David Nadlinger's Photo of a Single Trapped Atom, Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
David Nadlinger's Photograph of a Single Trapped Atom

The faint pale dot at the very centre, between the two needle-like electrodes, is light from one strontium ion. Photo: David Nadlinger, University of Oxford / EPSRC.

Yes, you really can see a single atom in this photograph, though not in the way the headlines suggested. The tiny pale-blue dot in the middle of the picture is light given off by one positively charged strontium atom, held almost perfectly still by electric fields inside an ultra-high-vacuum chamber at the University of Oxford. David Nadlinger, then a doctoral researcher in Oxford's ion-trap quantum computing group, captured it with an ordinary digital SLR and a long exposure in August 2017.

In February 2018 the image won the overall prize in the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) science photography competition, chosen from more than 100 entries submitted by EPSRC-funded researchers. Below we explain what the photo shows, how a normal camera can record one atom, what the picture does not prove, and why physicists trap single ions in the first place.

What you are looking at

The metallic structure filling the frame is an ion trap: a set of precisely shaped electrodes that create electric fields to hold a charged particle in place. The two pointed electrodes on either side of the dot are reported to be only about two millimetres apart, which gives a sense of how small the scene really is.

The picture was taken through a window in the vacuum chamber that houses the trap. Removing almost all the air matters, because stray gas molecules would collide with the ion and knock it out of position. A laser of a carefully chosen blue-violet colour shines on the ion, and that light is what makes it visible.

David Nadlinger's Photograph of a Single Trapped Atom

A second view from Nadlinger's entry. The surrounding hardware, lit by coloured flashes, is part of the story: it shows how much engineering goes into holding one atom still. Photo: David Nadlinger, University of Oxford / EPSRC.

How an ordinary camera can record one atom

A single atom is far too small to be seen by its shape; it measures well under a billionth of a metre across. What the camera records is not the atom's outline but the light it gives off.

When the laser is tuned to exactly the right wavelength (around 422 nanometres for this strontium ion), the ion absorbs light and re-emits it over and over, very rapidly. Each individual flash is faint, but over a long exposure the camera collects enough of them to build up a visible point. Nadlinger's exposure lasted 30 seconds.

The dot in the picture is therefore far bigger than the atom itself. Light cannot be focused to a point smaller than roughly its own wavelength, and camera optics spread it further, so a source a fraction of a nanometre wide appears as a blurred spot many thousands of times larger. Think of seeing a distant star: you see its light, not its surface.

The camera, the lens and a quiet night in the lab

Nadlinger has published the details of the shot on his own website. He used a Canon EOS 5D Mark II with a Canon EF 50 mm f/1.8 lens stopped down to f/4, two flash units fitted with coloured gels to light the hardware, and extension tubes.

Some early coverage claimed he managed without any close-up accessories. In fact his write-up lists extension tubes. These are hollow spacers placed between the camera body and the lens: by moving the lens further from the sensor they let it focus much closer than normal. They do not change the lens's focal length.

His notes record the shot at 2:36 in the morning on 7 August 2017. He described the motivation in an interview: "It's exciting to find a picture that resonates with other people that shows what I spend my days and nights working on."

What the photo is not: three common myths

Myth 1: this was the first photo of an atom

It was not. Asked whether single atoms had been photographed before, Nadlinger answered that they had, probably even before he was born. Physicists have imaged single trapped ions for decades, and electron and scanning-probe microscopes routinely map individual atoms.

Myth 2: it was a scientific breakthrough

Nadlinger himself was clear about this. The picture "won a photography competition, not a science prize," he wrote, adding that ion traps and laser cooling are standard tools in many laboratories. Its value is in communication: it lets anyone see, with their own eyes, an experiment that is normally described only in equations.

Myth 3: the atom is hanging in mid-air

The ion is not floating in air, and it is not touching the electrodes. It sits in a near-perfect vacuum, held in place by electric fields from the surrounding electrodes.

Why physicists trap single ions

Ion traps have a distinguished history. Wolfgang Paul, who developed the radio-frequency "Paul trap," shared the 1989 Nobel Prize in Physics for the work; Hans Dehmelt, co-inventor of the related Penning trap, was honoured the same year.

Today, trapped ions are among the leading candidates for building quantum computers. Each ion can store a quantum bit of information in its internal energy levels, and lasers are used to manipulate and read out those states. In a readout, a "bright" ion that glows under the laser and a "dark" one that does not represent different results, which is exactly the kind of glow captured in Nadlinger's photo.

Trapped ions are also the heart of some of the most precise atomic clocks ever built.

Other winning images from the 2018 competition

The EPSRC competition, then in its fifth year, invites researchers it funds to share images from their work in several categories. Two other entries from 2018 are shown here.

David Nadlinger's Photograph of a Single Trapped Atom

Luke Cramphorn of the Bristol Robotics Laboratory, University of Bristol, entered a two-part image: a robotic hand and arm holding a selfie stick and phone, and the selfie it took. It is a playful look at how researchers teach robots to grip and handle everyday objects. Photo: Luke Cramphorn, University of Bristol / EPSRC.

David Nadlinger's Photograph of a Single Trapped Atom

Bernice Akpinar of Imperial College London used an atomic force microscope, which "feels" a surface with an extremely fine tip, to map a butterfly's wing in extreme close-up. The image won the "Weird and Wonderful" category. Photo: Bernice Akpinar, Imperial College London / EPSRC.

Together, the three images show different ways science becomes visible: light from one atom, a robot imitating a human habit, and a surface pattern far too fine for the naked eye. Nadlinger's pale dot remains the most striking, precisely because it looks so modest. It is a reminder that some of the strangest physics in the universe can be recorded, with patience, on an ordinary camera.

Sources: Photographs by David Nadlinger (University of Oxford), Luke Cramphorn (University of Bristol) and Bernice Akpinar (Imperial College London), courtesy of EPSRC; David Nadlinger, "Photographing a single atom"; Gizmodo, "Picture of Single Trapped Atom Wins UK Science Photography Prize" (February 2018); Wikipedia, Ion trap.

Related articles

COMMENTS