
On Reddit, a "progress pic" is normally a sincere thing: a before-and-after photo posted to show weight lost, muscle gained or years of sobriety. Around the spring of 2018, users of the r/pics forum turned the format into a running joke. They paired two pictures of completely different people, cartoons or objects, gave them a heartfelt caption about hard work and recovery, and let readers do the rest.
The joke works because it borrows the exact language of real transformation posts, the "12 years of hard work," the "10 months clean," the thanks to the community, and attaches it to a celebrity lookalike or a pun. The best ones need a second look before the penny drops.
Below are the funniest examples from that wave, grouped by the type of gag, with a note on who or what is actually in each picture. Where the original poster is known, they are credited. At the end you will find a few words on the real progress-pic community that inspired them.
Celebrity lookalike "transformations"
"30 years ago I quit drugs and sex, and found Jesus."

The "before" is a famous photo of Dr. Dre, Snoop Dogg, Ice Cube and Eminem; the "after" is Pope Francis holding a microphone among clergy, in a pose that looks oddly like a rapper mid-verse. The caption imagines the most dramatic life change possible. It was shared via Imgur.
"They've finally moved out of the apartment."

Beavis and Butt-Head, Mike Judge's couch-bound MTV slackers, are paired with Benedict Cumberbatch and Neil Patrick Harris. The resemblance is surprisingly convincing, especially the hair and the grins. The joke is that leaving the sofa was all it took.
"The progress pic to end all progress pics."

A nine-step chain of bald heads that slowly morphs from the cartoon mascot Mr. Clean through Patrick Stewart, Bruce Willis and Breaking Bad's Dean Norris to Lord Voldemort. Each face differs only slightly from the one before it, which is what makes the end result so absurd. Posted by Glichrapto on Reddit.
"Mike Dirnt from Green Day quit his rock'n'roll life and became a politician."

Green Day's bassist, with bleached spiky hair, beside a stern Vladimir Putin. Fans have joked about the likeness for years. Dirnt, of course, is still playing bass with the band.
"12 years of hard work paid off: from lovable big guy to heartthrob."

Jorge Garcia, who played Hurley in Lost, on the left in 2005, and Kit Harington, Jon Snow in Game of Thrones, on the right in 2017. The two share curly dark hair and a beard, and nothing else. The same pairing, with the caption "All it takes is a bit of will," opens this article. Credit: OG_Bill_Brasky.
"Twelve years later, I left my toxic life in Michigan behind."

Millie Bobby Brown as Eleven in Stranger Things, with her shaved head, beside a young Eminem, Detroit's most famous rapper. The caption flips the real geography, since Eminem made his name in Michigan rather than leaving it. Credit: Reddit post.
"50 years. Been a hard slog, but I truly got to be the man I was born to be."

Mara Wilson as the title character in the 1996 film Matilda, next to a weathered man with long, slicked-back hair who looks like Swedish actor Peter Stormare. Same fringe, same serious gaze, several decades of "hard living" in between. It is one of the more unsettling pairings in the set.
Screen characters who "turned their lives around"
"Keanu Reeves' progress through the centuries."

A nod to the long-running joke that Keanu Reeves is immortal. The panel sets a Renaissance-style portrait labelled 1530 and a 19th-century portrait labelled 1875 beside photos of the actor from 1994 to 2015. The old images are of other men who happen to resemble him. Posted by NEONCiTiZEN.
"Remember Sid from Toy Story? He's no longer a bully. He's also in college."

Sid Phillips, the toy-torturing neighbour from Pixar's 1995 Toy Story, beside British actor Will Poulter, born in 1993. Poulter is known for We're the Millers, The Maze Runner, The Revenant and later Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3, and the comparison has followed him for years. His raised eyebrows do most of the work.
"My name is Obi-Wan Kenobi, and here is a progress pic of me after cleaning up from heroin and learning the ways of the Force."

Ewan McGregor played both roles: Mark Renton, the heroin user of Trainspotting (1996), and the young Obi-Wan Kenobi in the Star Wars prequels from 1999. The caption simply joins his two most famous characters into one life story. Credit: ak47revolver9.
"I am now officially free of cancer. I quit my job and started my own business as well!"

Bryan Cranston as Walter White in Breaking Bad: the timid chemistry teacher of the first season and the shaven-headed "Heisenberg" of later seasons. In the series, Walter's cancer goes into remission while his "business" is making methamphetamine. Fans of the show get the joke instantly. Credit: -StarLust-.
"Today marks 10 months clean."

The dried-out, wrinkled SpongeBob from the episode in which he gets stranded on land, beside his normal sunny self. The image has long been used as a meme for desperate need. Here it stands in for a recovery story. Credit: philov.
"(9/m/4'2") I've lost 40 pounds in the last 6 months."

The caption copies the age, sex and height format used on real fitness forums, and the "9-year-old" is Eric Cartman of South Park. The before and after look almost exactly the same, which is the punchline. Credit: RespectMyAuthoriteh, a username borrowed from Cartman himself.
Weight-loss puns
"The progress of me dropping 90 pounds in record time."

A man in the snow carries a large black dog in his arms, then sets it down beside him. The 90 pounds he "dropped" is the dog. It may be the most wholesome photo in the set.
"Progress: Fit Tea."

A parody of slimming-tea adverts: the before and after photos of the same shirtless man are identical, and the caption says that after six weeks of the tea he lost $500. It is a pointed joke about "detox" products that promise easy weight loss. Credit: a Reddit user in r/pics.
"210 pounds to 0 pounds in one weekend."

A wallet stuffed with banknotes, then the same wallet empty. The "pounds" are British money, and the weekend seems to have been a good one. Credited to Demderdemden and ThattBiggie.
"It's been a tough ride, but thanks to your help, Reddit, I achieved my dreams."

A heavy young man labelled 2012 and a very muscular bodybuilder labelled 2014. They are plainly two different people, which is the joke: some online "transformations" are too good to be true. Credit: qqqxfk.
History, nature and politics
"Kept hitting the gym for ages, proud to show off my progress."

The "before" is a rough block of white stone; the "after" is Michelangelo's David, carved in marble between 1501 and 1504 and now in the Galleria dell'Accademia in Florence. The 5-metre statue was cut from a single block of Carrara marble that other sculptors had started on and abandoned decades earlier, so "ages" is fair. Credit: godlesswickedcreep.
"Progress: millennia of selective breeding."

A majestic grey wolf beside a scruffy hairless dog with its tongue out, holding a first-place ribbon from an ugly-dog contest. All domestic dogs descend from ancient wolves, and thousands of years of breeding by humans produced every shape in between. Not every result is a beauty champion. Credit: killerbunnyfamily.
"Germany's progress all the way from 2005 to 2018."

Eighteen photos of Angela Merkel, chancellor from 2005 to 2021, in jackets of every colour but always with the same hand gesture. Known in Germany as the Merkel-Raute, or Merkel diamond, it became her trademark; she once said it simply solved the question of what to do with her arms. In 2013 her party even built a giant campaign billboard out of supporters' hands making it.
The real progress pics behind the joke
The parody only works because real progress posts are so common and so moving. Communities such as Reddit's r/progresspics are full of people sharing weight loss, recovery from addiction, surviving illness or simply getting healthier, and the support they get from strangers can be genuine motivation.
If you are inspired to make a change of your own, a few things are worth keeping in mind:
- Real change is usually slow. Dramatic before-and-after pairs online are sometimes edited, staged, or, as above, two different people.
- Be wary of miracle products. Slimming teas and "detox" drinks are a favourite target of these jokes for a reason.
- Get proper support. For weight loss, addiction or any health goal, talk to a doctor.
The joke progress pics are a gentle satire of internet self-improvement culture, and they still land years later because the formula hasn't changed: a heartfelt caption, two photos, and one long second look.
Sources: Images from Reddit's r/pics and Imgur, credited to their posters above; Wikipedia: Merkel-Raute; Wikipedia: Will Poulter.

COMMENTS