Stan Lee's 1968 Soapbox Column on Bigotry and Racism Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-11-16.

Stan Lee's 1968 Soapbox Column Challenged Racism and Bigotry

Getty ImagesNewsday LLC

In a short column printed in Marvel comics with a December 1968 cover date, Stan Lee told millions of young readers that prejudice was one of the gravest dangers facing the world. He opened bluntly: "Bigotry and racism are among the deadliest social ills plaguing the world today." Half a century later, the same page went viral twice, first in August 2017 after the violence in Charlottesville, Virginia, and again in November 2018, when Lee died at the age of 95.

Below we look at what the column actually argued, where it appeared, why it was written when it was, and why its central idea still holds up.

What was Stan's Soapbox?

Stan's Soapbox was Lee's personal column on the "Bullpen Bulletins" page, a chatty news section that ran inside Marvel's comic books. It debuted in 1967. Most months Lee used it to hype upcoming issues, joke with fans and introduce the artists and writers in what he called the Marvel Bullpen. Every so often, though, he stepped away from the sales talk and wrote about real-world problems such as intolerance, war and prejudice.

By then Lee, born Stanley Martin Lieber in New York in 1922, was Marvel's editor-in-chief and best-known voice. With artists such as Jack Kirby and Steve Ditko he had co-created the Fantastic Four, Spider-Man, the Hulk, Thor, Iron Man and the X-Men, and with Kirby he introduced Black Panther, the first Black superhero in mainstream American comics, in 1966. A message on his Soapbox page reached a very large and very young audience.

The 1968 column in plain words

Lee's argument is short and easy to follow. He starts by naming bigotry and racism as social diseases, then points out the gap between comics and reality: a super-villain can be stopped with a punch, but hatred cannot. The only real weapon, he says, is exposure, showing prejudice clearly for what it is.

He then describes the bigot as someone who hates without reason or limit, and he offers three everyday examples. If such a person once had a bad experience with one member of a group, whether defined by skin colour, hair colour or nationality, they turn against the whole group, including people they have never met.

The heart of the column is a distinction. Lee accepts that individuals will sometimes annoy one another and that disliking a particular person is a normal part of life. What he calls irrational is the jump from one person to an entire race, nation or religion. His proposed remedy is simple: "Sooner or later, we must learn to judge each other on our own merits." He closes on a religious note, appealing to the idea that all people are children of the same God, and therefore deserving of the same tolerance.

Why 1968?

The timing matters. 1968 was one of the most turbulent years in modern American history. Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated in April, Robert F. Kennedy in June, and riots broke out in many cities. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965 were still new, and the Fair Housing Act was signed that same spring. The Vietnam War was dividing the country.

Comic books in that era were widely seen as children's entertainment, and many publishers avoided politics. Lee chose to speak to readers directly about one of the most charged subjects of the day. He was not the only voice in comics doing so, but the reach of Marvel's titles made his page unusually influential.

It was also not a one-off. Over the following years Lee returned to the theme several times, including a 1969 Soapbox reflecting that men of hate are soon forgotten while teachers of peace are remembered, and later columns mocking bigots as foolish and insisting that no single person stands for a whole culture.

How a 50-year-old page went viral

In August 2017, after a white nationalist rally in Charlottesville turned deadly, Lee shared the old column on Twitter. The post spread quickly, although it was later deleted. Fans who had never seen the Bullpen pages were struck that the creator of their favourite heroes had addressed the same problem decades earlier.

When Lee died on 12 November 2018 in Los Angeles, film critics, journalists and fans shared the column again, often as an image of the original printed page. For many people it became a short summary of the values they associated with Marvel: that great power, and great influence, should be used for something decent.

What the column gets right, and its limits

Lee's central point fits well with what social psychologists describe as stereotyping and overgeneralisation: forming a fixed judgement of a whole group from a few experiences or second-hand stories. His advice to judge people individually is still one of the most widely recommended ways to reduce prejudice. Getting to know people from other groups as equals, especially through shared goals, is consistently linked with less bias in research going back to Gordon Allport's work in the 1950s.

It is fair, too, to note what the column does not cover. It treats racism mainly as a personal attitude held by "the bigot", and says little about laws, housing, policing or economic barriers, the structural issues that civil rights campaigners were fighting at the time. Marvel's own record was also mixed: some characters from the period now read as stereotyped, and Black and female creators were rare in the industry. The column is best seen as a sincere and brave starting point rather than a complete answer.

Why it still matters

Part of the column's power is its tone. Lee did not lecture in academic language. He wrote the way he wrote everything, with punchy phrases and a wink about ray guns and super-villains, and that made a serious idea accessible to a twelve-year-old.

His heroes worked the same way. Spider-Man was a teenager worried about rent and responsibility; the X-Men were feared and hated for being born different, a premise many readers have connected with the civil rights struggle. Those stories invited readers to imagine life from the point of view of an outsider, which is exactly the habit the Soapbox column asked them to practise in real life.

If there is one takeaway, it is Lee's distinction between disliking a person and condemning a people. It is an easy line to state and a hard one to live by, which is perhaps why his old page keeps finding new readers.

Sources: Mental Floss, November 2018; Inverse, Stan Lee's Soapbox columns on racism; Wikipedia, Bullpen Bulletins; Wikipedia, Stan Lee. Photo: Getty Images / Newsday LLC.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1