later Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshihide Suga, who later became prime minister, announced the withdrawal, arguing that the commission had lost sight of its original purpose of managing whaling and now focused only on protection.

When hunting resumed in July 2019, the first two minke whales were landed at the port of Kushiro in Hokkaido. The quota for the rest of that year was 227 animals, made up of minke, Bryde's and sei whales.

How "scientific whaling" ended up in court

Japan's research programmes in the Southern Ocean, known as JARPA and later JARPA II, were the most controversial part of its whaling. In 2010 Australia took Japan to the International Court of Justice, with New Zealand joining the case. On 31 March 2014 the court ruled by 12 votes to 4 that JARPA II was not being carried out for purposes of scientific research and ordered Japan to stop issuing permits under it.

Japan cancelled that season's Antarctic hunt but returned with a redesigned programme, NEWREP-A, which planned a smaller catch of about 333 minke whales a year. Leaving the IWC in 2019 ended the need for this research framework. In a sense, the move swapped a disputed hunt in distant international waters for an openly commercial one closer to home.

Japan's 2019 Return to Commercial WhalingGraphic photo: tap or click to view
Pilot whales killed during a traditional drive hunt (grindadráp) near Tórshavn in the Faroe Islands on 23 July 2010. These photos show the Faroese hunt, not Japanese whaling; they illustrate how contentious whale hunting remains in several countries.

Why whales matter to the ocean

Large whales are far more than an emblem of conservation. Scientists have documented several ways in which they keep marine ecosystems productive.

  • The "whale pump". Whales often feed at depth but release waste near the surface. Their faeces are rich in nitrogen and iron, nutrients that are scarce in surface waters and that phytoplankton need to grow. A 2010 study by Joe Roman and James McCarthy in the Gulf of Maine estimated that, before commercial hunting cut their numbers, marine mammals recycled nitrogen there at roughly three times the rate at which it was fixed from the atmosphere.
  • Feeding the base of the food chain. Phytoplankton are tiny algae that produce a large share of the oxygen generated on Earth each year and form the base of marine food webs. More phytoplankton means more krill and more fish.
  • Storing carbon. Iron from whale waste stimulates plankton blooms; when the plankton die and sink, some of their carbon is locked away in the deep ocean. When a whale dies and sinks, its huge body also carries carbon to the sea floor, where it feeds entire communities of deep-sea life for years.

The idea that whales compete with fishermen for food, sometimes used to justify hunting, is not supported by this research. Roman and McCarthy argued that removing whales may in fact reduce the productivity of fishing grounds.

Is whale meat still popular in Japan?

Whale meat was an important source of protein in the hungry years after the Second World War and appeared in school lunches for decades. Consumption has since fallen dramatically. Japanese media, including the Asahi Shimbun, reported in 2018 that whale meat made up only about 0.1 percent of the meat eaten in the country, and surveys suggest that few Japanese people eat it regularly.

Supporters of whaling describe it as a cultural tradition, particularly in coastal towns such as Taiji, Ayukawa and Shimonoseki, where small-scale hunts have centuries of history. Opponents point out that the modern deep-sea industry is a twentieth-century creation and that it relies on government subsidies; in 2019, about 5.1 billion yen was set aside to support it.

Japan's 2019 Return to Commercial WhalingGraphic photo: tap or click to view
Spectators and hunters on the shore during the same 2010 Faroese pilot whale hunt, where the water turns red as the animals are killed. The Faroe Islands are not IWC members and regulate this hunt themselves.

How the world reacted

The withdrawal drew immediate criticism. Australia's foreign and environment ministers, Marise Payne and Melissa Price, issued a joint statement saying the government was extremely disappointed and urging Japan to return to the commission. Greenpeace Japan warned that the decision would harm the country's image ahead of the G20 summit it hosted in Osaka in June 2019, and conservation groups in Europe and New Zealand voiced similar concerns.

Japan is not alone in rejecting the moratorium. Norway lodged a formal objection and continues commercial whaling, while Iceland hunted under a reservation for many years. Japan also remains bound by the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, which requires countries to work through an appropriate international body when managing whales, and it continues to attend IWC meetings as an observer.

What has happened since 2019

Japan has kept hunting within its own waters each season. In 2024 its whalers reported catching 179 Bryde's whales, 87 minke whales, 30 fin whales and 25 sei whales. The addition of fin whales, the second-largest whale species, drew fresh criticism from conservationists, since fin whales are listed as vulnerable worldwide.

The fears that other countries would follow Japan out of the IWC have so far not materialised. The commission remains the main forum for whale conservation, and the moratorium is still in place for its members.

Common myths about the whaling debate

  • "All whales are endangered." Not so. Some, such as the North Atlantic right whale, are critically endangered, while others, including the common minke whale, are numerous. Many populations nevertheless remain well below their size before industrial whaling.
  • "Japan hunted for fifty years under the research rule." Its research permits ran from 1987 to 2019, roughly thirty years.
  • "The famous red-water photos come from Japan." Many widely shared images, including those above, show the Faroe Islands hunt, which is a separate tradition with its own rules.
  • "Commercial whaling is now legal everywhere." The IWC moratorium still applies to its members. Japan's change applies only to its own waters.

Whatever your view on whaling, the 2019 decision is a useful case study in how international agreements, national pride, food traditions and ocean science collide. It also shows that the future of the great whales depends less on any single country and more on whether nations keep cooperating.

Sources: Wikipedia: Whaling in Japan; Wikipedia: Whale pump (citing Roman & McCarthy, PLOS ONE, 2010); NOAA Fisheries: North Atlantic right whale; images: Sergio Lacueva / 123RF; original reporting via Truth Theory.

COMMENTS