Originally published 2018-06-04.
Yes: Norway has made medication-free psychiatric treatment an official option inside its public health service. In 2015 the Ministry of Health and Care Services told the country’s four regional health authorities to set up treatment pathways for people with serious mental illness who do not want to take psychiatric drugs, or who want structured help coming off them. One of the first dedicated wards opened at Asgård, the psychiatric hospital in Tromsø run by the University Hospital of North Norway: a small unit with six beds.

The idea is not that medication is bad or that everyone should stop it. It is that patients get a real say in how they are treated, and that the hospital organises care around that choice instead of around a single default.
What “medication-free treatment” means in Norway
The Norwegian phrase on the ward door at Asgård is medikamentfritt behandlingstilbud, which translates roughly as “a medication-free treatment offer.” The wording matters. It describes an option, not a rule, and not a promise that every patient will leave without drugs.
In practice the units serve two groups of people. Some have never wanted psychiatric medication and want help without it. Others have taken antipsychotics, antidepressants or other drugs for years and want to reduce or stop them under supervision, with staff nearby if symptoms return. A patient who decides partway through that medication helps after all can take it; the point is that the decision is shared.
What replaces the prescription pad is mostly time and people: talking therapies, family work, physical activity, help with sleep and daily structure, and peer support from people who have their own experience of mental illness. Many of the approaches are the same ones used on ordinary wards. The difference is the starting assumption.
Why a remote Arctic hospital went first
Tromsø is an unlikely setting for a shift in psychiatric practice. The city sits more than 300 kilometres north of the Arctic Circle, is best known abroad for the northern lights, and spends roughly seven weeks of every winter without the sun rising. Asgård itself is a plain, mid-century institutional campus, a long way from the university clinics in London, Boston or Stockholm that usually set the tone for western psychiatry.
The ward was set up on a floor that had been closed and was refurbished for the purpose. Its small size reflects what it is: a test of a model, not a replacement for the rest of the hospital.

Staff who launched the unit described it as a change in attitude as much as a change in treatment. Merete Astrup, who led the medication-free unit, put the old and new approach side by side in a 2017 interview:
“We were used to saying to patients, ‘this is what is best for you.’ But we are now saying to them, ‘what do you really want?’”
How the policy came about
The government instruction did not come out of nowhere. Norwegian service-user organisations had campaigned for years for the right to choose treatment without drugs, arguing that patients with diagnoses such as psychosis were too often offered medication as the only realistic path. Health minister Bent Høie took up the demand and turned it into a formal requirement for the regional health authorities.
The policy fits a broader principle in Norwegian law and health policy, sometimes summed up as “the patient’s health service”: people should be involved in decisions about their own care and should be told about the alternatives. Medication-free wards are one concrete form of that idea.
Magnus Hald, chief of psychiatric services at the University Hospital of North Norway, explained the reasoning simply:
“We have to consider the patient’s perspective as equally valuable as the doctor’s perspective.”
Hald also said the hospital should support people who want medication just as firmly as those who do not. That balance is easy to lose in headlines, which often present the wards as a rejection of drugs. They were never designed that way.

What the evidence does and does not show
The research picture is more cautious than enthusiastic news stories suggest. Antipsychotic drugs have strong evidence for reducing acute psychotic symptoms and lowering the risk of relapse for many people. At the same time, they can cause weight gain, metabolic problems, sedation and movement disorders, and a minority of patients either do not respond or find the side effects intolerable. Long-term outcomes for people who use less medication are an active and contested research area.
Norway’s wards were not set up as large randomised trials, so they cannot answer the big question of whether medication-free care is better or worse overall. Early accounts from the units reportedly stress that patients valued being listened to and given a choice, but the numbers involved are modest and the patients choosing these units are not typical of everyone with severe mental illness. Critics within Norwegian psychiatry worried from the start that the label could encourage some people to stop medication abruptly or outside supervised care.
Both things can be true. A medication-free option can be a humane and sensible part of a health service, and stopping psychiatric medication without support can be dangerous.
Common myths about medication-free psychiatry
“Norway has banned psychiatric drugs”
No. Medication remains the standard treatment for many conditions in Norway. The policy added an option; it did not remove any.
“Medication-free means no treatment”
The opposite. These units tend to offer more contact, therapy and support than an average ward, because they cannot rely on a prescription to do part of the work.
“If it works for some, everyone should try stopping”
People who come off psychiatric drugs can experience withdrawal effects and relapse, sometimes weeks or months later. That is exactly why Norway put tapering inside a supervised hospital setting rather than leaving people to do it alone.
What this means if you are thinking about your own medication
The Norwegian model is about shared decisions, and the same principle applies anywhere. If you are unhappy with a psychiatric medication, the safest step is to talk to a doctor or the professional who prescribed it. Say what is bothering you, ask what the options are, and ask what a supervised reduction would look like if that is what you want. Do not stop suddenly on your own.
It is also reasonable to ask what non-drug support is available locally, such as psychotherapy, peer support groups or community mental health teams. Availability varies a great deal from country to country, but the question is a fair one in any system.
Why the experiment matters beyond Norway
Few health systems have gone as far as instructing every region to offer a medication-free pathway. That makes Norway a useful case study for clinicians, patient groups and policymakers elsewhere who are debating how much choice people with serious mental illness should have.
The six beds at Asgård will not settle that debate. What they show is that a public hospital can build care around the question Astrup described, “what do you really want?”, and still keep medication available for anyone who chooses it.
Sources: Wikipedia: Tromsø; Wikipedia: Mental health in Norway. Quotes from Merete Astrup and Magnus Hald come from 2017 interviews about the Asgård ward; video and photos as originally embedded.

this is brilliant- someone/ somewhere in the worlds, finally got some respect and love- for people feeling and thoughts- not just thoughts.
ReplyDelete