South Africa's 2018 Land Expropriation Vote and What Followed

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
South African Parliament Backs Land Expropriation Without Compensation

On 27 February 2018 South Africa's National Assembly voted 241 to 83 for a motion asking parliament to examine changing the constitution so that the state could expropriate land without paying compensation. The motion was brought by Julius Malema's Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) and amended by the governing African National Congress (ANC) before it passed.

The vote was widely reported abroad as a decision to seize land from white farmers. It was not that. It was a mandate for a committee to review Section 25 of the constitution, the property clause. The constitutional amendment that eventually came out of that process failed in parliament in 2021, and a different route, a new Expropriation Act, became law in January 2025. This article explains the 2018 vote, why land is such a charged issue in South Africa, and what has happened since.

What parliament actually voted for

The EFF's original motion called for an ad hoc committee to draft the change. The ANC rewrote it so that the existing Constitutional Review Committee, together with the National Council of Provinces, would review Section 25 and any other clauses needed to allow expropriation in the public interest without compensation. The committee was told to report back by 30 August 2018.

The vote came less than two weeks after Cyril Ramaphosa replaced Jacob Zuma as president, and land reform was a central part of his early agenda. With a general election due in 2019, the ANC was under pressure to show faster progress on redistribution, especially among poorer black voters.

South African Parliament Backs Land Expropriation Without Compensation

Malema, pictured in parliament in the red overalls worn by EFF members, framed the issue as one of dignity rather than revenge. In the debate he told the House: "The time for reconciliation is over; now is the time for justice." He had campaigned on expropriation without compensation for years, and some of his earlier remarks, including a 2016 rally remark that he was not, for the time being, calling for white people to be killed, had alarmed many South Africans.

An ANC minister speaking in the debate said the party supported the principle without reservation, putting it bluntly: "land shall be expropriated without compensation."

Why land ownership is so contested

The roots of the debate go back more than a century. The Natives Land Act of 1913 confined black land ownership to a small fraction of the country, and later apartheid laws forcibly removed millions of people from their homes. When apartheid ended in 1994, ownership of farmland was still overwhelmingly white.

The post-apartheid government chose a "willing buyer, willing seller" approach: the state bought farms at market prices and redistributed them, alongside a restitution programme for people who had been dispossessed. Both moved slowly. A 2017 government land audit found that white South Africans, about 9 per cent of the population, owned 72 per cent of the farmland held by individuals. Other estimates published at the time suggested white-owned share of farmland had fallen from around 85 per cent in 1994 to the low 70s, depending on how land is counted.

Supporters of expropriation without compensation argue that paying market prices for land taken through colonial and apartheid laws rewards past injustice and makes redistribution unaffordable. Critics argue that weakening property rights would scare off investment, threaten food security and expose all owners, black and white, to state power.

South African Parliament Backs Land Expropriation Without Compensation

Ramaphosa repeatedly promised that any change would be carried out in a way that did not damage the economy or food production. Throughout the process, the government described the goal as speeding up redistribution rather than taking farms indiscriminately.

Opposition and the farmers' protests

Opposition came from several directions. Freedom Front Plus leader Pieter Groenewald warned of unforeseen consequences that would not serve the country. The Democratic Alliance argued that the existing constitution already allowed land reform and that the real problems were corruption and poor implementation. AfriForum, the Afrikaner civil-rights group, said the motion broke the settlement reached at the end of apartheid; its then deputy chief executive, Ernst Roets, called the policy "racist theft."

South African Parliament Backs Land Expropriation Without Compensation

South African Parliament Backs Land Expropriation Without Compensation

South African Parliament Backs Land Expropriation Without Compensation

South African Parliament Backs Land Expropriation Without Compensation

These AFP photographs appear to come from the "Black Monday" demonstrations of late 2017, when farmers and supporters dressed in black gathered in several cities, including Cape Town, to protest against violent attacks on farms. White crosses laid on the ground stood for people killed in such attacks, and the slogan "No Boer, No Pap" painted on a vehicle argues that without farmers there is no maize porridge, South Africa's staple food. Farm attacks affect farmers and farmworkers of all backgrounds, and how to measure them is itself disputed, but the protests became closely linked in the public mind with the land debate.

South African Parliament Backs Land Expropriation Without Compensation

A farmer stands at the fence of his property in another AFP image used in coverage of the vote. Commercial farmers argued that uncertainty alone could make banks reluctant to lend against farmland, which is often the main collateral for agricultural loans.

The Zimbabwe comparison

Much international coverage pointed north to Zimbabwe, where Robert Mugabe's government seized thousands of white-owned commercial farms from 2000 onwards, often violently and with little planning. Agricultural output collapsed, contributing to food shortages and hyperinflation, and Zimbabwe later began offering compensation to some former owners.

South African leaders on all sides insisted they did not want to repeat that experience. The difference in approach is visible in what happened next: rather than a sudden seizure, the issue went through years of committee hearings, draft bills, court challenges and parliamentary votes.

What happened after 2018

The Constitutional Review Committee held public hearings across the country and recommended an amendment. A specially created committee then drafted the Constitution Eighteenth Amendment Bill to state explicitly that compensation could be nil in some cases. On 7 December 2021 it went to a vote in the National Assembly and received 204 votes in favour and 145 against, short of the two-thirds majority required. The DA opposed it as a threat to property rights; the EFF opposed it as too weak.

The government then turned to ordinary legislation. The Expropriation Bill, passed by the National Assembly in September 2022 and by the National Council of Provinces in May 2023, was signed by Ramaphosa on 23 January 2025. It replaces the apartheid-era Expropriation Act of 1975. Expropriation must be in the public interest, and the state is generally expected to try to buy land by agreement first. The act lists limited situations in which nil compensation may be considered just and equitable, such as land that is abandoned, land held only for speculation and not used, or land whose market value is no more than the state's own past investment in it.

The act takes effect on a date set by presidential proclamation. The DA said it would challenge it in court, and it drew a sharp response from the United States, where on 7 February 2025 President Donald Trump signed an executive order halting aid to South Africa, citing the law. Supporters of the act in South Africa pointed out that many countries allow expropriation for public purposes and that the courts retain the final say on compensation.

Key points to remember

  • The 27 February 2018 vote did not seize any land. It sent the question of amending Section 25 to a parliamentary committee.
  • The resulting constitutional amendment failed in December 2021.
  • The Expropriation Act, signed in January 2025, allows nil compensation only in defined circumstances and is subject to court review.
  • The underlying issue, a deeply unequal pattern of land ownership created by colonial and apartheid laws, remains unresolved, and so does the debate over how to fix it without harming food production or investment.

Sources: Parliament of South Africa: National Assembly gives Constitution Review Committee mandate to review Section 25 (27 February 2018); Sowetan: MPs reject land expropriation amendment (7 December 2021); Wikipedia: Expropriation Act, 2024; Wikipedia: Land reform in South Africa; earlier reporting by News24 and the Daily Mail. Photographs: AFP/Getty Images.

COMMENTS