Why Teachers Rejected Trump's Plan to Arm Them After Parkland

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-02-25.

Teachers' Responses to Trump's 2018 School-Gun Proposal

A week after the Parkland school shooting in February 2018, President Donald Trump suggested that up to about 20% of America's teachers could be trained and armed so they could stop an attacker. Teachers answered almost at once, and overwhelmingly they said no. On social media, educators including gun owners and military veterans explained why they did not want weapons in their classrooms, and a national poll a few weeks later showed most of the profession felt the same way.

This is what Trump proposed, how teachers and their unions responded, what the evidence says, and what happened next.

The shooting and the proposal

On 14 February 2018 a 19-year-old former student opened fire at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida, killing 17 people, 14 students and three staff members, and wounding 17 more, according to the Wikipedia account of the attack. He was later sentenced to life in prison without parole.

In the days that followed, Trump held a listening session at the White House with students, parents and teachers affected by school shootings. There, and in comments and posts the next day, he floated the idea of giving firearms training to a share of teachers, around one in five, so that an armed adult would already be inside the building when an attack began. He argued that gun-free schools act as a magnet for attackers and suggested bonuses for teachers who agreed to carry.

What teachers' unions said

The two largest teachers' unions rejected the plan. Lily Eskelsen García, then president of the National Education Association, told Education Week that the priority should be keeping guns away from people who want to kill, adding: "Arming teachers does nothing to prevent that."

Union leaders and many school administrators raised the same practical questions again and again. Who pays for training, insurance and secure storage? What happens if a student gets hold of a teacher's gun? How would police arriving at a chaotic scene tell an armed teacher from an attacker? And should someone whose job is to teach be expected to act as a security guard?

Teachers answer in their own words

The strongest response came from classroom teachers themselves. Thousands posted short messages that began with some version of "I'm a teacher", and several patterns stood out:

  • Experience with guns did not change their minds. Some of the most widely shared posts came from teachers who owned firearms, held concealed-carry permits or had trained with weapons in the military, and who said that experience was exactly why they did not want guns in schools.
  • Underfunded classrooms. Many pointed out that they already bought basic supplies such as markers out of their own pockets, so a plan to fund guns before paper and pay felt detached from reality.
  • The reality of a shooting. Teachers described how hard it would be to unlock a gun in a crowded room and hit an attacker without endangering students.
  • The role of a teacher. Others simply said they had chosen to teach and care for children, not to shoot anyone, and that they wanted the adults responsible for school safety to do that job.

A selection of the posts is below. Some have since been deleted by their authors and survive only as text.



Guys, I’m a college professor.

I’ve also been shooting guns my entire life and own multiple guns now.

I don’t trust myself to be able to capably defend a classroom against a shooter, and I’m a good shot.

Why would we expect teachers everywhere to bear this responsibility?

— Josh Grubbs (@JoshuaGrubbsPhD) February 21, 2018

(This post is no longer available on X.)



And your solution is to arm teachers??? Are you f***ing insane?? I'm a teacher, I teach children. I've been in the army, I've made the choice to no longer be a soldier, but a teacher!

— Lucien (@LucienOldenb) February 22, 2018

(This post is no longer available on X.)







I’m a teacher. Don’t give me a gun. Give me the supplies I need, the salary I deserve, and the common-sense gun laws to protect my kids.

— Jocelyn ✡️ (@jocelyndorf) February 20, 2018

(This post is no longer available on X.)









I’m a teacher and I don’t want a f***ing gun in my classroom! I’m trained in literature not shooting people! This is ridiculous.

— brb, sharpening my stick (@suzanne_young) February 21, 2018

(This post is no longer available on X.)



I’m a teacher. The last time I held a gun was when I played Duck Hunt, and I sucked at that. My job is to connect with kids and teach them a language. No shooting required.

— Margaret Kieler (@margiesaalsaa) February 22, 2018

(This post is no longer available on X.)









This "Listening Session" reveals itself to be what it truly is: NRA propaganda for guns, guns, and more guns.

I'm a teacher and if they put guns in my school I'm out. Every other teacher I know is out. Parents will pull kids out. It's FUCKING INSANE. #GunControlNow #NeverAgain

— liz murdock (@mizmurdock) February 21, 2018

(This post is no longer available on X.)



So you add even more responsibility to teachers who you already refuse to pay? I’m a teacher DAMN YOU

— Rb (@LethalBro2) February 22, 2018

(This post is no longer available on X.)











I’m a teacher and I’ll be honest. I’m a f***ing awful shot, especially with a handgun. But beyond that: I don’t want any sort of firearms in my classroom, or in my school. It’s f***ing insane.

— Drew (@DruSM157) February 21, 2018

(This post is no longer available on X.)



"I'm a teacher not a cop, damn it! I can't even focus the projector!" pic.twitter.com/8RO9tKXgKY

— Rogue White House Pizza Rat ❄🌊 (@unrealReg) February 22, 2018

(This post is no longer available on X.)

What a national poll of teachers found

The social media reaction was not a loud minority. In March 2018 Gallup surveyed 497 US teachers from kindergarten to 12th grade, just weeks after Parkland. It found that:

  • 73% opposed training teachers and staff to carry guns in school, while 20% supported the idea.
  • 58% thought arming staff would make schools less safe; only 20% thought it would make them safer.
  • 71% believed it would not be effective at limiting casualties in a shooting.
  • Just 18% said they would be willing to train and carry a gun at school if allowed.

Roughly a quarter of the teachers surveyed owned a gun, and owners were far more likely than others to say they would carry, but even among owners the idea was not widely popular. The wider public was more divided: Gallup found 42% of American adults supported arming school staff, the only proposal in its survey that failed to win majority support.

Does arming staff make schools safer?

Supporters argue that an armed adult on site could stop an attack in the minutes before police arrive, and some rural districts far from police stations already allowed trained staff to carry before 2018. Critics point to the risks of accidental discharge, guns left unsecured, students taking weapons, and armed staff being mistaken for attackers by responding officers.

The research base on arming teachers specifically is thin, because few schools have done it and serious attacks are, thankfully, rare at any one school. Researchers who review gun-policy studies have generally rated the evidence on this question as limited or inconclusive, which means neither side can claim a clear proof. What can be measured is how teachers feel about it, and the Gallup numbers show most of them do not want to be the last line of defence.

What happened after 2018

Florida passed the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School Public Safety Act in March 2018. It raised the minimum age for buying rifles to 21, added waiting periods, banned bump stocks and put around $400 million into school safety and mental health. It also created a voluntary programme allowing some trained school employees to carry guns; the original version largely excluded classroom teachers, and in 2019 the state widened it so that teachers in participating districts could volunteer.

Elsewhere, Parkland students led the March for Our Lives on 24 March 2018, one of the largest youth protests in US history. Several other states have since passed laws allowing trained staff to be armed, while most districts nationwide still do not take part. The debate continues, but the message teachers sent in February 2018 remains clear: most of them want safer schools through other means, not a gun in the desk drawer.

Sources: Gallup: Teachers oppose carrying guns in schools (March 2018); Wikipedia: Stoneman Douglas High School shooting; Education Week (February 2018); originally reported by HuffPost; posts embedded from X (Twitter), credited to their authors.

COMMENTS