Originally published 2018-05-30.

History lessons have to cover wars, treaties and dates, so the odd corners tend to get skipped: courts that tried pigs, coffins fitted with alarm bells, a baboon who was promoted to corporal. This list gathers forty of those stories. The short answer to whether they are true: most are, several are exaggerated, and a handful are simply false.
Every entry has been checked against encyclopedias, academic summaries and fact-checking sites. Where the popular version goes too far, the corrected version is in the caption. Caligula never actually made his horse a consul, no pope ordered Europe's cats wiped out, Rasputin did not drown, and the woman said to have survived both the Titanic and 9/11 never existed. Numbers get extra attention, because death tolls in viral lists are often inflated or stripped of context.
The entries are grouped by theme rather than shock value: superstition and strange justice, dangerous medicine, rulers and their odd moments, dark chapters with disputed numbers, and a final set of coincidences and curiosities. At the end you will find a short guide to testing any 'facts they never taught you in school' list before you share it.
Superstition, fear and strange justice
Several of the strangest stories come from societies trying to make sense of disease, death and crime without modern science. Some are better documented than the viral versions suggest; one is simply untrue.
Witch hunts: real, but not 600,000 deaths

Witch trials were real and often lethal, but the figure of 600,000 victims that circulates online has no support in current research. Scholars now estimate that roughly 35,000 to 60,000 people were executed for witchcraft in Europe, and around 40,000 is a widely used consensus figure. Most of those deaths fell between about 1450 and 1750, in the early modern era rather than the Middle Ages, which makes the Salem trials of 1692 a late and comparatively small episode. The woodcut comes from the Wickiana, a 16th-century Zurich collection of news sheets.
Animals in the dock

From the 13th to the 18th century, European courts, above all in France, did prosecute animals. In 1386 a pig that had killed a child in Falaise, Normandy, was wounded in the same way and then hanged in public, and in Autun the lawyer Bartholomé Chassenée won an adjournment for rats that had not turned up to a church court, arguing they feared for their lives. Convicted animals were usually executed or banished, sometimes by the town's professional executioner in front of a crowd.
Coffins with an alarm bell

Fear of being buried alive ran high in the 18th and 19th centuries, and inventors sold 'safety coffins' with bell cords, flags, viewing tubes and spring-loaded lids. The earliest recorded one was made for Duke Ferdinand of Brunswick, who died in 1792, and new patents kept appearing through the cholera epidemics of the 1800s. Despite all that ingenuity, there is no documented case of a safety coffin actually saving anyone.
Did a pope declare war on cats?

This one is a myth. Gregory IX's 1233 bull Vox in Rama described a supposed heretical ritual involving a black cat, but it never calls cats in general satanic and gives no order to kill them. The notion of a papal campaign against cats comes mostly from one modern author and has no documentary or archaeological backing; cat bones from 13th-century Cambridge suggest the animals were killed for meat and fur, not burned as agents of the devil.
Cats, rats and the Black Death

Since the cat massacre above did not happen as described, the claim that it caused the plague collapses with it. The Black Death of the 1340s and 1350s spread through fleas, chiefly the Oriental rat flea, carried by rats that travelled with grain, ships and wagons. It killed about a third of Europe's people and an estimated 50 million overall, which is well below the 'over a hundred million' quoted in many viral lists. Cats, incidentally, can catch the plague themselves.
New England's vampire panic

From the late 18th century through the 19th, tuberculosis, then called consumption, swept through families in Rhode Island, eastern Connecticut, southern Massachusetts and Vermont, and some people concluded that a dead relative was feeding on the living. Families exhumed bodies, and if one looked suspiciously fresh they burned the heart or other organs, sometimes giving the ashes to the sick as medicine; accounts describe burning, turning the body and occasionally decapitation rather than the stake. The best-known case is Mercy Brown of Exeter, Rhode Island, in 1892, whose heart was burned in a failed attempt to save her brother.
Trial by boiling water

In the ordeal of the cauldron, the accused reached into nearly boiling water, wrist-deep or elbow-deep depending on the charge, and pulled out a stone. The hand was bound and inspected three days later: clean healing meant innocence, festering meant guilt. The ritual took place in church, so when the Fourth Lateran Council of 1215 forbade clergy to take part, it quickly faded; English records show no ordeals after 1219.
Medicine that did more harm than good
Before clinical trials and drug regulation, remedies were judged by reputation, and some of the most popular ones were dangerous, macabre or both.
Corpses as medicine

For a long stretch of European history, eating parts of the dead was ordinary medicine. Apothecaries sold powdered skull for head complaints, human fat (often supplied by executioners) for wounds and aching joints, and fresh blood, which some people bought by the cup at public executions. The customers were not only the rich, and demand for 'man's grease' stayed strong into the 17th and 18th centuries.
Mummies on the pharmacy shelf

A favourite ingredient was 'mummia', made from Egyptian mummies that had mostly been taken from robbed tombs. Apothecaries scraped dark residue from the bodies, mixed it with herbs or wine and sold it as a cure for almost everything; the trade peaked in the 16th century. The painting imagines the embalming that those mummies went through thousands of years earlier.
Dentures from the battlefield
In the early 1800s, false teeth made with real human teeth were thought to look and feel better than ivory or porcelain, so teeth were in demand. After Waterloo in 1815, scavengers pulled them from the dead and sold them to dentists, who boiled and trimmed them into sets, while grave robbers supplied many more. Dental historians point out that the label 'Waterloo teeth' is hard to find in 19th-century writing, and battlefields were only one source among several.
Heroin as cough medicine

Bayer trademarked heroin (diacetylmorphine) and sold it from 1898 to 1910, promoting it as a cough suppressant and as a supposedly non-addictive replacement for morphine. It was also offered as an over-the-counter treatment for pneumonia and tuberculosis. Its addictive power soon became obvious, and today it is one of the most strictly controlled substances in the world.
Morphine for teething babies

Mrs. Winslow's Soothing Syrup, sold from 1845 to quiet teething infants, contained morphine, about 65 mg per fluid ounce in one version of the formula. In 1911 the American Medical Association put it in a 'baby killers' section of its book on quack remedies, yet it stayed on sale until 1930. Cheerful advertising cards like this one show how lightly patent medicines were regulated before modern drug laws.
Beaver-based birth control?

This claim is repeated widely online, but we could not trace it to a reliable historical source, so it should be treated as unconfirmed. What is well documented is that castoreum, a secretion from beavers' scent glands that was long mistaken for their testicles, appeared in European remedies for centuries, and that beaver fur drove the early Canadian fur trade. Whatever was drunk, no mixture of that kind would have prevented pregnancy.
Arsenic for a clear complexion

This catalogue advertisement, from Sears, Roebuck, offered Dr. Rose's Arsenic Complexion Wafers, promising flawless skin. Small doses of arsenic were sold as beauty aids in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, and the instructions urged regular use. Arsenic is a poison that accumulates in the body, which is why such products vanished once food and drug laws tightened.
Syphilis arrives in Europe

The first well-recorded European epidemic of syphilis broke out in 1494 and 1495 among the French army of Charles VIII as it invaded Italy, around Naples, and spread rapidly across the continent. Early infections were far more aggressive than today's: contemporary accounts describe pustules from head to knees and flesh eaten away from the face, often followed by death within months. The disease became less lethal over time, and since the 1940s penicillin has made it curable. Albrecht Dürer's 1510 woodcut of Death confronting a soldier reflects how close death felt in that era.
Rulers, generals and their odd moments
Powerful people attract legends. Here the documented record is set beside the story that usually gets told.
Caligula's horse was never a senator

The Roman writers Suetonius and Cassius Dio say Caligula spoiled his racehorse Incitatus with a marble stable, an ivory manger and jewelled collars, and that he intended to make the animal consul. The same sources make clear the appointment never took place, and none of them mention a senate seat. Many historians read the tale as the emperor mocking the Senate, or as hostile gossip that grew in the retelling.
President Einstein? He said no
True. When Israel's first president, Chaim Weizmann, died in November 1952, Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion offered the mostly ceremonial office to Albert Einstein, and ambassador Abba Eban passed on the request. Einstein replied that he was “deeply moved” but could not accept, and the government is reported to have been relieved, having felt obliged to ask.
The 38-minute war

The Anglo-Zanzibar War of 27 August 1896 is generally listed as the shortest war on record, lasting between 38 and 45 minutes depending on how its start and end are counted. It followed the suspicious death of the pro-British sultan Hamad bin Thuwaini, after which his nephew Khalid bin Barghash claimed the throne without British consent. A Royal Navy bombardment wrecked the palace, about 500 Zanzibaris were killed or wounded, and Britain installed its own candidate, Hamoud bin Mohammed.
Napoleon routed by rabbits
In July 1807, after the Treaties of Tilsit, Napoleon's chief of staff Alexandre Berthier laid on a celebratory rabbit hunt. According to the memoirs of General Paul Thiébault, Berthier had bought tame rabbits from farmers instead of catching wild ones, so when the cages opened the animals rushed at the emperor, apparently expecting to be fed, and pushed his party back to the carriages. The whole episode rests on one memoir, so enjoy it as a well-told anecdote rather than a certified fact.
A state funeral for a leg

Antonio López de Santa Anna lost much of one leg in 1838 when French cannon fire shattered his ankle at Veracruz during the so-called Pastry War. He later had the limb buried with full military honours, but in December 1844 an angry crowd dug it up and dragged it through the streets of Mexico City. One of his artificial legs, taken by Illinois troops at Cerro Gordo during the Mexican-American War, is still held by the Illinois State Military Museum.
Vlad the Impaler and Dracula

Vlad III of Wallachia was most likely born between 1428 and 1431 in Sighișoara, Transylvania, and his nickname comes from the mass impalements he ordered. The idea that he drank his enemies' blood is legend: German pamphlets of 1499 and 1500 showed him dining among impaled victims, largely to sell copies. His family name very probably gave Bram Stoker the name Dracula, although Vlad himself does not appear in Stoker's notes for the novel.
Erased from the photograph

Soviet censors routinely removed disgraced officials from photographs and books. Leon Trotsky and Lev Kamenev vanished from pictures of Lenin addressing troops, and victims of the purges were airbrushed out of group portraits, sometimes reappearing decades later after posthumous rehabilitation. The sequence above shows how a person could disappear from the record step by step.
How many died under Stalin?

There is no exact toll, and estimates vary widely depending on whether famine, deportation, labour-camp deaths and executions are all included. During the Great Purge of the late 1930s alone, at least 700,000 people were executed and more than a million imprisoned, while the famine of 1930 to 1933 devastated Ukraine and Kazakhstan. Totals for the whole era run into the millions, and 'up to 15 million' falls inside the range of published estimates rather than being a settled number.
Why Democrats have a donkey

During the 1828 presidential race, Andrew Jackson's opponents mocked him as a 'jackass'. Jackson and his supporters turned the stubborn, plain-man image to their advantage instead of resenting it. The donkey became the party's lasting emblem mainly through Thomas Nast's cartoons in Harper's Weekly from 1870, which also helped fix the elephant as the Republican symbol.
Dark chapters and disputed numbers
Death tolls are where viral history goes wrong most often. These entries are real, but the figures attached to them deserve care.
How far did the Native American population fall?

The collapse after 1492 was real and catastrophic, but exact numbers are uncertain. Most scholarly estimates for the pre-contact population of what is now the United States and Canada fall between about 2.5 and 7 million, with a few going as high as 18 million, and the 1900 US census is commonly cited as counting roughly 237,000 Native Americans. Epidemics such as smallpox caused the largest share of deaths, but historians stress that warfare, enslavement, forced removal and wrecked food systems made those epidemics far deadlier.
Aztec sacrifice and the numbers problem

Human sacrifice was central to Aztec religion, and the Templo Mayor in Tenochtitlan was its main stage. The scale is fiercely debated: some post-conquest sources claim 80,400 victims at the temple's rededication in 1487, while modern historians give ranges from a few thousand upward for that event and disagree sharply about yearly totals. By 2020 archaeologists had identified about 603 skulls from the skull rack beside the temple, so a neat figure such as 20,000 is an estimate at best.
What really killed Rasputin

Rasputin was murdered in the early hours of 30 December 1916 by a group of aristocrats that included Prince Felix Yusupov, Grand Duke Dmitri Pavlovich and Vladimir Purishkevich. The popular version, in which he shrugs off poison and stabbing before drowning in the Volga, does not match the evidence: his body was recovered from under the ice of the Malaya (Little) Nevka in Petrograd, and the autopsy found three gunshot wounds, no water in his lungs and no trace of poison. Much of the 'unkillable mystic' legend traces back to Yusupov's own dramatic memoir.
The man in Lincoln's box

Major Henry Rathbone and his fiancée Clara Harris were the Lincolns' guests at Ford's Theatre on 14 April 1865. When Rathbone grappled with John Wilkes Booth, the assassin slashed his arm from elbow to shoulder, cutting nearly to the bone. In December 1883, while serving as US consul in Germany, Rathbone shot and stabbed Clara, by then his wife, as she shielded their children; he was declared insane and spent the rest of his life in an asylum in Hildesheim, where he died in 1911.
Elizabeth Báthory: murderer or frame-up?

The Hungarian countess Elizabeth Báthory and her servants were charged with 80 counts of murder said to have taken place between about 1590 and 1610. The famous total of 650 victims comes from a servant who claimed to have seen it in an official's private register, which was never produced. Her servants were executed, and Báthory was confined at Csejte (Čachtice) Castle until her death in 1614; since the 1980s some historians have argued she was the target of a politically motivated frame-up.
Gilles de Rais, Joan of Arc's comrade

Gilles de Rais fought beside Joan of Arc in 1429, including at the attempt on Paris, and later became a Marshal of France. Years afterwards he was tried for the murder of children and executed at Nantes on 26 October 1440; estimates of his victims vary widely, with around 140 often cited and older claims going higher. A few writers argue he was framed, but most historians accept his guilt, while noting that novels and films exaggerate how close he and Joan were.
Coincidences, curiosities and everyday life
The rest of the list ranges from fashion and jewellery to a war hero baboon, a famous fake and a plant with a tiny home range.
Dresses sewn from flour sacks

Cotton feed and flour sacks were free fabric for rural households in the United States and Canada, and the habit peaked from the 1920s through the post-war years, covering the Depression and the Dust Bowl. Millers and bag makers noticed, and began printing their sacks in florals and bright colours so that shoppers would pick their brand. A 1933 US Department of Agriculture booklet praised the bags for their salvage value, and they became dresses, aprons, curtains and toys.
Tutankhamun's parents may have been siblings

A 2010 DNA study led by Zahi Hawass and published in JAMA identified the mummy known as the Younger Lady as Tutankhamun's mother and concluded she was a full sister of her husband, the mummy from tomb KV55 usually identified as Akhenaten. Other researchers have questioned this, arguing that degraded DNA and generations of royal intermarriage can mimic a sibling match, and that first-cousin marriages over three generations would fit as well. The sibling pairing is widely reported but not settled.
Corporal Jackie, the baboon soldier

Jackie was a baboon raised by Albert Marr, a South African farmer's son who refused to leave him behind when he joined the 3rd South African Infantry Regiment in 1915. Jackie became the regiment's mascot, was hit by shrapnel in the trenches in France and lost a leg to amputation. He was promoted from private to corporal, received the Pretoria Citizens Service Medal and died in a house fire in 1921.
The 'luckiest woman' who never existed

This story is false. No Anna Mae Dickinson survived the Titanic, the Lusitania, the Hindenburg, Pearl Harbor and 9/11; the tale began as a satirical 2006 post on the website InstaPunk and later circulated as a meme, and no such name appears on the Titanic passenger list. The photograph that travels with it actually shows the American folk painter Anna Mary Robertson Moses, better known as Grandma Moses.
Richard Parker, in fiction and in fact

In Edgar Allan Poe's only novel, The Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym of Nantucket (1838), starving castaways draw straws and a sailor named Richard Parker is killed and eaten. In 1884 the yacht Mignonette sank, leaving four men in a lifeboat; captain Tom Dudley killed the 17-year-old cabin boy, also called Richard Parker, while Edwin Stephens held him, and all three survivors ate from the body. A reader pointed out the coincidence to Arthur Koestler in 1974, and the real case, R v Dudley and Stephens, still anchors the legal principle that necessity is no defence to murder.
Jewellery made from a loved one's hair

Mourning jewellery made with the hair of the dead flourished in the Victorian era, helped by Queen Victoria's long, very public mourning. Lockets, rings and brooches held braided locks or tiny willows and gravestones worked in hair, and magazines printed instructions so families could make pieces at home. Hair was the material of choice because it barely decays; it lets a brooch like this one survive for well over a century.
Adams and Jefferson, same day

Both men died on 4 July 1826, fifty years to the day after the Declaration of Independence that Jefferson drafted and Adams fought for. Jefferson died first, at Monticello; Adams, in Massachusetts, is reported to have remarked that Jefferson still survived, not knowing his old rival and friend had died hours before. James Monroe, the fifth president, also died on the Fourth of July, in 1831.
The protest snowmen of Brussels

During the harsh winter of 1511, Brussels staged a snow festival, and residents built more than a hundred snow figures around the city. Many of them were rude or satirical, poking fun at the clergy and the city's rulers, and the writer Bob Eckstein, who researched the history of the snowman, has described the event as an early form of political commentary. Because every sculpture melted long ago, all we know comes from written descriptions.
A plant found in only two states

This one checks out. The Venus flytrap grows wild only on the coastal plain of North and South Carolina, with every known natural site within about 90 kilometres of Wilmington, North Carolina. Small introduced populations exist in northern Florida and western Washington, and the wild plants are threatened by habitat loss and illegal collecting.
Gordon Smiley's fatal qualifying crash

American driver Gordon Smiley died on 15 May 1982 while trying to qualify for the Indianapolis 500. His car oversteered in Turn 3, the front wheels suddenly regained grip and the car shot across the track into the wall nose-first at nearly 200 mph, not 185 as often quoted; the chassis broke apart and he was killed instantly. The track's medical chief, Dr. Steve Olvey, later wrote a frank account of reaching the car, and it is remembered as one of the most violent accidents in the race's history.
How to check a 'facts they never taught you' list
Lists like this one travel well because each item is short, surprising and unsourced. A few habits help separate the real from the invented:
- Look for a date, a place and a name. Real events leave specific traces; the Anna Mae Dickinson story collapses as soon as you check a passenger list.
- Ask what a number counts. Accusations, trials, convictions and deaths are different things, and the witch-hunt and Aztec figures show how far estimates can drift.
- Find the earliest source. Napoleon's rabbits rest on one memoir; Rasputin's 'unkillable' legend rests largely on his killer's memoir.
- Watch for tidy cause and effect. 'The pope killed the cats, so the rats brought the plague' is a neat story with no evidence behind its first step.
Scored that way, this list holds up better than most: roughly thirty of the forty items are accurate as stated or need only small corrections, while the cat crusade, the plague link, the senator horse, Rasputin's drowning, Vlad's blood-drinking and the luckiest woman alive are myths or distortions. The beaver remedy remains unconfirmed. The true stories are strange enough on their own.
Sources: Wikipedia: Witch-hunt; Wikipedia: Animal trial; Wikipedia: Feed sack dress; Wikipedia: Safety coffin; Wikipedia: Vox in Rama; Wikipedia: Bubonic plague; Wikipedia: Incitatus; Wikipedia: Population history of Indigenous peoples of the Americas; Wikipedia: Medical cannibalism; Wikipedia: Albert Einstein; Wikipedia: Anglo-Zanzibar War; Mental Floss: The time Napoleon was attacked by rabbits; Mental Floss: When dentures were made from the teeth of dead Waterloo soldiers; Wikipedia: The Younger Lady; Wikipedia: Corporal Jackie; Wikipedia: Antonio López de Santa Anna; Wikipedia: New England vampire panic; Wikipedia: Human sacrifice in Aztec culture; Snopes: Did a woman survive the Titanic, Hindenburg, Pearl Harbor and 9/11?; Wikipedia: Bayer; Wikipedia: Mrs. Winslow's Soothing Syrup; Wikipedia: Grigori Rasputin; Wikipedia: Vlad the Impaler; Wikipedia: Censorship of images in the Soviet Union; Wikipedia: Joseph Stalin; Wikipedia: Democratic Party (United States); Wikipedia: The Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym of Nantucket; Wikipedia: R v Dudley and Stephens; Wikipedia: Hair jewellery; Wikipedia: Henry Rathbone; Wikipedia: Elizabeth Báthory; Wikipedia: Thomas Jefferson; Wikipedia: Snowman; Wikipedia: Gilles de Rais; Wikipedia: Trial by ordeal; Wikipedia: Venus flytrap; Wikipedia: Gordon Smiley; Wikipedia: History of syphilis; Original list compiled by Twentytwowords. Image credits are given under each picture.

COMMENTS