Originally published 2018-02-25.
In February 2018, days after the Parkland school shooting, two images were set side by side across social media. One, posted by former White House photographer Pete Souza, showed Barack Obama sitting alone in a Sandy Hook Elementary classroom in December 2012. The other showed Donald Trump smiling and giving a thumbs-up during his visit to Broward County after the Parkland attack. The pairing went viral as shorthand for two very different presidential styles in the face of mass shootings. Here is what each photo actually shows, what happened around them and why the comparison struck such a nerve.

The pairing that circulated in February 2018: Obama at Newtown in 2012 (left) and Trump in Florida in 2018 (right). Photos: Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images; Donald Trump's Instagram account.
Sandy Hook, December 2012
On the morning of 14 December 2012, a 20-year-old gunman shot his way into Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Connecticut. He killed 20 children, all six or seven years old, and six women who worked at the school, after first killing his mother at home. It remains one of the deadliest school shootings in American history.
Obama spoke from the White House briefing room that afternoon. He paused several times during the short statement and wiped his eyes, a moment that was broadcast live and widely remembered. Two days later he travelled to Newtown, spent hours with the families of victims and then spoke at an interfaith prayer vigil, where he argued that the country was failing in its first duty to keep children safe.
The photo Pete Souza shared
Pete Souza was Obama's chief official photographer for both terms. After leaving the White House he became known for posting archive pictures on Instagram that implicitly contrasted his former boss with his successor. On 17 February 2018 he shared a frame from 16 December 2012: Obama seated by himself in a classroom in Newtown, head down, shortly after meeting grieving parents and before going out to the vigil. Souza paired it with a long excerpt from the vigil speech.
He did not need to mention Trump. Coming three days after Parkland, the timing made the point for him, and thousands of users quickly built the side-by-side image themselves.
Obama's emotion over gun deaths was not a single moment. In January 2016, while announcing executive actions to tighten background checks, he cried openly as he recalled the first-graders killed at Sandy Hook. His efforts in Congress mostly failed: the bipartisan Manchin-Toomey amendment to expand background checks was defeated in the Senate in April 2013.
Parkland, February 2018
On 14 February 2018, a former student opened fire at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida. Seventeen people were killed and seventeen more wounded. The gunman pleaded guilty in 2021 and was sentenced in November 2022 to life without parole after a jury did not agree unanimously on the death penalty.
On 16 February, Donald and Melania Trump flew to Florida. Their first stop was Broward Health North hospital, where several victims had been treated; reports said the president met privately with two wounded students there. They then went to the Broward County Sheriff's Office to thank first responders, where Trump praised their work and joked that everyone in the room deserved a raise.
The thumbs-up picture and the Mar-a-Lago party
Photos from the hospital stop were then posted on the president's own social media accounts. In one, he and the first lady stand with medical staff, the president grinning and giving a thumbs-up. Supporters saw a leader thanking doctors and nurses who had worked through a terrible night. Critics saw a gesture that looked celebratory in a place where teenagers were recovering from gunshot wounds.
The criticism grew when CNN's Kevin Liptak reported that the Trumps had stopped by a disco-themed party in the Mar-a-Lago ballroom after returning from the sheriff's office. Guests shared photos on Instagram. Some outlets also reported that the hospital visit had been brief, a detail that was widely repeated but is hard to pin down precisely.
Within hours, users on Twitter were sharing the two presidents' photos together. A selection of those reactions is below; several of the original posts have since been deleted.
(The Instagram post originally embedded here is no longer available.)
Both these pictures were taken after national tragedies. Guess which president is a sociopath just posing and which one is capable of genuine empathy. pic.twitter.com/F7Qm7Y0l5H
— Tuxedo Mask (@TheLoveBel0w) February 17, 2018
True to form, trump tweets out huge smiles all around and thumbs up. In contrast, Obama shows real empathy in times of tragedy pic.twitter.com/f9k7X1ZDES
— ❄️Lorena🌊 (@Lorenalouisefor) February 17, 2018
(This post is no longer available on X.)
Trump has no emotions. He is shallow affect, psychotic. No one in their right mind would smile and give thumbs up in this situation. Real president vs fake president. Real sorrow vs photo op. Good vs evil. #ImpeachTrumpPence pic.twitter.com/WbEq7MFs6I
— Madeline, Washer of Brains (@ChicagoDungeon) February 17, 2018
Obama’s reaction to slaughtered American children was tears.
— eli friedmann (@eligit) February 17, 2018
Trump’s reaction to slaughtered American children was a smile and a thumbs up.
Another jarring juxtaposition. pic.twitter.com/LgDMaFZ8dP
The visual difference between Trump and Obama when talking about or visiting the aftermath of a school shooting is striking. Did anyone tell Trump it’s not a celebration? pic.twitter.com/cgwy32ql8S
— Brian Klaas (@brianklaas) February 17, 2018
(This post is no longer available on X.)
1: After meeting with families of the Sandy Hook victims for hours, Obama sat alone in a classroom before attending a prayer vigil.
— SeriouslyUS? (@USseriously) February 18, 2018
2: After visiting with the wounded in one of the worst school shootings in U.S. history, Trump attends a Studio 54 themed party at Mar-a-Lago. pic.twitter.com/AmZSHMyGhP
What a side-by-side can and cannot tell you
Comparison images are powerful because they compress a complicated argument into a single glance. They also leave out a lot.
- Moments are chosen. Souza's photo was selected from years of archives by a photographer with a clear point of view. The Trump image was one of several taken that day, and a posed group photo with hospital staff is a different kind of picture from a private moment of reflection.
- Context still matters. Thumbs-up photos with staff are a routine part of presidential visits. Whether that routine was appropriate after a massacre is a fair question, and many people thought it was not.
- Policy is the bigger test. How each administration responded in law tells more than any photo.
On that last point, the record is mixed for both men. Obama's main legislative push failed, and his 2016 measures were limited executive actions. After Parkland, Trump directed the Justice Department to ban bump stocks, signed the STOP School Violence Act in March 2018, and floated arming some teachers, an idea strongly opposed by many educators. Florida, under Republican governor Rick Scott, passed its own law raising the minimum age for buying rifles to 21.
Why the image still resonates
The Parkland students did not leave the debate to photos. Within weeks they organised March for Our Lives, which brought hundreds of thousands of people onto the streets on 24 March 2018. Their activism, more than any viral comparison, kept school safety and gun laws in the headlines.
Still, the pairing captured something many Americans felt about leadership in moments of national grief: that people look to a president not only for policy but for a sense that their loss has been understood. Sandy Hook families would later fight a long legal battle against conspiracy theorist Alex Jones, who had claimed the shooting was staged, and in 2022 won damages totalling well over a billion dollars. Their experience is a reminder that how public figures speak about such tragedies has real consequences for the families left behind.
Sources: Wikipedia: Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting; Wikipedia: Parkland high school shooting; Sinclair/Fox 11: Trump focuses on first responders in visit after Florida shooting; Mediaite, 17 February 2018; Indy100; Mashable. Lead photos: Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images and Donald Trump's Instagram; classroom photo by Pete Souza.

COMMENTS