Originally published 2018-03-19.

The interview mistake hiring managers forgive least is turning up late. In a survey by the job site Simply Hired of 850 hiring managers, 93% named arriving late as a deal breaker, just ahead of whining or complaining (92%) and showing up unprepared. Most of the top ten are about attitude and preparation rather than skills, which is good news: they are almost all things a candidate can control.
Below is the full ranking, what each item tends to look like from the other side of the table, and practical ways to avoid it. A survey like this reflects what managers say bothers them, not a law of hiring, so treat it as a checklist rather than a verdict.
The ten biggest interview mistakes, ranked
These are the share of surveyed managers who said each behaviour would hurt a candidate's chances:
- Arriving late (93%)
- Whining or complaining (92%)
- Showing a lack of preparation (88%; some reports give 89%)
- Bad-mouthing a former boss (88%)
- Bad-mouthing a former company (87%)
- Grammar or spelling mistakes in the cover letter (86%)
- Poor grammar during the interview (84%)
- Unrealistic salary or compensation demands (84%)
- Being underqualified for the role (80%)
- Answering questions incorrectly (77%)
Notice how close the numbers are. The gap between first and seventh place is under ten points, which suggests most managers see these as a cluster of warning signs rather than a strict order.
Why lateness tops the list
To an interviewer, punctuality is the first piece of evidence about how you will behave on the job. It is also one of the few things they can judge before you say a word. Arriving late can read as poor planning or as a sign that the role is not a priority, even when the real cause is a delayed train.
How to avoid it:
- Do a trial run of the route, or at least check it at the same time of day, and plan to arrive ten to fifteen minutes early.
- For video interviews, test the link, camera and microphone beforehand and log in a few minutes early.
- Save the interviewer's phone number or email. If something goes wrong, contact them before the start time, apologise briefly and give a realistic arrival time. A clear, early message does far less damage than silence.
Attitude problems: whining and criticising past employers
Three of the top five items are about negativity. Complaining about the commute, the weather or the application process, or describing a former boss as incompetent, tells the interviewer how you may talk about them in a year's time.
This does not mean you must pretend every job was perfect. If you left because of a poor fit, a reorganisation or a bad manager, describe it in neutral, forward-looking terms: what you learned and what you want next. "The team was restructured and I want a role with more client contact" lands far better than a list of grievances.
Preparation, writing and spoken grammar
Being unprepared was named by close to nine in ten managers. Interviewers notice quickly when a candidate cannot say what the company does or why they applied. Half an hour of research covers most of it: the company's products or services, recent news, the job description and who you are meeting.
- Prepare three or four short stories from your experience that show results, using a simple structure such as situation, task, action and result.
- Have two or three thoughtful questions ready about the team, the first few months or how success is measured.
- Proofread your cover letter and CV, ideally out loud or with a second reader. Spell-checkers miss wrong words that are spelled correctly, and names of companies and contacts are the most common slip.
Spoken grammar matters less in most roles than written accuracy, but heavy slang, filler words and very casual phrasing can make a candidate seem unprepared. Practising answers aloud, or recording yourself once, smooths out most of it. Interviewers generally make allowances for nerves and for people speaking in a second language.
Salary talk, qualifications and wrong answers
Unrealistic pay demands rank eighth. The fix is research: check salary ranges on job boards, pay-transparency listings and industry surveys for the role and location, then give a range rather than a single figure. In many places employers now must publish pay ranges in job ads, which makes this easier.
Being underqualified (80%) is the item candidates can least change on the day. Still, job descriptions are often wish lists, and many people are hired without meeting every requirement. Be honest about gaps and explain how you would close them, rather than claiming experience you do not have.
Answering questions incorrectly sits at the bottom at 77%. For a technical question you cannot answer, it is usually better to say so, explain how you would find the answer and reason through it aloud than to bluff.
What other hiring surveys add
Other surveys point in the same direction. A 2014 poll by the staffing firm Express Employment Professionals put lying about experience at the top (65%), followed by answering a phone call during the interview (61%) and arriving late (59%). In a CareerBuilder survey of more than 2,200 hiring managers and HR staff from the same year, the most common complaints were appearing uninterested, dressing inappropriately and seeming arrogant, and 70% flagged failure to make eye contact.
The common thread is respect: for the interviewer's time, for former colleagues and for the truth. Phones should be silenced and out of sight, and honesty about your experience will serve you better than a polished exaggeration that falls apart in a reference check.
A quick myth check
"One mistake ends your chances." Not necessarily. Most interviewers weigh the whole conversation, and a calm recovery from a slip can even show resilience.
"Only qualifications matter." The survey suggests the opposite: most of the top deal breakers are about behaviour, which is why preparation pays off so well.
Sources: Esquire Middle East: Simply Hired survey of 850 hiring managers; HRD Canada: Express Employment Professionals and CareerBuilder interview surveys (2014).

COMMENTS