Cambodian YouTubers Who Cooked Protected Wildlife Faced Legal Action

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-06-10.

Cambodian YouTubers Face Legal Action for Cooking Protected Wildlife

A still from one of the couple's videos showing a dead spotted wild cat; reports at the time identified the animal they cooked as a fishing cat, a species listed as Vulnerable. Photo: ViralPress.

In May 2018, Cambodia's Ministry of Environment said it was taking legal action against a young couple from Phnom Penh whose YouTube channel showed them preparing and eating wild animals, several of them protected under Cambodian law. Ah Lin Tuch, who presented herself as a "survivalist", and her husband Phoun Raty had filmed recipes using birds, frogs, a large lizard, stingrays, a shark, a king cobra and, most controversially, a fishing cat.

The case went viral worldwide, but the details are often blurred in retellings. Here is what the authorities actually said, why those particular animals matter, and what the episode reveals about wildlife law, online video and the market trade that supplies it.

What happened with the Natural Life TV channel

The couple's channel, reported as Natural Life TV, had around 31,000 subscribers and roughly four million lifetime views by mid-May 2018, according to the online video news site Tubefilter. The videos followed a familiar outdoor-cooking format: a rural setting, a camp fire or clay pot, and a young woman preparing a meal from scratch. What set them apart was the menu.

Viewers began pointing out in the comments that some of the animals looked like protected species, and the channel was reported to the authorities. Officials from the Ministry of Environment tracked the couple down, and the videos in question were removed. British outlets including Metro reported that Ah Lin had been detained while officials prepared a case.

Species identification matters more than an animal looking unfamiliar

Meat stewing in a clay pot in one of the channel's cooking videos. The couple said they bought the animals already dead at a local market. Photo: ViralPress.

What the Environment Ministry said

Chea Sam Arng, who headed the ministry's directorate for nature conservation and protection, told reporters that legal action was under way and that a working group was preparing a report. He drew an important distinction: most of the animals were mostly not on the endangered list, but are protected, and only one species was considered at risk of extinction.

That nuance often got lost in headlines claiming the couple ate "endangered animals" across the board. Legally, though, protection is what counts. Many species that are not globally endangered are still covered by national rules that ban hunting, trading or keeping them without a permit, and buying them can be an offence in itself.

Investigators said they would examine whether the animals had been taken from the wild by the couple or bought at illegal market stalls. Public reporting did not follow up on the final outcome of the case, so it is not clear what penalty, if any, was eventually imposed.

The couple's side of the story

Ah Lin said she had not known which species she was using or what harm it might do to conservation. According to her account, she bought the wildlife at a market in Preak Phnov, on the outskirts of Phnom Penh, and had been filming since the previous December. She said she had admitted her mistake, and the couple apologised publicly.

Phoun Raty said they had hoped to make a living from the channel, which had reportedly earned them about $500 from advertising. That figure is modest by Western standards but meaningful in Cambodia, where many rural incomes are low, and it helps explain why survival-cooking content became a popular genre in the region.

Species identification matters more than an animal looking unfamiliar

Ah Lin roasting meat over an open fire, the outdoor format that made "primitive cooking" channels popular across Southeast Asia around 2017 and 2018. Photo: ViralPress.

Why the fishing cat matters

The fishing cat (Prionailurus viverrinus) is a stocky wild cat about twice the size of a house cat, with webbed-looking paws and a taste for fish, which makes up most of its diet. It lives in dense wetlands, mangroves, marshes and slow-moving rivers across South and Southeast Asia.

The IUCN Red List classes it as Vulnerable. Its main threat is the loss of wetlands to farming, aquaculture ponds and development, but snaring, poisoning and killing in retaliation for raids on fish ponds add to the pressure. In Cambodia it has been recorded only rarely, including by camera traps in coastal protected areas such as Ream National Park, so every animal taken from the wild matters to a fragile local population.

The king cobra, another animal that appeared in the videos, is also listed as Vulnerable by the IUCN, largely because of habitat loss and collection for food, skins and traditional medicine.

Species identification matters more than an animal looking unfamiliar

Ah Lin holding two dead birds that appear to be coucals. Several of the birds in the videos were reported to be protected species under Cambodian law. Photo: ViralPress.

Why the public reaction was divided

Online reactions split along familiar lines. Many viewers were angry and some made violent comments about the woman herself. Others pushed back, asking why eating a protected bird was so different from eating chicken or pork, or arguing that people in poorer rural areas cannot be expected to know an animal's conservation status.

Both sides have a point, but they miss the central issue. Cambodia, like most countries, protects certain species not because eating them is uniquely cruel but because their populations cannot withstand steady hunting and trade. A video that turns a protected animal into entertainment also creates demand, encouraging copycats and normalising a market that conservationists across the region are trying to shut down.

Harsh personal abuse of the couple does little to help wildlife. Education, enforcement against traders, and clear platform rules do far more.

Wildlife markets, YouTube and the bigger picture

The case highlighted three wider problems. First, protected species were apparently on sale at an ordinary market close to the capital, which points to weak enforcement against traders rather than only consumers. Second, the money that video platforms pay for views can reward shocking content, a pattern seen in many countries; that same year, a US snake handler on YouTube faced charges for illegally keeping venomous snakes. Third, many viewers simply cannot recognise protected species, so outrage often arrives late and lands on the most visible person rather than the supply chain.

Video platforms have rules against content showing animal abuse or illegal activity, and viewers can report videos they think break them. If you notice wildlife for sale in a market while travelling, the most useful step is to report it to local authorities or to organisations that run wildlife crime hotlines, rather than buying an animal to "rescue" it, which only funds the trade.

Sources: Tubefilter: Cambodian YouTubers in legal jeopardy (May 2018); Wikipedia: Fishing cat; original reporting by Metro and Unilad; photos: ViralPress.

COMMENTS