Kwinana's Drainage Nets: How Stormwater Litter Traps Work

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Kwinana's Drainage Nets: Catching Litter at an Outlet

How do you stop street litter from reaching rivers and wetlands? One of the cheapest answers is surprisingly low-tech: hang a strong net over the end of the drainage pipe. In March 2018 the City of Kwinana, south of Perth in Western Australia, fitted two of these nets at Henley Reserve. By August they had caught about 370 kilograms (around 815 pounds) of rubbish, and the city reported that no animals had been trapped.

A photo of one of the bulging nets went viral that August, and the idea has been shared around the world ever since. Here is how these litter traps work, what they cost, what happens to the rubbish, and where their limits lie.

What Kwinana installed and what it caught

Kwinana is a local government area about 38 kilometres south of Perth's city centre, home to around 46,000 people and one of Western Australia's biggest industrial zones. Henley Reserve is a stretch of bushland and wetland where stormwater from surrounding streets is piped out into the natural environment.

According to Mayor Carol Adams, quoted by the World Economic Forum, the two nets sit on the outlets of drainage pipes that run between residential areas and the reserve. Their job is to catch what engineers call gross pollutants: bottles, cans, wrappers, bags, leaves and other debris that rain washes off the roads.

Kwinana's Drainage Nets: Catching Litter at an Outlet

Kwinana's Drainage Nets: Catching Litter at an Outlet

The pictures above show how such a net looks in practice. A metal ring clamps to the end of the pipe and a long mesh sack hangs from it. Water flows through the mesh while solid litter stays behind, so the sack slowly fills like a vacuum-cleaner bag.

The results surprised the city. In roughly five months the pair collected 370 kilograms of waste, material that would otherwise have ended up in the reserve and possibly downstream. Adams said no wildlife had been caught in either net, which answered one of the first worries people raised online.

How a stormwater net trap works

Most towns have two separate systems under the streets. Sewage goes to treatment plants, but stormwater, the rain that runs off roofs, roads and car parks, usually flows straight to creeks, rivers, wetlands or the sea with little or no treatment. Anything dropped in the street can travel the same route.

The heaviest load arrives with the first big rain after a dry spell, often called the "first flush", when weeks of accumulated rubbish are swept into drains at once. End-of-pipe nets are designed for exactly this moment.

Kwinana's Drainage Nets: Catching Litter at an Outlet

Kwinana's Drainage Nets: Catching Litter at an Outlet

Commercial versions follow a similar design. The US maker Storm Water Systems, whose photos appear in this article, describes its StormX nets as high-density polyethylene mesh hung from stainless-steel hubs fixed to concrete pipes, headwalls or weir walls. It says the nets capture debris down to about 5 millimetres, including leaves, and can be fitted to pipes from 18 to 84 inches across. Several pipes can be fitted side by side, as in the rows of nets shown here.

Many of the photos in this article are from manufacturers and other installations rather than from Kwinana itself. They show the same idea used in different settings, from single outfalls to banks of four or six nets.

Emptying the nets: where the rubbish goes

A net only helps while it has room. Once full, it has to be emptied before the next storm, or water and litter may back up or bypass it.

Kwinana's Drainage Nets: Catching Litter at an Outlet

Kwinana's Drainage Nets: Catching Litter at an Outlet

In Kwinana, staff use a machine to lift each full net and tip the contents into a truck. The load goes to a sorting facility, where compostable material and recyclables are separated out and the remainder goes to landfill. The emptied nets are then reattached to the pipes.

Kwinana's Drainage Nets: Catching Litter at an Outlet

Kwinana's Drainage Nets: Catching Litter at an Outlet

Manufacturers describe the same routine: a truck-mounted crane, or a two-person crew for smaller nets, followed by a check of the nets and steel fittings. How often this is needed depends entirely on the local litter load and the weather. After a storm, a busy outfall can fill quickly.

One honest caveat: landfill is not an ideal destination. Organic matter breaks down poorly in landfill conditions, as the WEF article noted. The net solves a pollution problem in the wetland; it does not make the waste disappear.

What it cost and why councils like it

The two nets cost the city a little under $20,000 in total, including installation. That is roughly $10,000 per outlet, a modest sum for local infrastructure.

The savings come mainly from labour. Before the nets, picking litter out of bushland and wetland edges was slow manual work. Collecting it in one place, at the mouth of a pipe, is far quicker. The city said it expected considerable savings over time, although it did not publish a full cost-benefit study, so the exact payback period is not known.

After the first trial, Kwinana's engineering design team identified three more locations along Henley Reserve and planned to propose them in the 2019/2020 budget. Kwinana was not the first, either. The council of Nelson, in New Zealand, said it had used a similar structure for about a decade, and versions are sold in several countries.

What drainage nets cannot do

Kwinana's Drainage Nets: Catching Litter at an Outlet

Kwinana's Drainage Nets: Catching Litter at an Outlet

Viral posts sometimes present these nets as the answer to plastic pollution. They are a useful tool, but a limited one:

  • They do not stop microplastics. Mesh that lets water through also lets through tiny fragments, tyre dust and fibres. Nets catch litter, not chemical or fine pollution such as oil, fertiliser runoff or heavy metals.
  • They need suitable sites. Nets work on outfalls with enough space and access for a vehicle. Many drains discharge underwater or in places that are hard to reach.
  • They need maintenance budgets. An unemptied net can clog, and a torn net stops working. The installation cost is only part of the story.
  • They treat the symptom. Every kilogram in the net is rubbish that was dropped, blown from bins or spilled upstream. Reducing litter at the source remains cheaper still.

Net traps fit into a wider family of devices, from grates and trash racks to floating river barriers. Our article on The Ocean Cleanup's river Interceptor follows the same idea further downstream.

What residents can do

The most effective net is the one that stays empty. Keep bin lids closed on windy days, never sweep leaves or rubbish into the gutter, and pick up litter near storm drains in your street. If you see a blocked or overflowing outlet, report it to your local council. And if your area has no litter traps, ask whether a pilot is possible. Kwinana's experience shows that a small, visible project can win public support quickly.

Sources: World Economic Forum: This Australian city has the simplest way to stop trash going into the water (14 February 2019); Storm Water Systems: StormX netting trash trap; Wikipedia: City of Kwinana. Photos: City of Kwinana / Facebook, Oldcastle Infrastructure, Storm Water Systems.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1