Norway's 2017 Vote to Decriminalise Drug Use and What Followed

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-01-21.

Norway's Parliament Has Voted For The Decriminalization Of All Drugs

In December 2017 a majority in Norway's parliament, the Storting, backed a change of direction in drug policy: people caught using drugs or holding small amounts for their own use should be offered help and treatment instead of fines and prison. It was a political instruction to the government, not a new law, and it did not legalise any drug. The bill that eventually followed was voted down in April 2021. Even so, Norwegian practice has since moved a long way towards treating dependence as a health problem.

Here is what the 2017 decision said, why Portugal was the model everyone mentioned, what went wrong for the reform, and where things stand.

What Norway's parliament actually decided

The move came out of the Storting's health committee, and the news was reported internationally in mid-December 2017. Parties from both the governing centre-right and the opposition supported the principle. Press reports at the time listed the Conservatives (Høyre), the Liberals (Venstre), the Labour Party (Arbeiderpartiet) and the Socialist Left (SV) among the backers, and parliament directed the government to prepare a reform.

The committee's deputy chairman, Sveinung Stensland of the Conservatives, made the limits clear in an interview with the Norwegian newspaper VG: "It is important to emphasize that we do not legalize cannabis and other drugs, but we decriminalize." Making, importing and selling drugs would stay crimes. What would change was the response to the user.

That distinction is the key to reading the many headlines that claimed Norway had "decriminalised all drugs" overnight. Nothing changed for drug users on the day of the vote; the government was simply asked to design a new system.

Decriminalisation, legalisation and treatment: the difference

These three words are often mixed up, so it helps to separate them:

  • Legalisation means a drug can be produced and sold legally under rules, as with alcohol or, in some countries, cannabis.
  • Decriminalisation means using or possessing a small amount stays forbidden, but it is no longer a criminal offence. It may be handled by an administrative body, a fine or a referral, without a criminal record.
  • Diversion to treatment means people still pass through the justice system, but courts can send them to treatment instead of prison.

Norway in 2017 was talking about the second option, building on years of experience with the third.

Norway's earlier experiments

The 2017 vote did not come out of nowhere. Newsweek reported at the time that Norway had trialled drug-treatment courts in Oslo and Bergen from 2006, where people convicted of drug-related crimes could be sentenced to a supervised programme rather than jail. Around 2016 courts across the country were given the option of using these programmes. The idea was to break the cycle of addiction and reoffending, while still sending people back to prison if they abandoned the terms.

Norway also had a pressing reason to look again. For years it reported one of the higher rates of drug-induced deaths in Western Europe, mostly linked to opioids, and many health workers argued that the fear of prosecution kept people from seeking help.

Why everyone pointed to Portugal

Portugal changed course with Law 30/2000, which took effect in July 2001. Since then, possession of up to roughly a ten-day personal supply of any drug has been an administrative offence rather than a crime. People caught are referred to a "dissuasion commission" in their district, a panel that typically includes a social worker, a psychiatrist and a lawyer. The commission can encourage treatment, impose sanctions or community service, or close the case; most cases end without a penalty.

The reform was introduced against a grim background: heroin use was widespread and Portugal had a high rate of drug-related HIV infection. In the years that followed, new HIV diagnoses among people who inject drugs fell sharply, and drug-related deaths dropped from 131 in 2001 to 20 in 2008, according to figures summarised on Wikipedia. The predicted surge in drug tourism did not happen, a point the writer Glenn Greenwald stressed in his 2009 report for the Cato Institute.

It is fair to add that the picture is not frozen. Overdose deaths in Portugal rose again in the late 2010s, and the treatment system was reorganised and reportedly squeezed after the 2008 financial crisis. Researchers broadly agree that decriminalisation worked in Portugal because it came with investment in treatment, harm reduction and social support, not on its own.

What happened to the Norwegian reform

After the 2017 decision the government set up a reform committee in 2018, which delivered its proposals at the end of 2019. A bill followed in early 2021. It would have removed criminal penalties for using and holding small quantities of drugs, including cannabis, cocaine and heroin, while still expecting users to engage with health services.

The minority centre-right government needed support from the opposition. On 16 April 2021 Labour, which had backed the principle in 2017, refused. As reported by AFP, the party argued that the bill could encourage young people to experiment, and it preferred removing penalties only for people with serious drug dependence. The reform fell.

The story did not end there. In 2021 and 2022, following Supreme Court rulings, Norway's prosecution authorities issued guidelines under which people with drug dependence are, in general, no longer punished for using, buying or holding small amounts for their own use, and police powers to search phones or homes in such minor cases were restricted. In practice, part of what the 2017 vote asked for has come about through the courts rather than through a new law.

Common myths about drug decriminalisation

"Decriminalisation means drugs are legal." It does not. Selling and trafficking stay crimes, and possession remains prohibited, only handled outside criminal courts.

"Use always explodes afterwards." Portugal's experience did not show the large rise opponents predicted, although results vary between countries and depend heavily on the treatment system behind the law.

"It is a soft option that does nothing." Supporters see it as a way to get people to services earlier and to stop criminal records from blocking jobs and housing. Critics worry about mixed messages to young people. Both concerns shaped the Norwegian debate.

If you or someone close to you is struggling with drug use, talk to a doctor or a local support service; help works best when it starts early.

Sources: UNGASS on Drugs, 15 December 2017; UNGASS on Drugs (AFP), 16 April 2021; Wikipedia: Cannabis in Norway; Wikipedia: Drug policy of Portugal; The Mind Unleashed.

COMMENTS