Erdogan Tells Crying Girl in Uniform She'd Be Honoured as a Martyr

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Turkish President's Comments On Child Martyrdom Spark Outrage

On 24 February 2018, at a congress of the ruling AK Party in the southern Turkish city of Kahramanmaras, President Recep Tayyip Erdogan invited a crying six-year-old girl in a commando uniform up onto the stage. With state television broadcasting live and the hall cheering, he told the audience that if she were "martyred" she would be wrapped in the Turkish flag. Within hours the clip was circulating around the world, and many viewers asked the same question: how could a head of state talk so casually about a small child dying in war?

This piece sets out what was actually said, the military campaign it was meant to rally support for, why child-rights advocates and opposition politicians reacted so strongly, and what became of the war in Afrin afterwards.

What Erdogan said to the girl on stage

The girl, named in reports as Amine Tiras, had come to the rally dressed in camouflage and wearing the maroon beret of Turkey's special forces. When Erdogan spotted her in the crowd he called her forward. She was clearly upset and in tears as she was lifted up beside him.

He first teased her gently for crying, telling the hall that soldiers who wear the maroon beret are not supposed to cry. Then he pointed out the small Turkish flag tucked into her uniform pocket. In the English translation published by the New York Times and carried by Australia's SBS, his next words were:

"Her Turkish flag is in her pocket. If she becomes a martyr, God willing, she will be wrapped with it."

He asked the crowd whether she was ready for anything, the girl answered yes, and he kissed her on the cheek before she was led away. The audience applauded throughout. Some early reports described her as about five years old; most outlets, including SBS, gave her age as six.

Turkish President's Comments On Child Martyrdom Spark Outrage

Turkish President's Comments On Child Martyrdom Spark Outrage

Turkish President's Comments On Child Martyrdom Spark Outrage

Stills from the televised AK Party congress in Kahramanmaras, where the girl in a commando uniform was brought onto the stage.

The war behind the rally: Operation Olive Branch

The remark did not come out of nowhere. Five weeks earlier, on 20 January 2018, Turkey had launched Operation Olive Branch, a cross-border offensive into the Afrin region of north-western Syria. Afrin was held by the Kurdish People's Protection Units (YPG), which Ankara treats as an extension of the PKK, a group Turkey, the United States and the European Union list as a terrorist organisation. The YPG was at the same time the backbone of the US-backed forces fighting the Islamic State group, which made the offensive a source of friction between Turkey and its NATO allies.

Rallies like the one in Kahramanmaras were part of a nationwide effort to build public support for the campaign. Erdogan also threatened to push further east to Manbij, where American troops were stationed, a move many analysts warned would sharply escalate the conflict.

(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)


Turkish President's Comments On Child Martyrdom Spark Outrage

Turkish forces and allied Syrian fighters entered the Afrin region in January 2018.


Turkish President's Comments On Child Martyrdom Spark Outrage

Afrin, on Syria's border with Turkey, had been run by the Kurdish YPG before the offensive.


Turkish President's Comments On Child Martyrdom Spark Outrage

Ankara justified the operation as protection of its southern border from groups it calls terrorists.


Turkish President's Comments On Child Martyrdom Spark Outrage

Turkish air strikes hit targets the government linked to the PKK during the same period.

Why the comments caused such outrage

Critics focused on two things. The first was the phrase "God willing", which in this context sounded like a wish for a child's death. Turkish social media users called the scene child abuse, and one widely shared post pointed out that nobody should pray for a little girl to die.

The second was the image itself: a political leader using a frightened child in military dress as a prop for a war. Andrew Stroehlein of Human Rights Watch summed up his reaction in one word, "Sick", and asked whether the moment glorified the deaths of children and normalised the idea of child soldiers. International commentators compared it with the way militarist regimes of the twentieth century used children in propaganda.

Inside Turkey, opposition politicians spoke out as well. Garo Paylan, an Armenian-Turkish MP from the pro-Kurdish Peoples' Democratic Party (HDP), which opposed the Afrin offensive, shared the video and wrote: "What is this cruelty. And the applaud... mass madness is continuing."

Martyrdom in Turkish public life

To understand why the line landed the way it did, it helps to know how central the idea of the martyr, or şehit, is in Turkish politics. Soldiers and police officers killed on duty are officially called martyrs, their coffins are draped in the red flag, and funerals are often attended by ministers and broadcast on television. Politicians from every party use the language of sacrifice for the homeland.

That shared vocabulary is exactly why many Turks who support their armed forces still felt something had gone wrong in Kahramanmaras. Honouring adults who chose to serve is one thing. Telling a sobbing six-year-old, in front of a cheering crowd, that her death would be a source of national pride is something else, and it suggested how far wartime rhetoric had drifted.

Children, uniforms and propaganda

Dressing children in miniature uniforms for parades and national holidays is common in many countries, and on its own it rarely causes controversy. The problem, child-rights advocates argue, begins when children are tied directly to violence and death. International law reflects this concern: the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child and its optional protocol on children in armed conflict set out to keep minors away from fighting and from recruitment into it.

Psychologists who work with children in conflict zones often stress that young children cannot make sense of messages about dying for a cause; what they absorb instead is fear, or the idea that adults approve of violence. The girl's tears on stage were, for many viewers, the most honest part of the whole scene.

What happened next in Afrin

The outrage did little to change the course of the campaign or Erdogan's standing with his base. Turkish and allied Syrian forces entered Afrin city on 18 March 2018, and Ankara declared the operation over a few days later. Estimates of the human cost vary widely by source; the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights recorded hundreds of civilian deaths and said around 300,000 Kurdish residents were displaced. Human Rights Watch said Turkey failed to take necessary precautions to protect civilians, and Amnesty International condemned indiscriminate shelling.

After the capture, rights groups and journalists documented looting by Turkish-backed factions, seizures of homes belonging to displaced Kurds and Yazidis, and the resettlement of other families into them. Turkish-backed control of Afrin has continued since. For readers in Greece and Cyprus the pattern feels familiar: Turkey has occupied the northern third of Cyprus since its 1974 invasion, displacing tens of thousands of Greek Cypriots from their homes.

Erdogan went on to win the June 2018 presidential election. The clip of the crying girl, though, has become one of the most remembered images of that year, often shared whenever the use of children in political theatre comes up.

Sources: SBS News, Armenpress, Wikipedia: Operation Olive Branch.

COMMENTS