DNA Kits as Christmas Gifts: A Reddit Family Secret Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published January 5, 2019.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

Around Christmas 2018, a Reddit user posted in the r/TIFU forum ("today I messed up") about buying AncestryDNA kits for both parents and all four children as Christmas Eve presents. Their mother panicked as soon as the boxes were opened, the parents spent the evening arguing upstairs, and the siblings sat downstairs wondering which of them had a different father. A day later came an update with a gentler ending: one sister's biological father had died shortly after she was born, and the mother had never found the strength to tell the children.

The thread drew thousands of replies, many of them jokes and many of them true stories of family secrets uncovered by consumer DNA tests. Below we walk through the original post and the most telling comments, each with a note on what it shows, followed by what genetics actually says about these surprises and a short checklist to read before you give anyone a DNA kit. The story is anonymous and could not be independently verified, so treat it as one family's account rather than a documented case.

The Christmas post and its update

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

Steve Garfield

A saliva collection tube of the kind used by consumer DNA kits, photographed by Steve Garfield. You spit into the tube, seal it with a stabilising liquid and post it to a lab, which reads hundreds of thousands of genetic markers and compares them with other customers.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

The first part of the post. The writer bought six kits during a sale. When everyone opened them together, the mother objected first that the kits contained unsafe chemicals and then that only one child needed to test because siblings would get identical results. Both claims are wrong: the kits contain no hazard to speak of, and brothers and sisters inherit different halves of each parent's DNA, so full siblings share only about half their DNA on average.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

An hour later the parents were still arguing and the children were trying to work out who had a different dad. The first update said the siblings had not yet decided whether to take the tests and that they would love one another and their parents whatever the results.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

The second update revealed the secret. One sister's father had died soon after her birth, and a close friend who supported the mother through that loss became her partner and the father of the other children. The family spent the next evening looking at old photos together, and everyone decided to test after all. The writer signed off with a blunt joke aimed at commenters who had assumed the worst.

Readers who found secrets of their own

Many replies came from people whose own tests had redrawn the family tree. Their stories are anonymous, but the patterns they describe are well documented.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

Reddit user ebroms describes the reverse surprise. A cousin match revealed that an uncle's youngest daughter, whom he had doubted for decades, really was his child. DNA can settle old suspicions in both directions.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User dman4835 tells how his father opted in to see close matches and was contacted by a stranger more than a thousand miles away who matched as a cousin. When she sent a photo, the resemblance to a relative pointed to a family secret. Opting in to matching is what makes such contact possible.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User thundergun661 describes relatives whose eldest daughter, now in her thirties, learned through 23andMe that her father was not her biological father, which ended in a divorce. When the mother was young, home DNA tests did not exist, a point many commenters made: secrets kept in the 1980s were never expected to face this technology.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User Runbunnierun reports that kits showed her husband's grandfather was not his biological grandfather, which also explained why her mother-in-law never resembled her sisters. Testing one person can expose a secret two or three generations back.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User lunchladyshand recalls her mother buying kits for two sisters but not her, insisting the results would be the same, and shutting down the question sharply. It echoes the mother in the original post and the false idea that siblings are genetic copies.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User foofad found a half-uncle through a 12.5% DNA match and learned that a grandmother had raised her own son as her younger brother. In an edit, the writer asked readers not to judge a woman who lived through the Second World War and post-war Europe, and to be gentle about family adoption stories from harder times. It is one of the most humane comments in the thread.

Heritage myths the tests exposed

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User clearlyok writes that their mother's family claimed a Cherokee grandfather, yet the test found no Native American ancestry, and the father now dismisses the tests. Family stories of Cherokee ancestry are very common in the United States and often unsupported, but ethnicity estimates are also imperfect, especially for smaller or under-sampled populations.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User MollyThreeGuns gave parents kits and found that their proud French and Cherokee heritage came back as Irish and English. Her father declared the results wrong. Continental-level estimates are generally reliable; finer breakdowns can shift between companies and updates.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User Secstornado suddenly remembers a mother who called a kit a waste of money because you could simply average the parents' results. That would not work: each child inherits a random half of each parent's DNA, so averaging parents does not give you your own result.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

The same user claimed to work at AncestryDNA and said this kind of discovery happens all the time. The claim is unverified, though research shows such surprises are real and not rare among millions of testers.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User fabsterpal pointed out that the mother's story about dangerous chemicals made the post more believable, because it is just the kind of excuse someone invents on the spot.

The jokes

Reddit being Reddit, the thread was also full of dark humour. Some of it is crude, but it shows how people use jokes to cope with a story that touches a nerve.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User NixonCarmichael joked that people who had affairs in the 1980s and 1990s never imagined a saliva tube would catch up with them.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User TooShiftyForYou offered the most popular kind of reassurance: given the parents' reaction, the gift was not the real mistake here.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

A three-word reply from user DocWsky, read as pure enjoyment of the family drama unfolding on Christmas Eve.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User NoelGalaga ranked the possibilities from best case to worst, ending with every child having a different father, a joke that played on the siblings' downstairs guessing game.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User l1ttlel4dy admitted to giggling at the line about the children trying to work out who had a different dad, the detail most readers quoted back.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User iron-while-wearing pictured the siblings in a circle comparing noses, a scene of tipsy amateur genetics that drew more than 33,000 upvotes.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User PerilousAll flipped the game around, suggesting the real question might be which child was not a surprise.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User M0shka joked that the nose might not be the most obvious clue in the family, a gag about evidence hiding in plain sight.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User Beardedrugbymonster wondered whether divorce lawyers run holiday specials.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

Another commenter made a crude joke about the writer's mother, the kind of reply the update's closing line pushed back against once the real story came out.

A Family DNA-Gift Story Raises Questions About Consent and Surprises

User TooShiftyForYou returned with a pun: a DNA report showing a higher Alzheimer's risk that they have been trying to forget ever since. Some tests do report genetic risk markers, which is another reason to think before you test.

What genetics says about family surprises

When a person's presumed father turns out not to be their biological father, genealogists call it a non-paternity event, or more broadly misattributed parentage. It is often imagined to be very common, and a figure of 30% still circulates. Geneticists Turi King and Mark Jobling called that number an urban myth; their estimate is closer to 2%. A large Swedish study published in 2022 put rates between about 0.4% and 5.9% depending on the group, and about 3% of nearly 24,000 FamilyTreeDNA customers surveyed in the US reported such a finding.

The causes are varied: donor conception, closed adoptions, mix-ups in fertility treatment, relationships outside a marriage, and sometimes abuse. As the original post shows, a family secret is not always a scandal. It can be grief that a parent could not talk about.

Consumer tests reveal these situations mainly through relative matching, the list of other customers who share DNA with you and their predicted relationship. A missing expected parent or an unexpected close relative is usually the first clue. Ethnicity percentages, by contrast, are estimates built from reference populations; they are reasonable at continental level but less reliable for specific countries or tribes, and tribal membership in the US is decided by tribes through documentation, not by DNA tests.

Before you give a DNA kit as a gift

  • Ask first. A DNA test is a decision about someone's own data. Let them choose rather than presenting it as a surprise in front of the family.
  • Talk about matching. Relative-matching features are usually opt-in. Each person can decide whether to see matches and whether to be visible to others.
  • Read the privacy settings. Check how the company stores samples and data, and whether data can be shared for research. Law enforcement has used some genealogy databases, notably in the 2018 Golden State Killer case.
  • Remember your results involve relatives. Your DNA reveals information about parents, siblings and cousins who did not take the test.
  • Have a plan for surprises. If results raise questions about parentage or health, take time before confronting anyone. Genetic counsellors can help explain results, and for any health report, talk to a doctor.

The family in this story had a happy ending, helped by a mother who eventually shared her past and children who chose kindness. Not every family is so lucky, which is why a conversation before the test is worth more than any surprise under the tree.

Sources: Original post on Reddit r/tifu (anonymous; not independently verified); comments by the Reddit users named under each screenshot. Photo of saliva tube by Steve Garfield on Flickr. Background: Wikipedia: Non-paternity event; Wikipedia: Genealogical DNA test.

COMMENTS