My Kids Are Not an Inconvenience: Children in Shared Public Spaces

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-04-16.

A Parent's Reflection on Children and Shared Neighbourhood Space

Photo: Jess Marie / Wonderoak

Children are not an inconvenience to be managed out of sight. They are part of every community, and they have as much right to parks, pavements, shops, restaurants and aeroplanes as anyone else. That is the heart of a widely shared essay by Jess, a mother of four who writes the parenting blog Wonderoak. She is not asking for children to be excused from good manners. She is asking adults to stop treating their mere presence as a problem.

Her essay struck a nerve because almost every parent has felt the sigh behind them in a queue. Below we retell her experience in our own words, look at the real reasons behind some of those tense moments, such as crying babies on planes, and set out what the law says when the brush-off comes from a landlord.

The moments that prompted the essay

Jess and her husband had just moved to a new street with their four children, who were then aged between about four and ten. Introducing herself to an older neighbour a few doors down, she mentioned the size of her family. The woman repeated the number in disbelief, then told her it would be fine as long as they are quiet. She was not joking.

Jess tried to see it from her side. Someone who has lived on the same quiet street for decades may well dread change, and six new people arriving at once can feel like an invasion. Still, the encounter crystallised something she had noticed for years: the feeling that her family bothered people simply by existing, before the children had done anything at all.

She gives other examples. At an airport check-in, waiting their turn with passports and tickets, the family could hear exasperated breathing from the traveller behind them. She was tempted to point out that they had bought six seats and he had bought one.

A Parent's Reflection on Children and Shared Neighbourhood Space

One of Jess's children dancing on the beach. Photo: Jess Marie / Wonderoak

Children belong in shared spaces

Her argument is straightforward. Children have always been part of public life. Nobody is obliged to have them, and adults are free to choose child-free holidays, venues and events. What adults cannot reasonably expect is for families to keep children out of the spaces everyone shares: parks, streets, supermarkets, beaches, trains, planes and, yes, restaurants.

That right comes with responsibilities, and Jess spells out what her family works on. The children are taught to be respectful, to offer their seat to an older passenger, to shake hands and make eye contact, to say please and thank you, and not to wrestle or shout where it would bother others. They don't always manage it, she admits, and the youngest is a work in progress. But within those limits, she refuses to apologise for her children behaving like children: laughing on their bikes, the occasional whoop of joy in the cul-de-sac, the ordinary noise of growing up.

This is a fair balance, and one most people would agree with once it is spelled out. Parents are responsible for guiding behaviour. Other adults are responsible for tolerating normal childhood noise without treating it as an offence.

Why babies cry on planes

Few situations raise tempers like a crying baby on a flight. Jess makes a point worth taking seriously: the baby is not trying to ruin anyone's journey and may well be in pain.

The Mayo Clinic explains why. During take-off and especially landing, cabin pressure changes faster than the middle ear can adjust. The eustachian tube, a narrow channel that equalises pressure behind the eardrum, opens when we swallow or yawn. In infants and toddlers this tube is small, so the pressure imbalance can be genuinely painful, a problem known as airplane ear. Adults can pop their ears on purpose; babies cannot.

Parents can help by offering a feed or a dummy during ascent and descent so the baby swallows, and older children can drink through a straw or chew gum. Fellow passengers can help by remembering that the parents are almost certainly more stressed than they are, and by reaching for headphones rather than a glare.

A Parent's Reflection on Children and Shared Neighbourhood Space

Kids being kids: a leap of joy at the water's edge. Photo: Jess Marie / Wonderoak

When a landlord says no to children

One episode in the essay has a clear legal side. When the family asked to apply for a three-bedroom rental, the property manager sent a one-line reply saying the house was too small for them. They had always lived in three-bedroom homes. Nobody asked about their needs; it read as a polite way of saying no to children.

In the United States, that kind of response can be illegal. The federal Fair Housing Act protects “familial status”, which covers households with children under 18, pregnant people, and those gaining custody of a child, including adoptive and foster parents. According to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), it is unlawful to:

  • refuse to rent or sell to a family because they have children;
  • evict a family when a child joins the household;
  • restrict families with children to certain floors, buildings or parts of a property;
  • impose unreasonably strict rules on children's use of shared areas such as pools, hallways and courtyards;
  • advertise that children are not welcome.

There are limits. Qualifying housing for older people is exempt, and reasonable local, state or federal occupancy limits still apply. So a landlord may lawfully cap the number of occupants per bedroom under a genuine occupancy code, but cannot simply decide that a family is “too big” because of the children. People who believe they have faced this kind of discrimination can file a complaint with HUD. Rules in other countries differ, so check your local tenancy authority.

Turning friction into a neighbourly conversation

Most tension between families and other adults is not about law but about everyday life. A few habits make shared spaces easier for everyone:

  • For parents: introduce yourselves to close neighbours, give a heads-up before a birthday party, keep the loudest play to reasonable hours, and step outside with a child who is truly melting down in a quiet venue.
  • For neighbours: raise a specific problem kindly and directly, such as a ball hitting your car or noise late at night, rather than a general complaint about “those children”.
  • For everyone: remember that each of us was once the noisy child in a restaurant, and that most of us will one day be the older person who needs a seat on the train.
A Parent's Reflection on Children and Shared Neighbourhood Space

Jess with one of her daughters. Photo: Jess Marie / Wonderoak

Generations need each other

Jess ends on a hopeful note. Visiting a church where every age group was present, her family was welcomed warmly; strangers shook the children's hands, and someone went to fetch crayons for them. It was a small gesture, but it captured what she wanted from the wider world.

Her conclusion is that communities work best when grandparents, toddlers, teenagers and everyone in between share the same spaces and look out for one another. Children who grow up around patient adults learn patience themselves. Adults who make room for children are investing in the neighbours, colleagues and carers of the future.

She admits she gets annoyed with her own kids too, and would happily commiserate with a frustrated neighbour over a glass of wine. But she is not going to apologise for them being part of the world, and neither should any parent who is doing their best.

Sources: Original essay and photos by Jess Marie, “My Kids Are Not an Inconvenience for You”, Wonderoak (6 October 2017); HUD: Discrimination against families with children; U.S. Department of Justice: The Fair Housing Act; Mayo Clinic: Airplane ear.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1