Originally published 2018-10-14.

Yes, in a limited but real sense. Two small experiments at Kyoto University, both published in 2015, found that pet dogs adjust how they treat a person after watching that person behave badly. In one, dogs stopped following the pointing gestures of someone who had just sent them to an empty container. In the other, dogs avoided taking a treat from a stranger who had refused to help their owner.
That is not the same as a dog reading a person's character, and it does not mean your dog can spot a liar at a dinner party. What the studies show is narrower and, in some ways, more interesting: dogs keep track of how useful and how cooperative individual humans are, and they change their behaviour to match.
The short answer: dogs remember who misled them
Dogs are unusually good at reading human signals. Researchers have shown for years that dogs follow a pointing finger, a nod or even a glance towards a hidden reward, and they often do this better than chimpanzees or hand-raised wolves. That skill is almost certainly a product of thousands of years living alongside people.
A skill like that raises an obvious question. If a dog relies on human cues, what happens when the cue turns out to be wrong? A dog that blindly followed every pointing hand would waste a lot of effort. The Kyoto experiments were designed to test whether dogs simply follow the gesture, or whether they also weigh up the person behind it.
The pointing experiment: three rounds and an empty box
The first study, led by Akiko Takaoka and published in the journal Animal Cognition, worked with 34 dogs. The set-up was simple. A person pointed to one of two containers, and the dog was free to go and check it.
How the rounds worked
- Round one: the person pointed honestly at a container that held food, and the dogs went straight to it.
- Round two: after showing the dog what was inside, the same person pointed at a container that was empty.
- Round three: the same person pointed again at a container that really did hold food.
By the third round, many of the dogs no longer followed that person's gesture. Having been sent to an empty box once, they treated the next cue from the same person with caution. According to reports on the study, Takaoka said the dogs reassessed the person's reliability more quickly than she expected.
A new person, a fresh start
The researchers then brought in a different experimenter, who pointed honestly. The dogs followed this newcomer readily. That detail matters: the dogs were not just becoming bored with the game or ignoring pointing in general. They had lowered their trust in one particular individual. Takaoka summed it up by saying dogs have "more sophisticated social intelligence than we thought."
The helper experiment: dogs watching how strangers treat their owner
The second study came from Hitomi Chijiiwa, Kazuo Fujita and colleagues at Kyoto University and appeared in Animal Behaviour in August 2015. It asked a different question: does a dog care how a stranger treats its owner, even when the dog has nothing to gain or lose?
Fifty-four pet dogs were split into three groups of 18. Each dog watched its owner struggle to open a clear container. The owner then turned to one of two strangers for help, while a third, neutral person sat nearby.
- In the helper condition, the stranger held the container so the owner could open it.
- In the non-helper condition, the stranger turned away and refused.
- In a control condition, the owner did not ask, and the stranger simply turned away.
Afterwards, the stranger and the neutral person each offered the dog an identical treat at the same moment. When the stranger had refused to help, the dogs were more likely to take food from the neutral person instead. When the stranger had helped, or in the control, the dogs chose at random.
So the dogs avoided people who were unhelpful to their owner, but they did not show any special preference for helpful ones. The university's summary described it as dogs evaluating people "by watching their interactions with the owner." Human infants show a similar kind of judgement, which is one reason the result drew attention.
What these studies do not show
Popular headlines turned these findings into "dogs can sense bad people." That goes well beyond the evidence.
- Small samples. Thirty-four and 54 dogs are reasonable numbers for animal cognition work, but they are not large enough to make sweeping claims about all dogs.
- Specific behaviour, not character. The dogs reacted to concrete events they had just seen: a misleading point, a refusal to help. Nothing suggests they can detect dishonesty they have not witnessed.
- Not every dog changed its behaviour. The results were trends across a group. Some individual dogs kept following the misleading person.
- Jealousy is a separate topic. Older versions of this story claimed dogs can recognise "jealous" facial expressions. Research has shown dogs can tell happy and angry human faces apart, and other work describes jealous-looking behaviour in dogs, but that is not the same as reading jealousy on a human face.
Animal behaviour researchers also warn against reading too much human thinking into dogs. The British anthrozoologist John Bradshaw, commenting on the pointing study, noted that dogs tend to live in the present rather than reflecting on the past in an abstract way.
What this means for dog owners
The practical lessons are modest but useful.
- Be consistent with your cues. If you point, call or signal and there is nothing there, your dog may learn to ignore you. Training works best when your signals reliably mean something.
- Do not use your dog as a lie detector. If your dog is wary of a visitor, it may be reacting to a smell, a loud voice, a hat, sudden movements or its own past experiences. That is worth noticing, but it is not proof that the person is untrustworthy.
- Your dog is watching your relationships. The helper study suggests dogs pay attention to how other people treat you. A calm, friendly introduction to new people helps a dog relax around them.
- Fear and anxiety deserve attention. If a dog reacts strongly or aggressively to certain people, a vet or a qualified behaviourist is the right person to ask.
Why dogs may have evolved this ability
Dogs have spent tens of thousands of years depending on humans for food, shelter and safety. For an animal in that position, telling the difference between a reliable person and an unreliable one, and noticing who is cooperative with its own group, would be valuable. The Kyoto researchers suggested that this kind of social evaluation may be a shared feature of highly social species, from humans to dogs, rather than something unique to people.
It is a reminder that dogs are not just responding to commands. They are quietly building a picture of the people around them, one interaction at a time.
Sources: Kyoto University: Dogs avoid people who behave negatively to their owners (Chijiiwa et al., Animal Behaviour, 2015); ScienceAlert on Takaoka et al., Animal Cognition, 2015; Wikipedia: Dog intelligence. Video: House Beautiful. Story first circulated via I Heart Intelligence.

COMMENTS