Liquid Water Under Mars’ South Pole? The Radar Lake and Its Doubts

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Mars’ Proposed Underground Lake: Radar Evidence and Later Doubts

Is there a lake of liquid water under the ice at Mars’ south pole? In 2018 an Italian-led team said radar data pointed to one, about 20 kilometres across and 1.5 kilometres beneath the surface. Since 2021, several studies have offered other explanations, frozen clay minerals above all, and today the honest answer is: maybe, but probably not a lake in the everyday sense.

Here is how the claim was made, why it caused such excitement, why scientists pushed back, and what it would actually take to settle it.

The 2018 announcement

The study, led by Roberto Orosei of Italy’s National Institute for Astrophysics (INAF), appeared in Science in July 2018. It relied on MARSIS, an Italian-built radar sounder on the European Space Agency’s Mars Express orbiter, which has been circling Mars since late 2003.

MARSIS sends low-frequency radio pulses down through the ice and listens for echoes from the layers below. Between 2012 and 2015 the team collected 29 radar profiles over a region of the south polar layered deposits called Planum Australe. Beneath one patch, the echo from the base of the ice was unusually strong, brighter even than the surface echo.

On Earth, the same kind of bright basal reflection is the classic radar signature of lakes hidden under the Antarctic and Greenland ice sheets. The team considered alternatives, such as carbon-dioxide ice or very cold water ice, and judged them unable to produce such a strong signal. Their conclusion: a body of liquid water, its depth unknown but at least tens of centimetres.

Mars’ Proposed Underground Lake: Radar Evidence and Later Doubts

An artist’s view of Mars Express probing the south polar ice with radar, the method behind the 2018 claim. Image: USGS/ASU/ESA/INAF/Davide Coero Borga

Mars’ Proposed Underground Lake: Radar Evidence and Later Doubts

A MARSIS radar profile of the south polar deposits; the bright patch at the base, shown in blue, is the reflection first read as liquid water. Image: ESA/INAF/Davide Coero Borga

How could water stay liquid at minus 68°C?

The obvious objection is temperature. The base of the ice in this region is estimated at roughly minus 68°C, far too cold for fresh water. Two factors were proposed to help.

First, pressure: a thick ice sheet pressing down lowers the melting point slightly, which is part of why Earth’s subglacial lakes exist. Second, and far more important on Mars, salt. Martian soil contains perchlorates, salts of calcium, magnesium and sodium that can keep water liquid well below zero. Any Martian lake would therefore be a cold, very salty brine, more like the hypersaline lakes found beneath some Canadian Arctic ice than like Lake Vostok in Antarctica.

Excitement followed quickly. Microbes survive in Earth’s subglacial lakes, and Orosei described the site to IFLScience as “potentially the first habitat we know of on Mars.” In 2020 the team reported that further data showed three smaller patches surrounding the first, suggesting a possible system of brines.

Why later studies doubt the lake

In 2021 three papers appeared within about a month, summarised by NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory.

  • Too many bright spots. Aditya Khuller and Jeffrey Plaut sifted through some 44,000 MARSIS echoes from 15 years of data. They found many similar bright reflections in places so close to the surface, and so cold, that even salty water could not stay liquid there.
  • Other materials can do it. Carver Bierson and colleagues showed by modelling that clays, metal-bearing minerals and saline ice could also produce strong reflections.
  • Frozen clay matches. Isaac Smith’s team chilled smectite clays to about minus 50°C in the lab and found their radar response closely matched MARSIS. They then used another orbiter to confirm that smectites exist near the south polar cap.

A further 2022 study argued that brine trapped between ice grains or in sediment explains the signal better than an open lake. Plaut, who co-leads MARSIS with Orosei, summed up the balance fairly: “The original paper didn’t prove it was water, and these new papers don’t prove it isn’t.”

Mars and water: what is and is not established

None of this means Mars is dry. Water ice is abundant in its polar caps and beneath the surface at mid latitudes, and old river valleys, deltas and clay minerals show that liquid water once flowed there for long periods. What remains unproven is stable liquid water today.

Mars’ Proposed Underground Lake: Radar Evidence and Later Doubts

Dark streaks on the slopes of Krupac Crater, a type of feature called recurring slope lineae; first read as possible seeping water, they are now widely attributed to dry sand and dust flows. Image: NASA/JPL-Caltech/Univ. of Arizona

The radar lake story echoes an earlier one. In 2015 NASA highlighted seasonal dark streaks, recurring slope lineae, as evidence of briny flows. Follow-up work favoured granular flows of sand and dust instead. In both cases the observation was real and the first interpretation the most exciting one.

What it would take to know for sure

Radar measures how strongly a boundary reflects; it cannot tell you directly what the material is. Confirming liquid water would mean better radar coverage at different frequencies, careful thermal modelling of the polar ice, and ultimately drilling, which is a huge task even in Antarctica, where reaching Lake Vostok took years.

No current mission can drill that deep on Mars. ESA’s Rosalind Franklin rover, delayed many times since the 2018 coverage, is designed to drill about two metres down, enough to search for preserved organic material but nowhere near 1.5 kilometres of ice. Mars Express itself is still operating, with its mission extended at least to the end of 2026.

So the 2018 discovery remains valuable: a real, puzzling radar signal under the south pole that pushed scientists to test their assumptions. The safest summary is that a salty subsurface brine is possible but unconfirmed, and frozen clays may explain the signal without any liquid at all.

Sources: Orosei et al. (2018), Science; NASA/JPL: Clays, not water, are likely source of Mars ‘lakes’; Wikipedia: Mars Express; Wikipedia: Planum Australe; ESA: Mars Express; IFLScience (2018 coverage, original report).

COMMENTS