
First published August 18, 2018. Lilia Alvarado’s paired portraits show how framing, light and colour can shape the mood of a family photograph.
A finished portrait can conceal the many decisions between pressing the shutter and sharing the image. Lilia Alvarado brings some of those decisions into view by showing photographs before and after editing. Interested in fine art and portraiture since childhood, she turned more closely towards photography after the birth of her twin daughters, Annabella and Juliette. They became frequent subjects, giving her portraits a personal starting point as well as a setting for experiments with light and atmosphere.
After receiving criticism on Instagram that her photographs were over-edited, Alvarado shared paired versions of her images. The comparison opens a more useful conversation than a finished picture alone can provide. It shows what changed, while leaving room to discuss whether those changes serve the photograph. It also makes clear that the version a viewer encounters online is the result of choices, rather than a transparent record of everything that happened in front of the lens.
Those choices have a long history, although the tools have changed. The Harry Ransom Center dates Niépce’s earliest surviving camera photograph to 1827. Its account describes heliography using light-sensitive bitumen on a pewter plate, with an exposure lasting several days. That early camera image is far removed from a modern digital portrait, but it is a useful reminder that photographs have always depended on a process for turning light into a visible result. The pewter plate is held by the Harry Ransom Center, where its material and long exposure are central to the account of how the image was made.
In digital editing, cropping, contrast and color adjustments can change the emphasis of a photograph without changing the moment when it was taken. A tighter frame alters the relationship between the subject and the surroundings. A brighter area can attract attention, while a shift in color can make an image feel warmer or cooler. These are different kinds of intervention, and a discussion of editing becomes clearer when it names the change rather than treating every adjustment as the same operation.
Alvarado’s portfolio and social accounts, linked below, place the paired examples alongside her finished work. The comparison is most informative when both versions receive attention: the first contains the scene and its possibilities, while the second shows the direction she chose to take.
Historical date: Harry Ransom Center’s record of the Niépce heliograph.
What changes between two versions
The word before can suggest an image untouched by decisions, but the photograph already has a viewpoint, a frame and a moment of exposure. After adds another set of choices to those earlier ones. The paired format makes part of that sequence visible without documenting every step. It does not, by itself, reveal the exact order of adjustments, the settings used or how long the edit took. Two versions show the visible differences, but a record of the editing session would be needed to establish the order of adjustments or the time spent on each one. Similar-looking results can come from different sequences of changes.
From an adjustment to an effect
The strongest comparison connects a visible change to its effect on the portrait. A different crop may make the figure more prominent; a change in brightness may separate a face from its setting. The question is what happens to the image as a whole. An adjustment can be technically subtle and still alter the mood, while a more obvious change may be central to the style the photographer wants to create.
Photographer and photographic history: Lilia Alvarado · Instagram · earliest known photograph · heliography











Lilia Alvarado: Website | Facebook | Instagram | YouTube
Reference: Mymodernmet
Related reading: Gilmar Silva: Behind the Scenes of Creative Portrait Photography.
What a before-and-after pair can tell us
The Metropolitan Museum of Art’s exhibition Faking It traced photographic manipulation from the 1840s to the early 1990s. Its examples include retouching, painting over images and assembling a picture from more than one negative. One practical problem was the sky: nineteenth-century photographic emulsions could leave it overexposed, so some landscape photographers combined a negative made for the land with another made for the sky. That example gives the historical discussion a concrete technique, rather than assuming that all photographs were once left unaltered. It does not identify the method behind Alvarado’s portraits; it shows that the wish to reshape a camera image predates digital software.
Historical source: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Faking It.
The disagreement over editing raises a question about the kind of photograph a viewer expects to be seeing.
In Lilia Alvarado’s work, the portrait is presented as a creative image with a deliberately shaped atmosphere. That context matters when assessing the finished picture. A viewer can prefer the first version, admire the later one or feel that a particular adjustment goes too far without denying that making the photograph involved choices from the beginning. Showing both versions gives those preferences a concrete basis: the discussion can turn to the actual frame, light or color rather than an assumption about what an unseen starting image must have looked like.
A social platform such as Instagram encourages quick reactions to an image at a small size. Paired photographs can slow that response by making a second version available immediately. They also complicate the familiar idea of an edit as a repair. The goal may be to correct a distraction, but it may also be to develop a particular mood. Whether that direction works is an aesthetic judgment that the comparison invites; the presence of editing alone cannot settle it.
The earliest known photograph belongs to a different technological world from these portraits. Niépce’s heliography is included as historical context, not as evidence that every kind of modern manipulation is equivalent or equally appropriate. A material process, a tonal adjustment and the addition or removal of a subject are distinct matters. Keeping those distinctions clear prevents a broad statement about photographic history from replacing a closer discussion of what has actually changed in an individual image.
That closer discussion also benefits from separating the picture’s emotional effect from assumptions about the software. A warm color treatment may suggest a remembered summer afternoon, but the mood does not disclose a particular preset or prove how the work was made. The side-by-side format supplies evidence of visible differences. An editing tutorial would need additional information about the method. Appreciating the result does not require filling that gap with an imagined technical recipe.
The photographs of Annabella and Juliette sit at the meeting point of a family subject and an artistic practice. Their familiarity to the photographer gives the work a personal context; the editing gives each selected image a further direction. The paired versions allow viewers to see part of that development and decide which choices hold their attention. The value of the comparison is that it makes the conversation more specific, giving both admiration and criticism something visible to address.
Additional source: Harry Ransom Center: The Niépce Heliograph.

COMMENTS