How People Answered Trump's 'Shithole Countries' Remark on Twitter

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-01-21.

Responses to Trump's 2018 Remarks About Countries

In January 2018, newspapers reported that Donald Trump, then US president, had asked lawmakers at a White House meeting on immigration why the United States was accepting people from "shithole countries", a phrase he was said to have used about Haiti, El Salvador and nations in Africa. Within hours, people from those places and their children turned the insult into a hashtag. Doctors, students, journalists and engineers posted photos of themselves with short lists of their degrees, languages and jobs, each ending with a variation on "I'm from a #ShitHole country".

The replies spread across Twitter and were collected by sites such as BuzzFeed, Mashable and Bored Panda. Below are twenty of them, mostly posted on 12 and 13 January 2018, with a note on who wrote each and what it says. They are individual voices, not a survey of whole countries, and nobody needs a long list of degrees to deserve respect. But together they show how a single dismissive word met a flood of specific, human answers.

What Trump was reported to have said

The meeting took place on 11 January 2018 with a group of senators discussing a bipartisan deal on DACA, the programme protecting people brought to the US as children, and on Temporary Protected Status for countries such as Haiti and El Salvador. The Washington Post first reported the remark, and Democratic Senator Dick Durbin, who was present, said publicly that Trump had used the word. Trump was also reported to have said the US should take more people from places like Norway.

The next day Trump tweeted that his language at the meeting had been tough, "but this was not the language used." Some Republicans present said they did not recall the phrase. Nearly eight years later, at a rally in Pennsylvania in December 2025, Trump described the same meeting and effectively confirmed using the expression.

The reaction abroad was swift. A spokesman for the UN human rights office, Rupert Colville, called the comments racist. The African Union said it was frankly alarmed, Haiti's government condemned the remarks, El Salvador sent a formal letter of protest, and South Africa's governing ANC called them extremely offensive.

Doctors, nurses and medical students

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

The tweet that set the pattern came from AF_ROdisiac, a medical student who showed a South Sudanese flag. She listed three degrees, three languages, published work in psycho-oncology and membership of the Zeta Phi Beta sorority. With more than 265,000 likes, it was one of the most shared replies and inspired many of the posts that followed.

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

Lotanna Ike, tanna_bby, posted under a Nigerian flag. A medical student with three degrees and two more under way, she spoke four languages and said she had helped raise tens of thousands of dollars for her community.

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

Not every answer came from a recent immigrant. ckiser619, a medical professional, said he was half South African, had grown up on the streets and had delivered babies and comforted families after a death. His father, he wrote, came from one of the countries in question, a reminder that the remark also landed on Americans with immigrant parents.

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

Nursing student Marvinmolina007 posted a selfie in hospital scrubs. He described himself as bilingual and an honours student, and ended with a pointed twist on Trump's slogan: people like him, he wrote, are the ones who make America great.

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

ogpdub, also with a Nigerian flag, shared a photo in a white coat and another at a formal event. A medical student with three degrees, he added that he had once played basketball professionally.

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

Replying to the original thread, balangchuol, from South Sudan, said she was heading for a career in medicine, could read and write in two languages and sat on the board of a non-profit she was founding. She also called herself a humanitarian and said first-generation children have her heart.

Journalists, writers and broadcasters

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

Takalani Sioga, TakalaniSioga, tweeted from Pretoria with a South African flag. A postgraduate student in journalism and media studies, he listed three degrees, six languages, a 2018 Hazelhurst fellowship and a merit award. His post drew more than 26,000 likes.

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

Sarafina, MissLokonobei, shared photos from a TV studio. The first of her family to come to the US and the first to finish college, she was co-president of the National Association of Black Journalists chapter at California State University, Long Beach, and planned a career in broadcasting.

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

Adhel, adheljok, a student at the University of Iowa with South Sudanese roots, posted a collage that included her draped in South Sudan's flag. She was a mentor, a former reporter for the Daily Iowan, president of the African Student Association and a member of the South Sudanese Youth Congress, and about to become a college graduate.

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

Yrbenka Arthus, YourBankAccount, a Haitian immigrant, worked as a publicist at BuzzFeed. Her photo in a swimsuit in a sunny garden and her line about having purpose and influence made it one of the more confident replies, with about 13,700 likes.

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

Afrodite, Folabomi_Olu, posted under a Nigerian flag. She described herself as a future neuroscientist, a TEDx speaker, a dancer, singer and writer, and halfway through her first degree.

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

Guyé, Guyefurula, a first-generation Sudanese American, said she would be the first of six children in her family to graduate from college. A content creator who speaks several languages, she hoped to become a businesswoman and talk-show host.

Students, advocates and researchers

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

Nyaliep, nyapapiya, answered with a row of South Sudanese flags. A mother and student aiming to become a clinical psychologist, she led a youth organisation and was certified as a peer-support and mental-health specialist.

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

Hamdia Ahmed grew up in a refugee camp and came to the US as a child; she posted a photo of herself speaking at the United Nations next to images from a protest. A college student, social-justice activist and aspiring model, she added a Somali flag to her post.

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

Rebecca, latte_lado, was still a high-school senior. She mentored other students, had co-founded a Black student organisation and expected to finish an associate degree in science together with her high-school diploma. Her flag was South Sudan's, and her goal was medicine.

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

lydiaosh, who described herself as half Nigerian and half Kenyan, posted text only. An honours student with a 3.8 grade point average and a research assistant job, she was preparing to apply for doctoral programmes in clinical psychology and said she was proud of where she came from.

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

Zaneta, ZanetaGAdme, the daughter of a Haitian immigrant, was a civil engineer and PhD candidate with a master's in economics. She taught microeconomics and mathematics at a university, had published research and homeschooled her nieces and nephew.

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

Amma, Ammazingg_, posted with a Ghanaian flag. A first-generation student about to receive her bachelor's degree, she planned a master's in counselling and a career as a school counsellor, and described herself as a writer and education advocate.

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

Yasmine, THEGREATJaZZ, said she had graduated at 21 with two bachelor's degrees in three years, was training as a hearing specialist and hoped to become a lawyer. Her father, she wrote, had served as a deputy foreign minister of the Republic of South Sudan, and she ended by saying her country was producing generations of greatness.

A historian's reply

People Respond To Trump 's***hole Countries' Remark. Take A Look At Their Powerful Tweets!

CNN commentator and author John Avlon pointed out that 11 January was the birthday of Alexander Hamilton, the immigrant from the Caribbean island of Nevis who became one of America's founders. Hamilton was born in Charlestown, Nevis, in 1755 or 1757, grew up poor and orphaned, and went on to become the first US Treasury secretary. Avlon's joke drew more than 44,000 likes.

What the replies tell us

Many of the people above traced their roots to South Sudan, Nigeria, Haiti and Ghana. That fits a pattern that studies based on US census data have reported for years: African immigrants are, on average, at least as likely as US-born adults to hold a university degree, and Nigerian Americans are often described as one of the most highly educated groups in the country.

Still, the most useful lesson is not that every immigrant is a high achiever. It is that a country is made of individual people, each with a story, and that a whole nation, or a whole continent, cannot be summed up with one crude word. The hashtag worked because it replaced a slur with names, faces and specifics.

Sources: Al Jazeera, 12 January 2018; CNN via KVIA, 10 December 2025; tweets as linked in each caption, first collected by BuzzFeed, Mashable and Bored Panda.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1